Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
On 11/15/2008 10:10 AM India Time, _kamal hassan_ wrote: > Some of harris's songs are a copy of arr's songs itself. do u think he > deserves a praise from arr for copying his songs?? > > Suresh Whatever little I have heard of Harris, I feel that he is quite imaginative and is capable of conceiving and composing original music. Thus, the charge of him copying ARR's songs appears "odd" to me. Could be that he uses similar style, arrangments that ARR had brought into bollywood music, but was it really an outright copy? Could you give some examples of such copies? -- V > > --- On *Fri, 11/14/08, Nivedita R /<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>/* wrote: > > From: Nivedita R <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? > To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > Date: Friday, November 14, 2008, 10:16 PM > > Well said Vinu aryan!!! ! > > > > > --- On *Tue, 11/11/08, Vinu aryan //* wrote: > > From: Vinu aryan > Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > Date: Tuesday, November 11, 2008, 8:36 AM > > I am just posting my opinion and i know no one will reply u r > mail . The thing is Arr's Spine is very strong yaar it wont get > shiverred by a copy cat. Who uses songs from westlife ,blue etc > and one more thing is that a must to praise someone?? Just > think and judge urself the music of Arr and others u will get > the answer > > > > > > *From:* nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> > *To:* arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > *Sent:* Monday, November 10, 2008 11:02:30 PM > *Subject:* [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? > > i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of > arr and > have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read > anywhere > any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as > the rival? > does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send > shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur > opinions.
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
Some of harris's songs are a copy of arr's songs itself. do u think he deserves a praise from arr for copying his songs?? Suresh --- On Fri, 11/14/08, Nivedita R <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Nivedita R <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Friday, November 14, 2008, 10:16 PM Well said Vinu aryan!!! ! --- On Tue, 11/11/08, Vinu aryan wrote: From: Vinu aryan Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Tuesday, November 11, 2008, 8:36 AM I am just posting my opinion and i know no one will reply u r mail . The thing is Arr's Spine is very strong yaar it wont get shiverred by a copy cat. Who uses songs from westlife ,blue etc and one more thing is that a must to praise someone?? Just think and judge urself the music of Arr and others u will get the answer From: nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Monday, November 10, 2008 11:02:30 PM Subject: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as the rival? does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur opinions.
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
Well said Vinu aryan --- On Tue, 11/11/08, Vinu aryan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Vinu aryan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 11, 2008, 8:36 AM I am just posting my opinion and i know no one will reply u r mail . The thing is Arr's Spine is very strong yaar it wont get shiverred by a copy cat. Who uses songs from westlife ,blue etc and one more thing is that a must to praise someone?? Just think and judge urself the music of Arr and others u will get the answer From: nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Monday, November 10, 2008 11:02:30 PM Subject: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as the rival? does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur opinions.
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
hey Rawat, I think i made a wrong impression may be on my last post.. i actually agreed with Vithur! and wanted to emphasis on the fact!! From: V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 12:52:32 PM Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? On 11/12/2008 10:15 AM India Time, _mb4zap®_ wrote: > Exactly! > > *ARR never gets any fear in his spine or anywhere in his body. His soul, > body, thoughts are all drowned in Divine Music and Divinity altogether.. > . he does everything for GOD, not for men / women etc ..* > > - How would anyone know how true it is without knowing who he is talking > about! After year of following up about a person, seeing him, hearing him and about him, listening to his work, we do form a fair idea about him even we have never met such that person in person. In 16 years of my follow-up of ARR, I have not found any instance where he had "given a slip" to his thoughts/ views/ actions/ interactions that were contrary to what Vithur wrote above. And, you must have known by now that I am openly, vocally, verbally, observant and critical if I feel anything is not correct. -- V
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
On 11/12/2008 10:15 AM India Time, _mb4zap®_ wrote: > Exactly! > > *ARR never gets any fear in his spine or anywhere in his body. His soul, > body, thoughts are all drowned in Divine Music and Divinity altogether.. > . he does everything for GOD, not for men / women etc ..* > > - How would anyone know how true it is without knowing who he is talking > about! After year of following up about a person, seeing him, hearing him and about him, listening to his work, we do form a fair idea about him even we have never met such that person in person. In 16 years of my follow-up of ARR, I have not found any instance where he had "given a slip" to his thoughts/ views/ actions/ interactions that were contrary to what Vithur wrote above. And, you must have known by now that I am openly, vocally, verbally, observant and critical if I feel anything is not correct. -- V
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
Exactly! ARR never gets any fear in his spine or anywhere in his body. His soul, body, thoughts are all drowned in Divine Music and Divinity altogether.. . he does everything for GOD, not for men / women etc .. - How would anyone know how true it is without knowing who he is talking about! From: Vithur <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com; nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, November 12, 2008 10:17:46 AM Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? if someone needs to be praised by ARR, they should deserve the same. Do you think Harris really deserves it ?. If asked himself, he may tell " Pls... Dont embarasse me" ( I hope so, he replies like that ) When Gowtham Menon approached ARR for Chennayil Oru Mazhai Kaalam, the first thing that ARR told was that he didnt want to disturb their combo ( Harris - Gowtham) , and that their pair was rocking and doing a good job. Has Harris told anywhere that ARR - Mani; ARR - Shankar ; ARR - Kadhir ; ARR - Ashutosh; ARR - Subhash Ghai ; ARR - Shyam Benegal ; ARR - Rajkumar santosh did a good job... ARR never gets any fear in his spine or anywhere in his body. His soul, body, thoughts are all drowned in Divine Music and Divinity altogether.. . he does everything for GOD, not for men / women etc .. On Tue, Nov 11, 2008 at 12:32 PM, nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> wrote: i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as the rival? does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur opinions. -- regards, Vithur
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
if someone needs to be praised by ARR, they should deserve the same. Do you think Harris really deserves it ?. If asked himself, he may tell " Pls... Dont embarasse me" ( I hope so, he replies like that ) When Gowtham Menon approached ARR for Chennayil Oru Mazhai Kaalam, the first thing that ARR told was that he didnt want to disturb their combo ( Harris - Gowtham) , and that their pair was rocking and doing a good job. Has Harris told anywhere that ARR - Mani; ARR - Shankar ; ARR - Kadhir ; ARR - Ashutosh; ARR - Subhash Ghai ; ARR - Shyam Benegal ; ARR - Rajkumar santosh did a good job... ARR never gets any fear in his spine or anywhere in his body. His soul, body, thoughts are all drowned in Divine Music and Divinity altogether... he does everything for GOD, not for men / women etc .. On Tue, Nov 11, 2008 at 12:32 PM, nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and > have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere > any praise from arr for harris...why?is he considering him as the rival? > does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send > shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur > opinions. > > > -- regards, Vithur
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
logesh u hv said tat Harris hasnt praised ARR, in Relaince mobile Vijay awards Harris got award for his song june ponal as most requested song in medias, he said ARR as his fav MD, in stage itself, that too they didnt ask him ques, he simply said jus aftr getting the award, even i was wondering why he s sayin this here ??!! confused.. anways jus to let u knw tat Harris praised ARR.. --- On Tue, 11/11/08, logesh kum-arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: logesh kum-arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 11, 2008, 2:39 PM To be frank, I have rarely seen a MD appreciating other MDs truthfully from heart, but I have seen ARR do that whenever he is asked such questions. once Rahman had mentioned that Harris is doing good these days, i think tht was 2 years back things. But I have never seen him praising Arr, actually I dont want comment abt Harris, but the way u posted ur questions sure doubts Rahmans authenticity with music. I believe rahman is true to his heart whwnever he is asked any questions not like ppl who behave differently just in front of media. Rahman rocks :) On 11/11/08, Vinu aryan wrote: > I am just posting my opinion and i know no one will reply u r mail . The > thing is Arr's Spine is very strong yaar it wont get shiverred by a copy > cat. Who uses songs from westlife ,blue etc and one more thing is that a > must to praise someone?? Just think and judge urself the music of Arr and > others u will get the answer > > > > > > _ _ __ > From: nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > Sent: Monday, November 10, 2008 11:02:30 PM > Subject: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? > > > i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and > have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere > any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as the rival? > does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send > shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur > opinions. > > > > > -- best regrards Logesh A
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
To be frank, I have rarely seen a MD appreciating other MDs truthfully from heart, but I have seen ARR do that whenever he is asked such questions. once Rahman had mentioned that Harris is doing good these days, i think tht was 2 years back things. But I have never seen him praising Arr, actually I dont want comment abt Harris, but the way u posted ur questions sure doubts Rahmans authenticity with music. I believe rahman is true to his heart whwnever he is asked any questions not like ppl who behave differently just in front of media. Rahman rocks :) On 11/11/08, Vinu aryan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I am just posting my opinion and i know no one will reply u r mail . The > thing is Arr's Spine is very strong yaar it wont get shiverred by a copy > cat. Who uses songs from westlife ,blue etc and one more thing is that a > must to praise someone?? Just think and judge urself the music of Arr and > others u will get the answer > > > > > > > From: nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > Sent: Monday, November 10, 2008 11:02:30 PM > Subject: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? > > > i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and > have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere > any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as the rival? > does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send > shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur > opinions. > > > > > -- best regrards Logesh A
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
I am just posting my opinion and i know no one will reply u r mail . The thing is Arr's Spine is very strong yaar it wont get shiverred by a copy cat. Who uses songs from westlife ,blue etc and one more thing is that a must to praise someone?? Just think and judge urself the music of Arr and others u will get the answer From: nikhil_341 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Monday, November 10, 2008 11:02:30 PM Subject: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman? i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere any praise from arr for harris...why? is he considering him as the rival? does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send shivers down the spine of arr?i really want to know...plz give ur opinions.
Re: [arr] why no praise for harris from rahman?
On 11/11/2008 12:32 PM India Time, _nikhil_341_ wrote: > i request moderator plz allow me to post this...i am a fan of arr and > have seen him praising MDs like himesh and yuvan..i never read anywhere > any praise from arr for harris...why?is he considering him as the rival? > does the entry and success of harris in tamil film industry send > shivers down the spine of arr? Should I call it derogatory or only laughable? In last 16-18 years, so many MDs have come and gone in Hindi and Tamil music, but ARR stays solidly. He is improvising and improving with every of his release. Nothing would ever send shivers to him. -- V
