Re: [ccp4bb] Protein Crystallography challenges Standard Model precision

2014-07-23 Thread Bernhard Rupp
Although Zby's remarks re precision are beyond my original bewilderment about listed zepto-meter range digits (sans precision measure), I wonder whether the argument that we have so many data and thus a quite high precision (n.b. not accuracy) can be attained, is perhaps somewhat optimistic. What

[ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Bernhard Rupp
Hi Fellows, something that may eventually become an issue for validation and reporting in PDB headers: using the Refmac grouped occupancy keyword I was able to form and refine various networks of correlated alternate conformations - it seems to works really well at least in a 1.6 and 1.2

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Robbie Joosten
Hi Bernhard, The validation of alternates is indeed quite poor and any improvements would probably depend on proper annotation by the depositor, particularly in complex correlated cases. For your model I would probably make the two waters alternates of each other. That way, it is easier to

Re: [ccp4bb] Off-Topic Q / X Ray FLuoresence Scan Vs XANES

2014-07-23 Thread Dworkowski Florian
Dear Tarek There are several things to consider: 1-At an MX beamline the X-ray fluorescence (XRF) scans are usually used to define good energies for measurement of anomalous data. While XANES and XRF in general are similar techniques, they are used for very different applications. This said,

Re: [ccp4bb] protein crystals?

2014-07-23 Thread Evgeny Osipov
Dear Atul, I suggest to run SDS-PAGE with your crystals. You can even use micro-crystalline precipitate that you probably have from optimization stage. May be protein dissociated into subunits in the crystallization conditions. But I am not sure because I know nothing about your protein.

Re: [ccp4bb] ICCBM15 workshop completely full / overbooked

2014-07-23 Thread mesters
As far as the *ICCBM15 pre-conference workshop* is concerned (consisting of short presentations, practical demonstrations and hands-on exercises taught by an international team of experts), the workshop is already completely overbooked. Students, postdocs and scientists interested in the

[ccp4bb] CCP4-6.4.0 Update 020

2014-07-23 Thread Andrey Lebedev
Dear CCP4 Users An update for the CCP4-6.4.0 series has just been released, consisting of the following changes • crank: – bug fix in bp3 – update to overcome OMP problem • ctruncate: – update to 1.15.9 • aimless: – update to 0.3.7 • pointless: – update to 1.9.11 – fix for

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Bernhard Rupp
I would probably make the two waters alternates of each other. Quite possible, but the group definition, i.e. to which alt conf. side chain they belong, would need to be preserved, too. BR Cheers, Robbie Sent from my Windows Phone _ Van: Bernhard Rupp Verzonden:

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Tim Gruene
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hi Bernhard, do you refer to the PDB who, according to Martyn, remove the altloc indicator? That's certainly a serious bug that should be fixed as quickly as possible. Within refmac the preservation is fine and as you would expect it to be: altA

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Bernhard Rupp
?? Refmac knows because of the group definition, otherwise I cannot force grouped occupancy refinement. There is no definition in PDB that eg ALTLOC A (of whatever residue) belongs to ALTLOC A of (whatever) residue/water. BR -Original Message- From: Tim Gruene

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Tim Gruene
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hi Bernhard, That's right, the definition is not in the PDB, but REFMAC sensibly handles it this way. It is certainly a short-coming if not bug in the PDB (definition). Best, Tim On 07/23/2014 04:49 PM, Bernhard Rupp wrote: ?? Refmac knows because

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Frances C. Bernstein
I agree that it would be excellent to be able to associate alternate conformations (beyond the individual residue) but when we defined the PDB format we had an 80-column limitation per atom and so only one column was allowed for alternate conformations. In an ASCII world only 36 characters were

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Nat Echols
On Wed, Jul 23, 2014 at 3:25 AM, MARTYN SYMMONS martainn_oshioma...@btinternet.com wrote: The practice at the PDB after deposition used to be to remove water alternate position indicators - although obviously to keep their partial occupancies. This has not been my experience - see for

[ccp4bb] AW: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Herman . Schreuder
One could check if the alternate conformations are part of a continuous alternate zone or if they make contact (no contact, no association). However, I think it is time to abandon the PDB format and move to cif or some other format. My 2 cents, Herman -Ursprüngliche Nachricht- Von:

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Zbyszek Otwinowski
An additional problem is existence of alternative conformations close to rotational axis that violate crystal symmetry. If we want to describe such correlated alternative configurations, we need to describe also how they transform by such rotational axis. This problems may also exists also for

[ccp4bb] Accuracy and precision of unit cell parameters

2014-07-23 Thread Jrh
Dear Colleagues, Stimulated by Bernhard's posting, and whilst certainly beyond his sense of bewilderment, I recalled that there were studies on this issue. These are neatly summarised in the Topical review :- http://dx.doi.org/10.1107/S01087681269X By Frank Herbstein in Acta Cryst B I

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread MARTYN SYMMONS
I think there has been historically some glitch in the deposition of some refmac altloc waters So for example 4a9x from Buster is annotated correctly REMARK 3 PROGRAM : BUSTER 2.11.2 HETATM 9407 O HOH A2517 -22.429 1.144 -35.218 1.00 29.73 O HETATM 9408 O AHOH

Re: [ccp4bb] Protein Crystallography challenges Standard Model precision

2014-07-23 Thread James Holton
Where is it written that compactness of representation and accuracy/precision are the same thing? Is 1/3 more or less precise than 0.333 ? If mmCIF were a binary floating-point format file, there would be more decimal places in the precision of the stored value for the unit cell, despite

Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread George Sheldrick
Dear Frances, I don't think that you can put the blame entirely on the 80 column limitation. The program SHELX76 was limited to 80 columns because the input came as punched cards. It introduced a simple concept, the /free variables/, that are frequently used to represent occupancies and can

Re: [ccp4bb] Protein Crystallography challenges Standard Model precision

2014-07-23 Thread Bernhard Rupp
The representation is simply non-parsimonious. There is no meaning to the zepto-meter digits. Numquam ponenda est pluralitas sine necessitate. BR From: James Holton [mailto:jmhol...@lbl.gov] Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2014 9:58 PM To: b...@hofkristallamt.org; CCP4BB@JISCMAIL.AC.UK Subject:

Re: [ccp4bb] AW: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread Bernhard Rupp
An ad hoc kludge that is admittedly undesirable but at least does not break anything with the PDB format could be as was done e.g. with the TLS and NCS records - put the alternate group definitions into a REMARK record... Best, BR -Original Message- From: CCP4 bulletin board

Re: [ccp4bb] Protein Crystallography challenges Standard Model precision

2014-07-23 Thread Sampson, Jared
Greetings all - My interest in the rest of the discussion of experimental precision and error notwithstanding, and at the risk of stating explicitly what some might consider obvious, it seems to me that no one has actually (intentionally) asserted that they have determined the unit cell to

[ccp4bb] Post-doctoral position in Singapore at the Duke-NUS is available

2014-07-23 Thread Sheemei Lok
Post-doctoral position in Singapore at the Duke-NUS is available A post-doctoral position is available at the laboratory of Shee-Mei Lok (http://www.loksheemeilab.com) in the emerging infectious disease program of the Duke-NUS. Duke-NUS graduate medical school situated in Singapore, is a global

[ccp4bb] Betreff: Re: [ccp4bb] correlated alternate confs - validation?

2014-07-23 Thread dusan turk
Hello, A solution exists also for PDB records: As a consequence of a discussion with George which took place years ago, I have taken the liberty to extend the PDB record length of 80 characters and use additional characters to specify the group ID and their members list number and provided

[ccp4bb] moleman2 install problem

2014-07-23 Thread Yamei Yu
Hi all, I’m trying to install a copy of moleman2 for my new Mac. (the version is 10.9.3). while I copy the osx_moleman2 from xutil directory I got the following message: The Finder can’t complete the operation because some data in “osx_moleman2” can’t be read or written. (Error code -36)