The power factor case is "semantically" different than the SWR case in the 
following way: With SWR, energy is flowing in both directions at near the speed 
of light.  If the reflected signal is the exact same frequency as the forward 
signal (as in the case where it is a reflection of a signal at a particular 
frequency, then there will be points along the line where the forward and 
reflects will be in phase and point along the line where they will be out of 
phase.  SWR is a ratio of the max voltage to the min voltage.  If there is no 
reflection, there is nothing to add or subtract, and so the max and min voltage 
will be the same.  The ratio (SWR) is therefore 1:1.  If all energy is 
reflected, the minimum will be zero, so that ratio of the max to the min will 
be infinite.

Now if I simultaneously measure a power line at 10 different point in a mile, I 
would detect no significant difference in power factor between the points.  
This is because the voltage anywhere on the wire is the same (san some IR 
drop), and the current into one end in the same as the current flowing out the 
other end.  Therefore, the angle between the voltage and current waveforms wil 
be the same all aong the run.

...Well, not exactly:

60 Hz has a period of 16.7ms.  On quarter wavelength is roughly where 
transmission line effects become significant.  One quarter of a period is at 
60Hz is 4.17ms.  If c=2.98x10^8 meters per second, it would travel 1241.7km in 
a quarter cycle.  (Actually, it is slightly less due to the relative delectric 
constant of air being slightly higher than that of a vacuum.)  If the distance 
between the source and the load is significantly less than this, no significant 
steady-state effects will be observable.  (Transient effects such as spikes 
could be seen if a power line broke in a windstorm.)

If I were to measure our power line at points much further apart (say thoudands 
of miles) we could indeed measure a difference because what happens is 
sufficiently delayed with respect the other points.  Thus the adjective 
"semantically".  When we talk about power factor the tacit assumption is that 
the same voltage exists at all locatons of the wires and that the current in 
equals the current out (i.e. that we are talking about distances much much 
smaller than a quarter wavelength).  When we talk about SWR (or more correctly 
VSWR) we tacitly assume we are talking about transmission lines of the order of 
or longer than a quarter wavelength.

Jeff Condit

Reply via email to