Re: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt

2007-03-11 Thread murali ramakrishnan
hai friends,

i dont think gv prakash is an ego person since he has strted giving 
interview just noe and sometimes we will forget to say important things 
which is common and who knows whether it has been edited by the tv people in 
order to make it short and sweet.

he is the son of rahmananna's sister and it is not rehaina and i came to 
know that prakash fly didnot converted to islam.

and whenever rahmananna asked about the maestro he has praised her 
wholeheartedly which is not seen in film industry and he has given full 
credit to raja sir that he was his main inspiration for his ddiscipline in 
work and in real life and being this much religious.

a true fact is MSV,RAJA and RAHMAN are very important and cannot be 
forgotten their works in the film music.

Salute the three Brahma's of music


From: rakesh venkatraman [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Reply-To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's 
interivew-he not told anything abt
Date: Tue, 6 Mar 2007 02:39:26 -0800 (PST)

from GV Prakash this has boiled down to IR n rahman..
guys grow up... 
--- Tapey3 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

  Influence is hard to see in hindsight.  IR brought
  village sounds to
  Tamil film music in a big way.  Before him it wasn't
  that common, but
  he brought a certain rusticness to many of his
  films.  Bharathiraja
  too brought that rusticness to his films,
  complemented by IR's music.
   And IR definitely did some interesting things with
  Western sounds,
  jazz, fusion, and strings.  A lot of his songs would
  fall into a
  monotonous and even predictable pattern but he has
  produced many
  amazing numbers.  Please do not expect any artist to
  do what an artist
  after him did.  That is like expecting Buddy Holly
  to have done what
  the Beatles did years later.
 
  --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, n_kumaar
  [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
  
   its ok if you talk about ar but plz stop comparing
  him to Illairaaja.
   If you want to know the reason try listening to
  tamil music from 50s
   till now and u will know the difference. stop
  degrading others. true
   ar fan won't do that. And bye the way ar's music
  is very much
   influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe
  me, listen first.
  
  
  
   --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Thulasi Ram
  karokelip@
   wrote:
   
yup... ARR is no way related to IR in musical
  terms except the fact
   that
both of them are musical directors. ARR's
  approach was 100% unique.
   he got
rid of some monotonic use of instruments that IR
  was constantly
   using
(according to me IT SUCKED BIG TIME  i hate
  them).. ARR gave a new
   touch
even to village woven story and songs.. take for
  example uzhavan,
   karuthama,
kizhaku seemaiylae, tajmahal... ARR's touch in
  any album is just
   extra
ordinary and brilliant; and most importantly NOT
  like the previous
   ageMD's..
   
remember the filmfare's encomiums on ARR: Every
  music director in
   this age
is definitely a clone of ARR.
and not the viceversa..
   
   
On 3/4/07, kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote:

   I am strongly opposing your comment.

 First main thing is, IR is not a relative for
  ARR. Second thing
   is,
 ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR
  doesnt know anybody in
 the industry other than IR initially.

 But GVP case is different, hes a close
  relative of ARR. do you
   know
 how many GVPs are there without getting a
  chance.

 GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs
  fame. Why shankar gave
 him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and
  additional thing is
   his
 relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,

 so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to
  ARR. Once shankar
 utilised him in his movie, then others started
  using him.

 i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes
  doing good. we have
   to
 wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss
  family.

 but our concern is, he should express his
  inspiration in the
 interview. i am once again saying hes here in
  the industry (200%)
 definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt
  expressed that in
   the
 interview. that was our disappointment.

 --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
  arrahmanfans%
   40yahoogroups.com, Sam
 samsinging@ wrote:
 
  This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants
  everyone to know that
   he
 is on his own and not because of his uncle.
 
  Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his
  inspiration in his
 interviews after Roja. So does that mean he
  doesn't respect IR?
 
  Stop this guys..
 
  Sam
 
 
 
  ruben mohan rubenamohan@ wrote:
  yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i
  alrdy knw
 he kind of ego personits because a lot of
  people comment that
 his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's

Re: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-06 Thread Gomtesh Upadhye

ar's music is very much
influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.


uh huh ! any refrences please?!


Gomzy


On 3/6/07, S, Karthik [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:


  ar's music is very much
influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.

I beg your pardon..What did you say?..Have you ever listened to them in
your life.

Your point that IR should not be dragged and belittled is well taken. No
dispute here, but what you did in later part of the mail is exactly like
shooting at the dark. Come on, went out your frustrations in a different
way. stop this.

bye
Karthik



From: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com on
behalf of n_kumaar
Sent: Mon 3/5/2007 1:08 PM
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com
Subject: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he
not told anything abt ARR

its ok if you talk about ar but plz stop comparing him to Illairaaja.
If you want to know the reason try listening to tamil music from 50s
till now and u will know the difference. stop degrading others. true
ar fan won't do that. And bye the way ar's music is very much
influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.commailto:
arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com , Thulasi Ram [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:

 yup... ARR is no way related to IR in musical terms except the fact
that
 both of them are musical directors. ARR's approach was 100% unique.
he got
 rid of some monotonic use of instruments that IR was constantly
using
 (according to me IT SUCKED BIG TIME  i hate them).. ARR gave a new
touch
 even to village woven story and songs.. take for example uzhavan,
karuthama,
 kizhaku seemaiylae, tajmahal... ARR's touch in any album is just
extra
 ordinary and brilliant; and most importantly NOT like the previous
ageMD's..

 remember the filmfare's encomiums on ARR: Every music director in
this age
 is definitely a clone of ARR.
 and not the viceversa..


 On 3/4/07, kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
  I am strongly opposing your comment.
 
  First main thing is, IR is not a relative for ARR. Second thing
is,
  ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR doesnt know anybody in
  the industry other than IR initially.
 
  But GVP case is different, hes a close relative of ARR. do you
know
  how many GVPs are there without getting a chance.
 
  GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs fame. Why shankar gave
  him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and additional thing is
his
  relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,
 
  so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to ARR. Once shankar
  utilised him in his movie, then others started using him.
 
  i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes doing good. we have
to
  wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss family.
 
  but our concern is, he should express his inspiration in the
  interview. i am once again saying hes here in the industry (200%)
  definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt expressed that in
the
  interview. that was our disappointment.
 
  --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.commailto:
arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%
40yahoogroups.com, Sam
  samsinging@ wrote:
  
   This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that
he
  is on his own and not because of his uncle.
  
   Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his
  interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR?
  
   Stop this guys..
  
   Sam
  
  
  
   ruben mohan rubenamohan@ wrote:
   yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw
  he kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that
  his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he
  wanted to be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of
  facts
  
   believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with
  their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down
  to earth
  
   lets see what GV can do...long way to go
  
   nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but
due
  to time limitation .
  
   ok bye
  
   kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote: Hi ARRFans,
  
   i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website.
  
   hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son.
  
   rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops
  and
   album as a chorus.
  
   she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
  
   that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss.
  not
   only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from
  our
   boss only.
  
   hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad.
  
   even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days
  itself. he
   (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
  
   but he never gave that respect to him.
  
   big talented people will grow high

[arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-05 Thread kannanmania
hi guys. i think some of the ur'll are over-reacting. GVP is a good 
man. He's young. Praise him for his work.   


--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sam [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that he 
is on his own and not because of his uncle.  

   Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his 
interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR? 

   Stop this guys..

   Sam

   
 
 ruben mohan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
   yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw he 
kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that his 
veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he wanted to 
be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of  facts
 
 believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with 
their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down to 
earth
 
 lets see what GV can do...long way to go
 
 nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but due 
to time limitation .
 
 ok bye
 
 kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:  Hi ARRFans,
 
 i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website. 
 
 hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son. 
 
 rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops 
and 
 album as a chorus. 
 
 she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
 
 that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss. 
not 
 only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from our 
 boss only.
 
 hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad. 
 
 even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days 
itself. he
 (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
 
 but he never gave that respect to him.
 
 big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness 
even 
 though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that only.
 
 but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for one 
 year. thats it.
 
 i am totally disappointed. i agree his Veyyil movie music is good.
 he has talent. but only thing is, he should express his true 
 inspiration in that interview.
 
 disappointed.
 
 Sivaraj
 
 
 
 
 
 -
   Need Mail bonding?
 Go to the Yahoo! Mail QA for great tips from Yahoo! Answers 
users.  
 
  
 
  
 -
 Never Miss an Email
 Stay connected with Yahoo! Mail on your mobile. Get started!





[arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-05 Thread jana_k3
This total topic seems wrong.  If you will only appreciate others 
with the assumption that they will be a boaster for someone you 
appreciate even more, then you can never be objective.  GVP is 19 
and seems like he has some talent.  And reading his interview, he 
seems hardworking and independent minded.  There is nothing wrong 
with that.  If he were out their using his uncle's name for work, 
and wasn't such a big hit, everyone would be bad-mouthing him in 
that way.  

Appreciate his work.  He doesn't need to always go around having a 
statement for others.  Same goes for ARR, or any other artist.  

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, kannanmania [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 hi guys. i think some of the ur'll are over-reacting. GVP is a 
good 
 man. He's young. Praise him for his work.   
 
 
 --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sam samsinging@ wrote:
 
  This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that 
he 
 is on his own and not because of his uncle.  
 
Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his 
 interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR? 
 
Stop this guys..
 
Sam
 

  
  ruben mohan rubenamohan@ wrote:
yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw 
he 
 kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that his 
 veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he wanted 
to 
 be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of  facts
  
  believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with 
 their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down 
to 
 earth
  
  lets see what GV can do...long way to go
  
  nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but 
due 
 to time limitation .
  
  ok bye
  
  kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote:  Hi ARRFans,
  
  i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website. 
  
  hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son. 
  
  rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops 
 and 
  album as a chorus. 
  
  she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
  
  that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss. 
 not 
  only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from 
our 
  boss only.
  
  hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad. 
  
  even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days 
 itself. he
  (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
  
  but he never gave that respect to him.
  
  big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness 
 even 
  though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that 
only.
  
  but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for 
one 
  year. thats it.
  
  i am totally disappointed. i agree his Veyyil movie music is 
good.
  he has talent. but only thing is, he should express his true 
  inspiration in that interview.
  
  disappointed.
  
  Sivaraj
  
  
  
  
  
  -
Need Mail bonding?
  Go to the Yahoo! Mail QA for great tips from Yahoo! Answers 
 users.  
  
   
  
   
  -
  Never Miss an Email
  Stay connected with Yahoo! Mail on your mobile. Get started!
 





[arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-05 Thread n_kumaar
its ok if you talk about ar but plz stop comparing him to Illairaaja. 
If you want to know the reason try listening to tamil music from 50s 
till now and u will know the difference. stop degrading others. true 
ar fan won't do that. And bye the way ar's music is very much 
influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.



--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Thulasi Ram [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 yup... ARR is no way related to IR in musical terms except the fact 
that
 both of them are musical directors. ARR's approach was 100% unique. 
he got
 rid of some monotonic use of instruments that IR was constantly 
using
 (according to me IT SUCKED BIG TIME  i hate them).. ARR gave a new 
touch
 even to village woven story and songs.. take for example uzhavan, 
karuthama,
 kizhaku seemaiylae, tajmahal... ARR's touch in any album is just 
extra
 ordinary and brilliant; and most importantly NOT like the previous 
ageMD's..
 
 remember the filmfare's encomiums on ARR: Every music director in 
this age
 is definitely a clone of ARR.
 and not the viceversa..
 
 
 On 3/4/07, kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
I am strongly opposing your comment.
 
  First main thing is, IR is not a relative for ARR. Second thing 
is,
  ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR doesnt know anybody in
  the industry other than IR initially.
 
  But GVP case is different, hes a close relative of ARR. do you 
know
  how many GVPs are there without getting a chance.
 
  GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs fame. Why shankar gave
  him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and additional thing is 
his
  relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,
 
  so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to ARR. Once shankar
  utilised him in his movie, then others started using him.
 
  i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes doing good. we have 
to
  wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss family.
 
  but our concern is, he should express his inspiration in the
  interview. i am once again saying hes here in the industry (200%)
  definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt expressed that in 
the
  interview. that was our disappointment.
 
  --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%
40yahoogroups.com, Sam
  samsinging@ wrote:
  
   This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that 
he
  is on his own and not because of his uncle.
  
   Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his
  interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR?
  
   Stop this guys..
  
   Sam
  
  
  
   ruben mohan rubenamohan@ wrote:
   yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw
  he kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that
  his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he
  wanted to be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of
  facts
  
   believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with
  their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down
  to earth
  
   lets see what GV can do...long way to go
  
   nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but 
due
  to time limitation .
  
   ok bye
  
   kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote: Hi ARRFans,
  
   i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website.
  
   hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son.
  
   rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops
  and
   album as a chorus.
  
   she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
  
   that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss.
  not
   only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from
  our
   boss only.
  
   hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad.
  
   even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days
  itself. he
   (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
  
   but he never gave that respect to him.
  
   big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness
  even
   though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that 
only.
  
   but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for
  one
   year. thats it.
  
   i am totally disappointed. i agree his Veyyil movie music is
  good.
   he has talent. but only thing is, he should express his true
   inspiration in that interview.
  
   disappointed.
  
   Sivaraj
  
  
  
  
  
   -
   Need Mail bonding?
   Go to the Yahoo! Mail QA for great tips from Yahoo! Answers
  users.
  
  
  
  
   -
   Never Miss an Email
   Stay connected with Yahoo! Mail on your mobile. Get started!
  
 
   
 





RE: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-05 Thread S, Karthik
ar's music is very much 
influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.
 
I beg your pardon..What did you say?..Have you ever listened to them in your 
life.
 
Your point that IR should not be dragged and belittled is well taken. No 
dispute here, but what you did in later part of the mail is exactly like 
shooting at the dark. Come on, went out your frustrations in a different way. 
stop this.
 
bye
Karthik



From: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com on behalf of n_kumaar
Sent: Mon 3/5/2007 1:08 PM
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not 
told anything abt ARR



its ok if you talk about ar but plz stop comparing him to Illairaaja. 
If you want to know the reason try listening to tamil music from 50s 
till now and u will know the difference. stop degrading others. true 
ar fan won't do that. And bye the way ar's music is very much 
influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com mailto:arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com , 
Thulasi Ram [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 yup... ARR is no way related to IR in musical terms except the fact 
that
 both of them are musical directors. ARR's approach was 100% unique. 
he got
 rid of some monotonic use of instruments that IR was constantly 
using
 (according to me IT SUCKED BIG TIME  i hate them).. ARR gave a new 
touch
 even to village woven story and songs.. take for example uzhavan, 
karuthama,
 kizhaku seemaiylae, tajmahal... ARR's touch in any album is just 
extra
 ordinary and brilliant; and most importantly NOT like the previous 
ageMD's..
 
 remember the filmfare's encomiums on ARR: Every music director in 
this age
 is definitely a clone of ARR.
 and not the viceversa..
 
 
 On 3/4/07, kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
  I am strongly opposing your comment.
 
  First main thing is, IR is not a relative for ARR. Second thing 
is,
  ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR doesnt know anybody in
  the industry other than IR initially.
 
  But GVP case is different, hes a close relative of ARR. do you 
know
  how many GVPs are there without getting a chance.
 
  GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs fame. Why shankar gave
  him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and additional thing is 
his
  relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,
 
  so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to ARR. Once shankar
  utilised him in his movie, then others started using him.
 
  i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes doing good. we have 
to
  wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss family.
 
  but our concern is, he should express his inspiration in the
  interview. i am once again saying hes here in the industry (200%)
  definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt expressed that in 
the
  interview. that was our disappointment.
 
  --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com mailto:arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com 
   arrahmanfans%
40yahoogroups.com, Sam
  samsinging@ wrote:
  
   This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that 
he
  is on his own and not because of his uncle.
  
   Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his
  interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR?
  
   Stop this guys..
  
   Sam
  
  
  
   ruben mohan rubenamohan@ wrote:
   yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw
  he kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that
  his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he
  wanted to be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of
  facts
  
   believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with
  their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down
  to earth
  
   lets see what GV can do...long way to go
  
   nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but 
due
  to time limitation .
  
   ok bye
  
   kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote: Hi ARRFans,
  
   i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website.
  
   hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son.
  
   rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops
  and
   album as a chorus.
  
   she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
  
   that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss.
  not
   only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from
  our
   boss only.
  
   hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad.
  
   even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days
  itself. he
   (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
  
   but he never gave that respect to him.
  
   big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness
  even
   though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that 
only.
  
   but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for
  one
   year. thats it.
  
   i am totally disappointed. i agree his Veyyil movie music

[arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt

2007-03-05 Thread Tapey3
Influence is hard to see in hindsight.  IR brought village sounds to
Tamil film music in a big way.  Before him it wasn't that common, but
he brought a certain rusticness to many of his films.  Bharathiraja
too brought that rusticness to his films, complemented by IR's music.
 And IR definitely did some interesting things with Western sounds,
jazz, fusion, and strings.  A lot of his songs would fall into a
monotonous and even predictable pattern but he has produced many
amazing numbers.  Please do not expect any artist to do what an artist
after him did.  That is like expecting Buddy Holly to have done what
the Beatles did years later.

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, n_kumaar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 its ok if you talk about ar but plz stop comparing him to Illairaaja. 
 If you want to know the reason try listening to tamil music from 50s 
 till now and u will know the difference. stop degrading others. true 
 ar fan won't do that. And bye the way ar's music is very much 
 influenced by Dr Alban and Maddonna. Don't believe me, listen first.
 
 
 
 --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Thulasi Ram karokelip@ 
 wrote:
 
  yup... ARR is no way related to IR in musical terms except the fact 
 that
  both of them are musical directors. ARR's approach was 100% unique. 
 he got
  rid of some monotonic use of instruments that IR was constantly 
 using
  (according to me IT SUCKED BIG TIME  i hate them).. ARR gave a new 
 touch
  even to village woven story and songs.. take for example uzhavan, 
 karuthama,
  kizhaku seemaiylae, tajmahal... ARR's touch in any album is just 
 extra
  ordinary and brilliant; and most importantly NOT like the previous 
 ageMD's..
  
  remember the filmfare's encomiums on ARR: Every music director in 
 this age
  is definitely a clone of ARR.
  and not the viceversa..
  
  
  On 3/4/07, kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote:
  
 I am strongly opposing your comment.
  
   First main thing is, IR is not a relative for ARR. Second thing 
 is,
   ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR doesnt know anybody in
   the industry other than IR initially.
  
   But GVP case is different, hes a close relative of ARR. do you 
 know
   how many GVPs are there without getting a chance.
  
   GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs fame. Why shankar gave
   him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and additional thing is 
 his
   relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,
  
   so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to ARR. Once shankar
   utilised him in his movie, then others started using him.
  
   i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes doing good. we have 
 to
   wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss family.
  
   but our concern is, he should express his inspiration in the
   interview. i am once again saying hes here in the industry (200%)
   definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt expressed that in 
 the
   interview. that was our disappointment.
  
   --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%
 40yahoogroups.com, Sam
   samsinging@ wrote:
   
This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that 
 he
   is on his own and not because of his uncle.
   
Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his
   interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR?
   
Stop this guys..
   
Sam
   
   
   
ruben mohan rubenamohan@ wrote:
yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw
   he kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that
   his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he
   wanted to be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of
   facts
   
believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with
   their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down
   to earth
   
lets see what GV can do...long way to go
   
nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but 
 due
   to time limitation .
   
ok bye
   
kanchi143 kanchi143@ wrote: Hi ARRFans,
   
i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website.
   
hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son.
   
rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops
   and
album as a chorus.
   
she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
   
that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss.
   not
only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from
   our
boss only.
   
hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad.
   
even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days
   itself. he
(ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
   
but he never gave that respect to him.
   
big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness
   even
though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that 
 only.
   
but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for
   one
year. thats it.
   

[arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-04 Thread kanchi143
I am strongly opposing your comment. 

First main thing is, IR is not a relative for ARR. Second thing is, 
ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR doesnt know anybody in 
the industry other than IR initially. 

But GVP case is different, hes a close relative of ARR. do you know 
how many GVPs are there without getting a chance. 

GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs fame. Why shankar gave 
him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and additional thing is his 
relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,

so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to ARR. Once shankar 
utilised him in his movie, then others started using him. 

i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes doing good. we have to 
wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss family. 

but our concern is, he should express his inspiration in the 
interview. i am once again saying hes here in the industry (200%)
definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt expressed that in the 
interview. that was our disappointment.


--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sam [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that he 
is on his own and not because of his uncle.  

   Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his 
interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR? 

   Stop this guys..

   Sam

   
 
 ruben mohan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
   yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw 
he kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that 
his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he 
wanted to be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of  
facts
 
 believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with 
their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down 
to earth
 
 lets see what GV can do...long way to go
 
 nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but due 
to time limitation .
 
 ok bye
 
 kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:  Hi ARRFans,
 
 i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website. 
 
 hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son. 
 
 rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops 
and 
 album as a chorus. 
 
 she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.
 
 that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss. 
not 
 only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from 
our 
 boss only.
 
 hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad. 
 
 even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days 
itself. he
 (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.
 
 but he never gave that respect to him.
 
 big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness 
even 
 though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that only.
 
 but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for 
one 
 year. thats it.
 
 i am totally disappointed. i agree his Veyyil movie music is 
good.
 he has talent. but only thing is, he should express his true 
 inspiration in that interview.
 
 disappointed.
 
 Sivaraj
 
 
 
 
 
 -
   Need Mail bonding?
 Go to the Yahoo! Mail QA for great tips from Yahoo! Answers 
users.  
 
  
 
  
 -
 Never Miss an Email
 Stay connected with Yahoo! Mail on your mobile. Get started!





Re: [arr] Re: disappointed after heard the GV Prakash's interivew-he not told anything abt ARR

2007-03-04 Thread Thulasi Ram

yup... ARR is no way related to IR in musical terms except the fact that
both of them are musical directors. ARR's approach was 100% unique. he got
rid of some monotonic use of instruments that IR was constantly using
(according to me IT SUCKED BIG TIME  i hate them).. ARR gave a new touch
even to village woven story and songs.. take for example uzhavan, karuthama,
kizhaku seemaiylae, tajmahal... ARR's touch in any album is just extra
ordinary and brilliant; and most importantly NOT like the previous ageMD's..

remember the filmfare's encomiums on ARR: Every music director in this age
is definitely a clone of ARR.
and not the viceversa..


On 3/4/07, kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:


  I am strongly opposing your comment.

First main thing is, IR is not a relative for ARR. Second thing is,
ARR came up his own talent and credits. ARR doesnt know anybody in
the industry other than IR initially.

But GVP case is different, hes a close relative of ARR. do you know
how many GVPs are there without getting a chance.

GVP cant entered in this field without ARRs fame. Why shankar gave
him a chance, bcos he knows GVP thru ARR and additional thing is his
relative. and he worked anniyan etc..,

so basically hes a known guy to shankar due to ARR. Once shankar
utilised him in his movie, then others started using him.

i am not saying GVP is bad or something, hes doing good. we have to
wish him to grow bcos hes from our boss family.

but our concern is, he should express his inspiration in the
interview. i am once again saying hes here in the industry (200%)
definetly due to inspiration of ARR. he didnt expressed that in the
interview. that was our disappointment.

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, Sam
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 This is utter nonsense. May be GVP wants everyone to know that he
is on his own and not because of his uncle.

 Even ARR did not mention Ilayaraja's as his inspiration in his
interviews after Roja. So does that mean he doesn't respect IR?

 Stop this guys..

 Sam



 ruben mohan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 yeah i 100% agree...in his first interview i alrdy knw
he kind of ego personits because a lot of people comment that
his veyil music have a touch of arrahman's styleso maybe he
wanted to be out of this comment ...so he giving this kind of
facts

 believe me this kind of ppl will not be too long in cinema with
their ego...GOD is there to judge...the higher u go u shld be down
to earth

 lets see what GV can do...long way to go

 nice post...thanks fr sharing...previously i wnted to post but due
to time limitation .

 ok bye

 kanchi143 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi ARRFans,

 i just heard the GV prakash interview in indiaglitz.com website.

 hes our boss sister (kanchana alias rehana) son.

 rehana is the sister of our boss and still singing in his troops
and
 album as a chorus.

 she composed one movie also called Machi of junior sivaji.

 that GV prakash should get inspiration(200% sure) from our boss.
not
 only him, most of the young directors will get inspiration from
our
 boss only.

 hes not at all expressing that in the interview. its too bad.

 even rahman introduced him as a singer in his childhood days
itself. he
 (ARR) would be first inspiration for him.

 but he never gave that respect to him.

 big talented people will grow high only due to their simpleness
even
 though they are very talented. rajini and ARR grown like that only.

 but this guy too much yaar. he told that he worked with ARR for
one
 year. thats it.

 i am totally disappointed. i agree his Veyyil movie music is
good.
 he has talent. but only thing is, he should express his true
 inspiration in that interview.

 disappointed.

 Sivaraj





 -
 Need Mail bonding?
 Go to the Yahoo! Mail QA for great tips from Yahoo! Answers
users.




 -
 Never Miss an Email
 Stay connected with Yahoo! Mail on your mobile. Get started!