On Wed, 2002-12-18 at 17:52, nate wrote:
> I have even had hardware raid 10 (3ware 6800 series) take down a system when
> a disk(1 out of 6) dies. That happened everytime a disk failed. system
> would immediately kernel panic.

Yep!  I've had SUN HW RAID Arrays Fail, and NetApp Hardware Raid Arrays
Fail, and Dell Perc3 HW RAID Arrays Fail when disks that had died were 
being removed and/or replaced....  (not that another disk died before
rebuild, but that the system hardware crashed and had to be power
cycled)  So it isn't just IDE Hardware...


> I would not trust software raid on a system that seems to be as "vital"
> as yours seems to be. go with a hardware SCSI raid controller with SCA
> hotswap drives. I have had more then 30 IDE disk failures in the past couple
> of years, my SCSI disk failures have been a fraction, 1 or 2 drives. I have
> had about twice as many IDE disks in use as SCSI.
> 

I have had plenty of both IDE and SCSI disks fail, but lately it seems
to be every darn'd HP SCSI disk that is failing...  I haven't kept any
statistics, but just off the top of my head I would say that neither
SCSI disks, nor IDE disks are particularly trustworthy.  


> and absolutely, under no circumstances rely on IDE for such storage, it
> is so incredibly unreliable it's sick, even with RAID. the reliability of
> IDE disks has gone down the toilet in the past 2 years.
> 

Really?  I haven't had the fun of playing with any IDE HW Raid devices..
But do you have LOTS of experiences with this?  Or is it just a few cases?
I am curious because I am considering purchasing some Promise HW IDE
RAID arrays that have SCSI Host Interfaces?  They just seem so damn cheap.



-- 
redhat-list mailing list
unsubscribe mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?subject=unsubscribe
https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list

Reply via email to