Hello,
Answer a little late;
During this HOT activation, I have done some damage assessment,
digitization and image search with the HOT coordination team.
For damage assessment, the OSM community was not prepared for this
and we had a lot of work digitizing over a wide area .
Provide the basic d
Id=ACT-466
Pierre
De : "Banick, Robert"
À : Dan S
Cc : Clay impact ;
"hot@openstreetmap.org"
Envoyé le : Mardi 18 février 2014 10h42
Objet : Re: [HOT] Interim Report: Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda) Damage Assessment
Hi Dan,
Thanks for
Hi Dan,
Thanks for this! We were disappointed to find the same thing -- the
correlation is just not there. I think we need to focus heavily on the
improvements in our recommendation section so we can nudge these numbers
towards something more reasonable, because at present it's just not good.
Bes
Hi Robert,
Thanks for pointing me to the raw data. I've run a crosstabulation
(matching up objects by their osm ID) and it seems to look like this:
nodamageddestroyed
no85 82 63
partial170 119 111
major 173
salut à tous
En lisant ces éléments, je me rends compte des difficultés que nous
rencontrons dans nos missions d'activation. En fait pour moi, tout le
problème réside dans la capacité d'acquisition d'imagerie de bonne
résolution et récente. l'établissement/ réalisation de reports assez
précis, dép
Hi Dan,
There's a "download raw data" button on the side of the website at
americanredcross.github.io/OSM-Assessment. Feel free to download and play
with the data further -- and do contribute back anything new you find.
We're running more intensive stats analysis on the data now and will be
worki
Hi Robert,
Thanks for this. It's great to have some concrete analysis of what we
did, and the extent to which it's accurate.
Is there a full cross-tabulation available of the numbers for
building-osm-status vs building-true-status? In the report there's a
table of over/underrepresentation, and so
, February 13, 2014 9:14 AM
> To: "mikel_ma...@yahoo.com"
> Cc: Pierre Béland , Robert Banick <
> robert.ban...@redcross.org>, "hot@openstreetmap.org" <
> hot@openstreetmap.org>, Clay impact ,
> "Kunce, Dale"
> Subject: Re: [HOT] Interim R
@Robert
I would be happy to contribute. We have done a lot of research and actually
have an App (very early stages) as a WIP.
What is the best way to contribute that would be meaningful.
Regards
Mark Cupitt
"If we change the world, let it bear the mark of our intelligence"
See me on LinkedIn
ailto:hot@openstreetmap.org>>, Clay impact
mailto:clay.westr...@impact-initiatives.org>>,
"Kunce, Dale" mailto:dale.ku...@redcross.org>>
Subject: Re: [HOT] Interim Report: Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda) Damage Assessment
@Pierre and Mikel,
Your comments are well received.
t; in damage assesment was the imagery that seemed to show undamaged buildings
> when in reality they had sustained damage. But this is not reflected in the
> Executive summary and in the Conclusion of the study. This study should be
> completed with a better analysis of the type of imag
ss study points to the fact that in most cases the limitation
> in damage assesment was the imagery that seemed to show undamaged buildings
> when in reality they had sustained damage. But this is not reflected in the
> Executive summary and in the Conclusion of the study. This study should b
stained damage. But this is not reflected in the Executive summary and in
the Conclusion of the study. This study should be completed with a better
analysis of the type of imagery necessary to make better asssesment studies.
>
>
>
>Pierre
>
>
>
>______________
e type of imagery necessary to make
> better asssesment studies.
>
>
> Pierre
>
> ________________
> De : "Banick, Robert"
> À : "hot@openstreetmap.org"
> Cc : Clay impact ; "Kunce, Dale"
>
> Envoyé le : Mercredi 12 f
is of the type of imagery necessary to make better asssesment studies.
Pierre
De : "Banick, Robert"
À : "hot@openstreetmap.org"
Cc : Clay impact ; "Kunce, Dale"
Envoyé le : Mercredi 12 février 2014 9h22
Objet : [HOT] Inte
Excellent Report, particularly in relation to the availability and
targeting decisions for Satellite Imagery. It is very difficult to map
something on a HOT activation if there is no imagery or it is covered by
Cloud.
Regards
Mark Cupitt
Regards
Mark Cupitt
"If we change the world, let it be
Thank you Red Cross and REACH, great work, a really useful review, we have a
lot to learn from it. In the coming months, we'll want to digest this and other
evaluations of the typhoon response, and process into concrete actions to
prepare HOT for future activations. I have some thoughts on what
Thank you Red Cross and REACH, great work, a really useful review, we have a
lot to learn from it. In the coming months, we'll want to digest this and other
evaluations of the typhoon response, and process into concrete actions to
prepare HOT for future activations. I have some thoughts on what
Thank you Red Cross and REACH, great work, a really useful review, we have a
lot to learn from it. In the coming months, we'll want to digest this and other
evaluations of the typhoon response, and process into concrete actions to
prepare HOT for future activations. I have some thoughts on what
Thank you Red Cross and REACH, great work, a really useful review, we have a
lot to learn from it. In the coming months, we'll want to digest this and other
evaluations of the typhoon response, and process into concrete actions to
prepare HOT for future activations. I have some thoughts on what
Here's Interim Assessment Report on the web:
http://americanredcross.github.io/OSM-Assessment/
Jonathan
http://bigfatfrog67.me
On 12/02/2014 14:22, Banick, Robert wrote:
Dear HOT Communuity,
The American Red Cross and the REACH Initiative are pleased to present
an interim assessment report
21 matches
Mail list logo
