[recoznet2] Report reveals physical abuse of young detainees in NSW

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
Report reveals physical abuse of young detainees in NSW centre Source: AAP | Published: Tuesday March 14, 2:20 PM A damning report into the causes of four riots at a NSW juvenile detention centre last year has revealed a culture of physical and verbal abuse of detainees by staff. The report u

[recoznet2] Fwd: Amnesty: Crunch time for children's human rights in Australia

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
Fwd: Issued today to Australian media from the International Secretariat of Amnesty International: News Service 048/00 AI INDEX: ASA 12/03/00 14 March 2000 Crunch time for children's human rights in Australia As Australia's Senators debate mandatory d

Re: [recoznet2] Conscience vote unlikely on mandatory sentencing

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
Graham, Here is an expanded list from one of this morning's articles: "Moderate number cruncher Mr Christopher Pyne confirmed in a statement that moderates would not support the Senate legislation. Mr Pyne did not return calls yesterday, nor did other Liberal dissidents. They include NSW member

Re: [recoznet2] Conscience vote unlikely on mandatory sentencing

2000-03-13 Thread Graham Young
Dear All,   A note on the ABC story, and lobbying Liberal MP's.   When dealing with the Liberal Party you should always bear in mind that its members effectively have the right to a conscience vote on every matter, even if they seldom see the need to exercise that right.   In the Labor Party

[recoznet2] HTML postings

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
Hi everyone, I have asked this before but people just seem to forget or not care - would you please not post in HTML to Recoznet2? Some people's email systems can't handle it and for ease of discussion, it is impossible to cut into to address specific points. There is no need for HTML unless i

[recoznet2] Local community doesn't accept Maralinga is safe

2000-03-13 Thread David Sjoberg
Local community doesn't accept Maralinga is safe The Maralinga Aboriginal community has disputed claims by the Federal Government about the safety of the former nuclear test site.The Industry Minister, Nick Michin, has declared the site safe, after the clean-up was completed two-weeks a

[recoznet2] River Torrens will be renamed

2000-03-13 Thread David Sjoberg
River Torrens will be renamed Adelaide City Council is moving to change the name of the River Torrens to the traditional Kaurna name of Karrawirraparri.Council last night voted to give several areas of the Parklands Kaurna names, including the Golf Links which will be known as Pilta-Wodl

[recoznet2] Conscience vote unlikely on mandatory sentencing

2000-03-13 Thread David Sjoberg
From ABC fon line     Conscience vote unlikely on mandatory sentencing The Prime Minister is under new pressure to allow a conscience vote on mandatory sentencing.The Senate could vote today on whether to repeal the laws in the Northern Territory and Western Australia.The Senate will resum

[recoznet2] SMH Editorial: Punishment on principle

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
The Sydney Morning Herald Editorial: Punishment on principle Date: 14/03/2000 THE division within the Senate committee on mandatory sentencing is a measure of how easily side issues can contaminate a question of principle. The minority report by the two Liberal senators, Helen Coonan and Marise

[recoznet2] Extract of Marise Payne's speech

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
http://www.smh.com.au/news/0003/14/text/features7.html Can we suffer this unjust law? This is an edited extract from Senator Marise Payne's speech to Federal Parliament yesterday. -- * Make the Hunger Site your homepage! http://www.thehungersite.com/index.html **

[recoznet2] Full Senate Report

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
http://www.aph.gov.au/senate/committee/legcon_ctte/mandatory/index.htm The full Senate Report on mandatory sentencing is available at the URL above. Trudy - -- * Make the Hunger Site your homepage! http://www.thehungersite.com/index.html *

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
I am forwarding Graham Young's message which bounced because it was too long. Please, everyone remember to remove the older parts of messages that are not needed for clarity. Trudy ** Karen, I am sorry that you feel that I was attacking you. That wasn't my = intentio

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Damien Short
Thanks to all for an interesting and insightful debate. I use this list to gain knowledge and understanding, and only wish I had more time to contribute. However, for my part I agree that an appology "will help reconciliation because it will acknowledge that how we live today came about beca

[recoznet2] Marise Payne

2000-03-13 Thread Graham Young
From what I have seen Marise Payne, a NSW Liberal Senator, a member of the Senate Committee, seems to have stuck her neck out against Mandatory Sentencing in the NT.   Given that the only hope of legislation on this getting through both houses of parliament lies with either Liberal or Nationa

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Claire O'Connor
Hello can someone tell me if it is possible to receive all mail from a list except one sender. I admire anyone who attempts to answer this sort of time consuming comment but when I get email sent from one person (and there seem to be more than 6 in one day), whose views and attitudes I am ful

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
Karen, You seem to have missed the point I was making. Whether or not it is a person you know or a group of people you don't is not what is relevant, but rather that 'sorry' is not an admission of guilt but an understanding of and empathy with suffering and grief. And if non-Aboriginal Australian

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame?

2000-03-13 Thread tdunlop
KAREN SAYS: In refernce to the above first para - to which you were talking about - he does not actually say that Tim. So you are interpreting it the way you want. He never actually got quoted as saying he doesn't believe in reconciliation.   Hi again Karen - you're right about t

Re: [recoznet2] Re: AAP: UN provides Australia with mandatory sentencing advice

2000-03-13 Thread Trudy and Rod Bray
Hello Heinz, Thanks for explaining that. Apparently, the government started lobbying almost immediately, just like they did with Jabiluka, so it is difficult to know what is going on. Unfortunately, I don't think any other UN body will be heeded by this government either. Trudy [EMAIL PROTECT

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Don Clark
Karen,   As I remember it you made clear statements that there was no racism in the laws of this land.  You made statements that the police are not racist.  You made other statements that a little research would have proven are quite the opposite of your statements.   Now you are saying that

Re: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Don Clark
Perhaps Karen you should study the histories and then you may know more than the basics?  A half read book is still a half read book.   Don   Don ClarkPresidentIndigenous Social Justice AssociationPO Box K555Haymarket  NSW  1240[EMAIL PROTECTED]   There can be no real reconciliation without s

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Glenn Murray
I'm sorry, but I have to agree with Graham. You have not hesitated to give your opinion on other things about which you don't have all the facts (no-one ever has all the facts), but when it came to a sticky question, you shielded yourself with an excuse. I empathise with your difficulty finding

RE: [recoznet2] Karen, Karen, Karen!

2000-03-13 Thread Glenn Murray
Hi again, Karen, Firstly, I agree with you that throwing knives isn't the answer, but I would definitely deny that I (amongst others, e.g., Trudy to mention but one) have been anything but frank and polite. I have been assertive (you may have noticed the exclamation marks every now and then), bu

RE: [recoznet2] Karen, Karen, Karen!

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
Sir, I am not on this site to start fights or whatever, I'm simply curious as to what is being said and discussed. I've raised a few of my own questions or thoughts on some matters. I expected to get some flak but certainly not as much of the very angry attitudes I have encountered. Plenty of kniv

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Glenn Murray
Exactly!!! And if we extrapolate a bit with that logic, would it be reasonable to assume that it is one's duty to be compassionate to those one knows and loves? Howard's refusal to apologise indicates that he doesn't know Australia's Aboriginal population, and he doesn't love them! Even genera

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
TIM SAYS:I can't believe he has the nerve to come out of a meeting and say, once again, that he's committed to reconciliation.  It's only a week ago on 3AW that he said: "What baffles me about this (reconciliation) issue is that I'm expected to repudiate my own personal beliefs; I'm told tha

RE: [recoznet2] Re: Karen

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
because I can - just like you! Remember that Freedom of Speech thingy!?!? All I simply said was that I did not wish to comment on something I did not know as much about as I would like to. So I get shot down for having an opinion and then I get shot down because I don't have an informed enough op

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
I was simply replying to your interpretation of my own personal experience. I'm not talking about revenge on a national scale as each situation is different. I was simply implying that by moving on my life is better. I have no need to forgive this person and I certainly would not reconcile. It's d

[recoznet2] Re: AAP: UN provides Australia with mandatory sentencing advice

2000-03-13 Thread hschurma
Trudy, this is the maximum than could be expected of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights under her mandate. They can't do on Australia what they couldn't also do on any other UN member state. For a case like this, other UN bodies have the necessary authority to level direct criti

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
The difference with your examples is that you are saying it to someone you know and love. Saying sorry to a race is entirely different - you say it to a group of people you could never know personally.   >The office of PM demands that he represent all Australians. The problem with John Howar

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Glenn Murray
Hi Karen, Once again, that's hardly reconciliation. Reconciliation is about doing our best to right the wrongs, not about perpetuating the "us & them". I'm sure someone else on this list will put it much more elegantly than I, but surely you can't think revenge should be considered the essence

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
In other words I will never forget what happened to me but the greatest revenge I can have to the person in question is to live my life to the fullest. Letting them know they did not destroy me!! Hmm, sweet revenge! -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTEC

RE: [recoznet2] has the man no shame!!!!!

2000-03-13 Thread Karen Crook
Graham says: If you don't know enough, then do us the courtesy of doing some research and finding out.   Karen says: Excuse me but you were the one to bring up this subject in the first place. I never once mentioned this topic. You mention it last night and when I reply with an honest ans