On May 9, 2006, at 10:21 PM, Matt Raible wrote:
Hmmm... I think we should consider that for 2.4. However, I don't
like the idea of introducing another comment form macro. We already
have two (regular and twisty-style) and we should really have just
one. Can we change the existing comment form macro to make it CSS
compliant/friendly instead?
Yes. We can certainly do this. However, it might be somewhat tedious
to make sure it works across all the themes.
It would definitely be an improvement. Many of the themes have no
styling around the comment form and fields at all, so we'd probably
only have to make corrections the couple nice themes that we have.
And, maintaining multiple comment forms is going to be more tedious
in the long run.
Should I enter a bug for
it? It'd be nice to figure out a fix for the twisty-style comments as
well, but I'm also open to bagging it altogether since it doesn't work
with the authenticators (unless we can call them using XHR).
I removed twisty comments from the themes last year when we ran into
problems with it, so I'm certainly not opposed to dropping it.
- Dave
