Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-10 Thread Sergio P. Korlowsky

On Wed, 08 Nov 2000, you wrote:
 from the quill of Robert L Martin [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  
  which iomega product is not supported
 
 By Iomega?  All of them.
 
  by linux
 
 Most of them work.  That is not the point however.
 
  Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers
  from
  the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
  download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
  the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
  ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)
  
  so what is the deal with iomega??
 
 The deal is that I had a Jaz drive eating disks.  It was a bad drive,
 plain and simple.  But do they trust my word for that fact?  Nope.  
 
 "What O/S are you running?"
 "Uhm, Linux."
 "Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 "No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying disks."
 "But we don't support Linux."
 "Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
 destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
 "Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 
 That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things work,
 great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a vendor.
 
 b.
 -- 
 Brian J. Murrell

I bought an Iomega Zip drive long time ago, it was a parallel port drive
after using it for just a very few times, after some time without use, I tried
to use once again... but this time It had the 'infamous' Click of Dead'

So... I am on your side... I will NEVER buy another Iomega Product. period.!

Sergio Korlowsky




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott (DO NOT REPLY!!!)

2000-11-10 Thread Christopher Molnar

Please stop this conversation!!!

This is not the place for it!

-Chris




Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Vadim Plessky

On Thursday 09 November 2000 14:21, Giuseppe Ghibo' wrote:
|   "Brian J. Murrell" wrote:
|"What O/S are you running?"
|"Uhm, Linux."
|"Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
|"No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying
|disks." "But we don't support Linux."
|"Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
|destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
|"Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
|   
|That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things
|work, great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a
|vendor.
|
|   AFAIK Iomega is distributing beta software for Linux to support
|   their devices. Looks at:
|
|   ftp://ftp.iomega.com/pub/english/*container*.tgz
|
|   So it's even no longer true that they do not support Linux... ;-)

It will not help them to recover as company.
With CD-Recorders at $130 level and probably prices for them dropping below 
$100 next year, I don't see how Iomega can survive.
(I told Iomega that they will not survive, when was meeting  discussing 
distributorship with them  around 3 years ago. They were very arregant. 
Didn't wanted to listen, just: our conditions are:... Minimal order is 
$100K... and so on. We could not agree on that. 
One year later they came back and asked: please!  Answer was _ f_ off ! 
May be, it will help you a little bit, Brian.)

Just want to ask people who using CD-recorders with Linux.
What models you have? Any problems/glitches?
Are CD-RW disks/drives fully supported?
I am thinking either to assemble PC with internal CD-recorder or to buy 
external for my notebook. I don't need CD-recorder which is not working in 
Linux. :-)

|
|   Bye.
|   Giuseppe
-- 

Vadim Plessky
http://kde2.newmail.ru  (English)
http://kde2.newmail.ru/index_rus.html  (Russian)
Do you have Arial font installed? Just test it!
http://kde2.newmail.ru/font_test_arial.html




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread Christopher Molnar

Can this conversation end? It's sort of off topic?

Thanks,
Chris

On Thursday 09 November 2000 17:38, you wrote:
 But, but, but.. I just downloaded Iomega's own driver for the Zip 250
 (I'm trying to find out why you can only put 119MB when using Linux) so how
 can they possibly say "Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye." !?!?!?!?!?
 Tell them they DO support Linux, it says so on their web site !

 Owen

 On Thu, 09 Nov 2000, you wrote:
  from the quill of Robert L Martin [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
   which iomega product is not supported
 
  By Iomega?  All of them.
 
   by linux
 
  Most of them work.  That is not the point however.
 
   Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers
   from
   the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
   download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
   the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
   ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)
  
   so what is the deal with iomega??
 
  The deal is that I had a Jaz drive eating disks.  It was a bad drive,
  plain and simple.  But do they trust my word for that fact?  Nope.
 
  "What O/S are you running?"
  "Uhm, Linux."
  "Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
  "No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying disks."
  "But we don't support Linux."
  "Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
  destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
  "Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 
  That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things work,
  great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a vendor.
 
  b.
 
 
 
  --
  Brian J. Murrell




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread Giuseppe Ghibo'

"Brian J. Murrell" wrote:
 
 "What O/S are you running?"
 "Uhm, Linux."
 "Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 "No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying disks."
 "But we don't support Linux."
 "Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
 destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
 "Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 
 That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things work,
 great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a vendor.

AFAIK Iomega is distributing beta software for Linux to support
their devices. Looks at:

ftp://ftp.iomega.com/pub/english/*container*.tgz

So it's even no longer true that they do not support Linux... ;-)

Bye.
Giuseppe





Re: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Burkhard Zombronner

Am Donnerstag 09 November 2000 17:22 schrieben Sie:
 So sprach Vadim Plessky am Thu, Nov 09, 2000 at 06:58:35PM +0300:
  Just want to ask people who using CD-recorders with Linux.
  What models you have? Any problems/glitches?

 TEAC CD-R56S SCSI
 No problems at all

 Alexander Skwar

Yamaha CDR 400t SCSI, working great, no problem. I love scsi

Burkhard Zombronner

-- 
Microsoft is not dead, it just smells funny




RE: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Matt Grest

What models you have? Any problems/glitches?

Up until very recently I was running an IDE Mitsumi 2801 on Mandrake 7.1. I
had to recompile the kernel with SCSI emulation support, which wasn't too
difficult.

I used XCDROAST to write CD's. I don't think I had a single coaster out of
over 100 burns (unlike the windows coaster to success ratio).

Matt

--
| Matt Grest"Smart Applications - Tools for life"
| Core System Development
| Insight ASP LTD   http://www.myopenapps.com
+-Open Source Innovation







Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread John Allen


"Brian J. Murrell" wrote:
from the quill of Robert L Martin [EMAIL PROTECTED]>
on scroll
[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>
> which iomega product is not supported
By Iomega? All of them.
> by linux
Most of them work. That is not the point however.
> Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers
> from
> the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
> download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
> the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
> ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)
>
> so what is the deal with iomega??
The deal is that I had a Jaz drive eating disks. It was a bad
drive,
plain and simple. But do they trust my word for that fact?
Nope.
"What O/S are you running?"
"Uhm, Linux."
"Oh we don't support Linux. Goodbye."
"No wait. It's got nothing to do with the O/S. It's destroying
disks."
"But we don't support Linux."
"Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter. The drive is physically
destroying disks. It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
"Sorry, we don't support Linux. Goodbye."

Of course there is a way around that,
"What O/S are you running?"
"Uhm, Windows 98."
"Ok we'll send you a replacement unit.."
"Thanks."


That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again. If things
work,
great. If not though, you are SOL. That is unacceptable
from a vendor.
b.
--
Brian J. Murrell

--
=
John Allen, Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Orbiscom Ltd, Web: http://www.orbiscom.com
3 Sandyford Park, Phone: +353-1-2945111
Sandyford Industrial Estate, Mobile: +353-86-2315986
Dublin 18. Fax: +353-1-2945119
=



Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread Brian J. Murrell

from the quill of John Allen [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
 Of course there is a way around that,
 "What O/S are you running?"
 "Uhm, Windows 98."
 "Ok we'll send you a replacement unit.."
 "Thanks."

Not really.  That only works until they say
"Go to your Start Menu, select Iomega and then click on... Now tell me
what it says/does."
"Uhm, I can't do that."
"Why not?"
"Well, I am not really running Windows 98."
"But you just said you were."
...

b.



-- 
Brian J. Murrell




Re: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Ryan Wahle

Go look at the cdrecord FAQ for the best drives that work perfectly.

see ya.

- Original Message -
From: "Vadim Plessky" [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Thursday, November 09, 2000 7:58 AM
Subject: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]


 On Thursday 09 November 2000 14:21, Giuseppe Ghibo' wrote:
 |   "Brian J. Murrell" wrote:
 |"What O/S are you running?"
 |"Uhm, Linux."
 |"Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 |"No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying
 |disks." "But we don't support Linux."
 |"Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
 |destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
 |"Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 |   
 |That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things
 |work, great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from
a
 |vendor.
 |
 |   AFAIK Iomega is distributing beta software for Linux to support
 |   their devices. Looks at:
 |
 |   ftp://ftp.iomega.com/pub/english/*container*.tgz
 |
 |   So it's even no longer true that they do not support Linux... ;-)

 It will not help them to recover as company.
 With CD-Recorders at $130 level and probably prices for them dropping
below
 $100 next year, I don't see how Iomega can survive.
 (I told Iomega that they will not survive, when was meeting  discussing
 distributorship with them  around 3 years ago. They were very arregant.
 Didn't wanted to listen, just: our conditions are:... Minimal order is
 $100K... and so on. We could not agree on that.
 One year later they came back and asked: please!  Answer was _ f_ off !
 May be, it will help you a little bit, Brian.)

 Just want to ask people who using CD-recorders with Linux.
 What models you have? Any problems/glitches?
 Are CD-RW disks/drives fully supported?
 I am thinking either to assemble PC with internal CD-recorder or to buy
 external for my notebook. I don't need CD-recorder which is not working in
 Linux. :-)

 |
 |   Bye.
 |   Giuseppe
 --

 Vadim Plessky
 http://kde2.newmail.ru  (English)
 http://kde2.newmail.ru/index_rus.html  (Russian)
 Do you have Arial font installed? Just test it!
 http://kde2.newmail.ru/font_test_arial.html






Re: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Sam

I'm using a SCSI ORB drive with Mandrake- 2.2GB per disk, $30 per disk, 
cheaper than a 1GB Jazz drive. Iomega is only still alive because of 
product name recognition. Everybody with a computer knows what a Zip 
drive is.

 Original Message 

On 11/9/00, 8:58:35 AM, Vadim Plessky [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote 
regarding Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]:


 On Thursday 09 November 2000 14:21, Giuseppe Ghibo' wrote:
 |   "Brian J. Murrell" wrote:
 |"What O/S are you running?"
 |"Uhm, Linux."
 |"Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 |"No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying
 |disks." "But we don't support Linux."
 |"Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
 |destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
 |"Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 |   
 |That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things
 |work, great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from 
a
 |vendor.
 |
 |   AFAIK Iomega is distributing beta software for Linux to support
 |   their devices. Looks at:
 |
 |   ftp://ftp.iomega.com/pub/english/*container*.tgz
 |
 |   So it's even no longer true that they do not support Linux... ;-)

 It will not help them to recover as company.
 With CD-Recorders at $130 level and probably prices for them dropping 
below
 $100 next year, I don't see how Iomega can survive.
 (I told Iomega that they will not survive, when was meeting  discussing
 distributorship with them  around 3 years ago. They were very arregant.
 Didn't wanted to listen, just: our conditions are:... Minimal order is
 $100K... and so on. We could not agree on that.
 One year later they came back and asked: please!  Answer was _ f_ off !
 May be, it will help you a little bit, Brian.)

 Just want to ask people who using CD-recorders with Linux.
 What models you have? Any problems/glitches?
 Are CD-RW disks/drives fully supported?
 I am thinking either to assemble PC with internal CD-recorder or to buy
 external for my notebook. I don't need CD-recorder which is not working 
in
 Linux. :-)

 |
 |   Bye.
 |   Giuseppe
 --

 Vadim Plessky
 http://kde2.newmail.ru  (English)
 http://kde2.newmail.ru/index_rus.html  (Russian)
 Do you have Arial font installed? Just test it!
 http://kde2.newmail.ru/font_test_arial.html




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread Alexander Skwar

So sprach Larry Marshall am Wed, Nov 08, 2000 at 09:04:38PM -0500:
 Heck, most of Kodak's digital specs are part of the configuration/setup of
 gPhoto.  

Okay, then Kodak is a good example after all.  Sorry to have spread some
wrong information.

Alexander Skwar
-- 
How to quote:   http://learn.to/quote (german) http://quote.6x.to (english)
Homepage:   http://www.digitalprojects.com  |  http://www.dp.ath.cx
GnuPG ID:   4E35467E  FP: 93367E5B4AB777B42065533F456FF17C4E35467E
ICQ:7328191




Re: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Alexander Skwar

So sprach Vadim Plessky am Thu, Nov 09, 2000 at 06:58:35PM +0300:
 Just want to ask people who using CD-recorders with Linux.
 What models you have? Any problems/glitches?

TEAC CD-R56S SCSI
No problems at all

Alexander Skwar
-- 
How to quote:   http://learn.to/quote (german) http://quote.6x.to (english)
Homepage:   http://www.digitalprojects.com  |  http://www.dp.ath.cx
GnuPG ID:   4E35467E  FP: 93367E5B4AB777B42065533F456FF17C4E35467E
ICQ:7328191




Re: Iomega and CD-Recorders support [Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott]

2000-11-09 Thread Arnold Troeger

Vadim Plessky wrote:

 On Thursday 09 November 2000 14:21, Giuseppe Ghibo' wrote:
 |   "Brian J. Murrell" wrote:
 |"What O/S are you running?"
 |"Uhm, Linux."
 |"Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 |"No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying
 |disks." "But we don't support Linux."
 |"Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
 |destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
 |"Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 |   
 |That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things
 |work, great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a
 |vendor.
 |
 |   AFAIK Iomega is distributing beta software for Linux to support
 |   their devices. Looks at:
 |
 |   ftp://ftp.iomega.com/pub/english/*container*.tgz
 |
 |   So it's even no longer true that they do not support Linux... ;-)

 It will not help them to recover as company.
 With CD-Recorders at $130 level and probably prices for them dropping below
 $100 next year, I don't see how Iomega can survive.
 (I told Iomega that they will not survive, when was meeting  discussing
 distributorship with them  around 3 years ago. They were very arregant.
 Didn't wanted to listen, just: our conditions are:... Minimal order is
 $100K... and so on. We could not agree on that.
 One year later they came back and asked: please!  Answer was _ f_ off !
 May be, it will help you a little bit, Brian.)

 Just want to ask people who using CD-recorders with Linux.
 What models you have? Any problems/glitches?
 Are CD-RW disks/drives fully supported?
 I am thinking either to assemble PC with internal CD-recorder or to buy
 external for my notebook. I don't need CD-recorder which is not working in
 Linux. :-)

 |
 |   Bye.
 |   Giuseppe
 --

 Vadim Plessky
 http://kde2.newmail.ru  (English)
 http://kde2.newmail.ru/index_rus.html  (Russian)
 Do you have Arial font installed? Just test it!
 http://kde2.newmail.ru/font_test_arial.html

I had a Phillips 3610 IDE CDBurner. It was a POS.  The local Phillips shop
replaced it three times and, each time, after a run of maybe 5 or 10 burns it
would generate coasters regularly.  I tried upgrading cdrecord to 1.10a4 (very
interesting comments about Phillips in the documentation there).  In the last
couple of weeks it would regularly lock up my machine.  In desparation, I
installed windows 98 and tried using the Adaptec software that ships with the
cdwriter to burn CDs; still, lockups.  By this time, the warranty had run out
and so, rather than fight it, I bought an HP 9610 CD-RW and have only generated
one coaster out of 40 burns (the coaster was due to a power failure; my next
purchase is a UPS).  From my personal experience I recommend staying away from
Phillips as they have some quality control problems and some developer
relations problems.   The HP CD writer works very nicely.  The Phillips CD
writer is now serving as a paper weight on my desk at home; a task to which it
seems very well suited.

My $.02 worth

--
Arnold Troeger  Unocal Thailand
Phone:  011-66-2-545-5456   5th Floor, Tower 3, SCB Park Plaza
FAX:011-66-2-545-5374   19 Ratchadapisek Road, Chatuchak
Email:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]   Bangkok 10900, Thailand

"Microsoft Windows:  for when your machine is just too fast"







Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread OS

WellI haven't found a Iomega drive not supported by Linux but..if Linux
support is so good how come you can only put 119MB on a Zip 250. Even gdiskfree
shows it as only 51% full, but can you get any more on it ? nooo !

:-)

Owen

On Thu, 09 Nov 2000, you wrote:
 Turnabout is fair play I say.
 
  I will NEVER buy another Iomega product EVER, and I am just biding my
  time until I can shuck my DSL vendor.
 which iomega product is not supported by linux
 Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers from
 the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
 download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
 the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
 ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)
 
 so what is the deal with iomega??
 
 Robert L Martin




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-09 Thread OS

But, but, but.. I just downloaded Iomega's own driver for the Zip 250 (I'm
trying to find out why you can only put 119MB when using Linux) so how can they
possibly say "Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye." !?!?!?!?!? Tell them
they DO support Linux, it says so on their web site !

Owen

On Thu, 09 Nov 2000, you wrote:
 from the quill of Robert L Martin [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  
  which iomega product is not supported
 
 By Iomega?  All of them.
 
  by linux
 
 Most of them work.  That is not the point however.
 
  Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers
  from
  the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
  download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
  the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
  ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)
  
  so what is the deal with iomega??
 
 The deal is that I had a Jaz drive eating disks.  It was a bad drive,
 plain and simple.  But do they trust my word for that fact?  Nope.  
 
 "What O/S are you running?"
 "Uhm, Linux."
 "Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 "No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying disks."
 "But we don't support Linux."
 "Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
 destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
 "Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
 
 That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things work,
 great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a vendor.
 
 b.
 
 
 
 -- 
 Brian J. Murrell




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread pgeorges

"Brian J. Murrell" a écrit :

 We should be quite public about the fact that if a hardware vendor
 refuses to support Linux now, it will be shunned and boycotted when the
 time comes that they do want to support Linux.  Let them gamble on not
 supporting Linux now when we need them.  Turnabout is fair play I say.
 
 I will NEVER buy another Iomega product EVER, and I am just biding my
 time until I can shuck my DSL vendor.

Let's make a step forward without polluting too much this list :

- is there already a boycot web site, listing all harware
vendors/manufacturers that should be boycotted, because linux unfriendly
?
- if not, what about making one with
 a/ one list calling for boycott
 b/ one list congratulating those making special efforts towards Linux
(nvidia, phillips, IBM, etc.)

I checked french law rapidly, and calling for boycott is not illegal, as
it can't be assimilated, in that case, to discrimination (ethnic,
racial, sexual, etc...)

If some people are interested into this, contact me directly (NOT
through this list, to avoid out of topic public discussions).




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Brian J. Murrell

from the quill of pgeorges [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
 Let's make a step forward without polluting too much this list :
 
 - is there already a boycot web site, listing all harware
 vendors/manufacturers that should be boycotted, because linux
 unfriendly

Keep in mind, boycotting should be the very last step.  Every effort
should be put into getting the vendor to want to play with Linux.  We
don't *want* to boycott anyone.  Nobody wins when that happens.

So before you boycott, make sure you have taken every step you can think
of to get the vendor on our side.  A boycott web site should have an
always evolving list of practices and procedures that one can take to
try to convince a vendor to play.  The focus of the website should be on
gaining the acceptance of Linux by a vendor, not shunning them.

I spent A LOT of time trying to get Iomega to even deal with Linux
before I finally wrote them off.

Now, as this heads offtopic, it should probably be taken somewhere else.

b.



-- 
Brian J. Murrell




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread pgeorges

"Brian J. Murrell" a écrit :

 Keep in mind, boycotting should be the very last step.  Every effort
 should be put into getting the vendor to want to play with Linux.  We
 don't *want* to boycott anyone.  Nobody wins when that happens.

False. By boycotting Matrox, the Millemium card was finally supported in
XFree.

Of course, boycotting is the last step. Just a way to make pressure and
lobbying.




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Yoann Vandoorselaere

pgeorges [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 "Brian J. Murrell" a écrit :
 
  We should be quite public about the fact that if a hardware vendor
  refuses to support Linux now, it will be shunned and boycotted when the
  time comes that they do want to support Linux.  Let them gamble on not
  supporting Linux now when we need them.  Turnabout is fair play I say.
  
  I will NEVER buy another Iomega product EVER, and I am just biding my
  time until I can shuck my DSL vendor.
 
 Let's make a step forward without polluting too much this list :
 
 - is there already a boycot web site, listing all harware
 vendors/manufacturers that should be boycotted, because linux unfriendly
 ?
 - if not, what about making one with
  a/ one list calling for boycott
  b/ one list congratulating those making special efforts towards Linux
 (nvidia, phillips, IBM, etc.)
   ^^

People making binary driver don't make any effort towards Linux...
What they do is getting money from you.

-- 
-- Yoann http://www.mandrakesoft.com/~yoann/
I worry about my child and the Internet all the time, even though she's too 
young to have logged on yet. Here's what I worry about. I worry that 10 or 15 
years from now, she will come to me and say 'Daddy, where were you when they 
took freedom of the press away from the Internet?'  -- Mike Godwin




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Brian J. Murrell

from the quill of pgeorges [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
 False. By boycotting Matrox, the Millemium card was finally supported
 in
 XFree.

That was a win then yes.  But I think the risks of alienating a vendor
are higher than winning one over with boycotting tactics.  I am not
saying not do it, but just make sure all other avenues have been
exhausted prior.

 Of course, boycotting is the last step. Just a way to make pressure
 and
 lobbying.

Agreed.

b.



-- 
Brian J. Murrell




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Meir Faraj

On Wednesday 08 November 2000 20:48, you wrote:
 from the quill of pgeorges [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

  False. By boycotting Matrox, the Millemium card was finally supported
  in
  XFree.

 That was a win then yes.  But I think the risks of alienating a vendor
 are higher than winning one over with boycotting tactics.  I am not
 saying not do it, but just make sure all other avenues have been
 exhausted prior.

  Of course, boycotting is the last step. Just a way to make pressure
  and
  lobbying.

 Agreed.

 b.
I'm for a boycott site it's a nice idea !




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Alexander Skwar

So sprach Yoann Vandoorselaere am Wed, Nov 08, 2000 at 07:40:44PM +0100:
 pgeorges [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
  (nvidia, phillips, IBM, etc.)
^^
 
 People making binary driver don't make any effort towards Linux...
 What they do is getting money from you.

While I agree to some degree with what you said, it always could be worse. 
Sure, NVidia is clearly not the best example for a Linux friendly company,
but then they are also not the worst.  Just have a look at Promise, another
market leader.  They don't do nothing to support Linux, or do you know of
anyone who's successfully using one of their RAID cards?  I don't.  Or have
a look at Kodak's digital cameras.  There's also not much support from them. 
Or think about all these parallel port scanners.  Do any actually work?

In my opinion your judgement against NVidia is too harsh.

Alexander Skwar
-- 
How to quote:   http://learn.to/quote (german) http://quote.6x.to (english)
Homepage:   http://www.digitalprojects.com  |  http://www.dp.ath.cx
GnuPG ID:   4E35467E  FP: 93367E5B4AB777B42065533F456FF17C4E35467E
ICQ:7328191




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Brian J. Murrell

from the quill of Alexander Skwar [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Or have
 a look at Kodak's digital cameras.

I have written software for the DC210.  They at least (or did at least)
publish the interface specs to their cameras.  That is better than some.
 Actually I might argue that publishing specs is better than binary only
drivers, so Kodak could be considered better than Nvidia.

b.



-- 
Brian J. Murrell




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread James A. Sutherland

On Wed, 08 Nov 2000, Brian J. Murrell wrote:
 from the quill of Alexander Skwar [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Or have
  a look at Kodak's digital cameras.
 
 I have written software for the DC210.  They at least (or did at least)
 publish the interface specs to their cameras.  That is better than some.
  Actually I might argue that publishing specs is better than binary only
 drivers, so Kodak could be considered better than Nvidia.

Yup - after all, the specs can be "converted" into with-source drivers. Also,
it allows non-Linux platforms (*BSD etc) to have drivers much more easily.


James.




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Ben Reser

On Wed, Nov 08, 2000 at 09:30:44PM +0100, Alexander Skwar wrote:
 anyone who's successfully using one of their RAID cards?  I don't.  Or have
 a look at Kodak's digital cameras.  There's also not much support from them. 

Umm they publish their specs.  They have an excellent developer relations
program.  And there is plenty of support for their cameras:
http://howto.tucows.com/LDP/HOWTO/Kodak-Digitalcam-HOWTO.html#toc5

-- 
Ben Reser [EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://ben.reser.org

Maslow's Maxim:  If the only tool you have is a hammer,
you treat everything like a nail.




Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Larry Marshall

  anyone who's successfully using one of their RAID cards?  I don't.  Or have
  a look at Kodak's digital cameras.  There's also not much support from them. 
 
 Umm they publish their specs.  They have an excellent developer relations
 program.  And there is plenty of support for their cameras:
 http://howto.tucows.com/LDP/HOWTO/Kodak-Digitalcam-HOWTO.html#toc5

Heck, most of Kodak's digital specs are part of the configuration/setup of
gPhoto.  

Cheers --- Larry






Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Robert L Martin

 Turnabout is fair play I say.

 I will NEVER buy another Iomega product EVER, and I am just biding my
 time until I can shuck my DSL vendor.
which iomega product is not supported by linux
Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers from
the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)

so what is the deal with iomega??

Robert L Martin





Re: [Cooker] Call for boycott

2000-11-08 Thread Brian J. Murrell

from the quill of Robert L Martin [EMAIL PROTECTED] on scroll
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
 which iomega product is not supported

By Iomega?  All of them.

 by linux

Most of them work.  That is not the point however.

 Jazz /Zip use either standard drivers (scsi card) or named drivers
 from
 the kernel (buried in the iomega site is a
 download for PPA/IMM Zip drives)
 the cd should use standard drivers (panasonic??)
 ditto uses more or less standard drivers (its scsi??)
 
 so what is the deal with iomega??

The deal is that I had a Jaz drive eating disks.  It was a bad drive,
plain and simple.  But do they trust my word for that fact?  Nope.  

"What O/S are you running?"
"Uhm, Linux."
"Oh we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."
"No wait.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S.  It's destroying disks."
"But we don't support Linux."
"Linux, Windows, MacOS, it doesn't matter.  The drive is physically
destroying disks.  It's got nothing to do with the O/S."
"Sorry, we don't support Linux.  Goodbye."

That is why I will NEVER do business with Iomega again.  If things work,
great.  If not though, you are SOL.  That is unacceptable from a vendor.

b.



-- 
Brian J. Murrell