Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-22 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 21 Nov 99, at 23:30, tracer wrote
about "Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah":

 Alexander But these are *Russian* bears:-)). They know! Those 
 Alexander Americans are really funny, they (provided that they know 
 Alexander *what and where* Russia is anyway) still seem to believe it's 
 Alexander common for the wild bears to walk down the streets in Russia:-) 
 Alexander At least I've already seen 3 such guys (all of them Americans) 
 Alexander who were *really* deadly surprised not to find those bears in 
 Alexander the streets. and a friend of mine now working in the 
 Alexander Silicon valley met 2 other Americans, who seemed to believe 
 Alexander that Russia is located somewhere next to Venezuela:-))

 whats wrong with that?

Nothing in particular:-))) At least, it leaves *me* calm:-)

 They tested students in the past on their chemistry knowledge  and
 according to some Sodium Chloride was a green gas

Well, well. AFAIK this summer there was a heated 
discussion in Oxford whether to teach their math students what 
"uniformly continuous function" is or NOT:-))) ROTFLMAO, as 
you say:-) This is exactly what *our* students are taught in the 
*very* first semester:-))

 But you are missing out on a tourist attraction, train some
 bears  and get the tourists to visit them. Obviously wanting
 repeat visits you cannot let those bears eat them (at least
 not all of them) 

Interesting idea, that:-)

 By the way a friend has an internet cafee and yesterday his
 internet browser looked 'odd' he said. Some smart visitor had
 switched him to the Russian character set... 

Apparently it was Russian:-) It's somehow a thing *every* 
Russian does first of all approaching *any* web browser 
anywhere:-)



SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Thought for the day:
  Friends don't let friends use Windows.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-21 Thread Ali Martin

Hi all,

  Steve Lamb wrote:

 snip
 Alt-F1, login, mutt;
 Alt-F2, login, mutt;
 in the mutt#1 open one IMAP account, in the mutt#2 open 
 another. What else do you want?

 That is two copies of mutt.  Would you be as happy with TB! if you had to
 open a separate copy of it for each account that you had?  I know I wouldn't.

I did this with Forte' Agent and disliked it a lot.

-- 
Regards,
 -=Ali=-   

Reality is nothing but a collective hunch. 
**
  Using The Bat! v1.38 Beta/2 [-] Windows NT 4.0 (Service Pack 6)
**

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-21 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 21 Nov 99, at 14:34, tracer wrote
about "Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah":

  Alexander Well, -5 (C), if you *really* wanted to know. And the wild polar 
  Alexander bears walking here and there:-)) Growling and eating people 
  Alexander bg
  Doesnt matter as long as they know WHOM to eat
 
 Alexander Americans, whom else?:-)))

 How do your bears know the difference

But these are *Russian* bears:-)). They know! Those 
Americans are really funny, they (provided that they know 
*what and where* Russia is anyway) still seem to believe it's 
common for the wild bears to walk down the streets in Russia:-) 
At least I've already seen 3 such guys (all of them Americans) 
who were *really* deadly surprised not to find those bears in 
the streets. and a friend of mine now working in the 
Silicon valley met 2 other Americans, who seemed to believe 
that Russia is located somewhere next to Venezuela:-))


SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Thought for the day:
  I am in total control, but don't tell my wife.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-21 Thread tracer

Sunday, November 21, 1999

Hello Alexander,

Sunday, Sunday, November 21, 1999, you wrote:

Alexander Hi there!

Alexander On 21 Nov 99, at 14:34, tracer wrote
Alexander about "Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah":

  Alexander Well, -5 (C), if you *really* wanted to know. And the wild polar 
  Alexander bears walking here and there:-)) Growling and eating people 
  Alexander bg
  Doesnt matter as long as they know WHOM to eat
 
 Alexander Americans, whom else?:-)))

 How do your bears know the difference

Alexander But these are *Russian* bears:-)). They know! Those 
Alexander Americans are really funny, they (provided that they know 
Alexander *what and where* Russia is anyway) still seem to believe it's 
Alexander common for the wild bears to walk down the streets in Russia:-) 
Alexander At least I've already seen 3 such guys (all of them Americans) 
Alexander who were *really* deadly surprised not to find those bears in 
Alexander the streets. and a friend of mine now working in the 
Alexander Silicon valley met 2 other Americans, who seemed to believe 
Alexander that Russia is located somewhere next to Venezuela:-))
whats wrong with that?
They tested students in the past on their chemistry knowledge  and
according to some Sodium Chloride was a green gas

But you are missing out on a tourist attraction, train some bears  and
get the tourists to visit them. Obviously wanting repeat visits you
cannot let those bears eat them (at least not all of them)
By the way a friend has an internet cafee and yesterday his internet
browser looked 'odd' he said.
Some smart visitor had switched him to the Russian character set...
They must have been trying to fix it for hours so when I visited  for
a refreshing beer it meant serious (g) work...

Alexander SY, Alex
Alexander (St.Petersburg, Russia)



Best regards,
 
tracer

Using theBAT 1.38 Beta/2 

mail to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
NOTE: 1 MAILRUN PER DAY ONLY



-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 20 Nov 99, at 14:39, tracer wrote
about "Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah":

 who has any details about what will be in v2??

RIT labs:-)))


SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Thought for the day:
  You cannot have a baby in one month by getting nine women
  pregnant.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 


-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 19 Nov 99, at 17:52, Steve Lamb wrote
about "Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah an":

  Your machine is three days fast and I can never find your messages
  until after someone has replied already and I go looking. Kindly
  check. ;-)

Okay, okay, it's been mea culpa:-) Just the new beta of WinEdt 
(2K) came out, and I've been digging in registry, and finally I 
wanted to check it's working bg, and then I forgot to move 
the time back:-) Hope you understand:-))) Needless to say 
more, that is:-) 

 Pst... ask him how the weather is.  :)

Well, -5 (C), if you *really* wanted to know. And the wild polar 
bears walking here and there:-)) Growling and eating people 
bg


SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Thought for the day:
  If we weren't all crazy, we would go insane.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread tracer

Saturday, November 20, 1999

Hello Thomas,

Saturday, Saturday, November 20, 1999, you wrote:

Thomas Hi Steve,

Thomas on Saturday, November 20, 1999, 8:37:02 AM GMT+0800, Steve Lamb wrote:

SL MUA stands for Mail Use Agent or Messaging User Agent.  MTA is for Mail
SL Transfer agent.  There is a third, MDA, which stands for Mail Delivery Agent.

Thomas [very good explanation skipped}

Thomas For all those who have put Steve on the kill filter, please note that
Thomas you've missed something very educational.

SL A lot of people have argued that an editor and a spell checker (for
SL example) are required in producing mail and thus should be reimplemented by
SL the authors of each individual email client.  A lot of other people argue that
SL separate tasks should be handled by separate programs.  So how do I reconcile
SL the need to combine some tasks (MUA/MTA/MDA) but not others (editor/spell
SL checker) into an email client?

Thomas FYI rumours have it that the well-advertised Version 2 will have an
Thomas option "use external editor". I think you will agree with me that
Thomas this would make everybody happy.

who has any details about what will be in v2??


Best regards,
 
tracer

Using theBAT 1.37 Beta/3 

mail to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
NOTE: 1 MAILRUN PER DAY ONLY



-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 19 Nov 99, at 17:37, Steve Lamb wrote
about "Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah an":

  The text editor would then not implement a spell check but,
 
  The only programs under WinDOS that do exactly this (but 
  leave no choice to the users) is... guess what? Office+Outlook:-
  )
 
 Quite the contrary, PMMail.  ;)

Nope, PMMail will work with English only (well, actually I don't 
know, but it *definitely* won't work with Russian, it's got 
defective code that won't accept anything then western unicode 
script correctly, and for Russian one needs cyrillic). 

  This would free up time for the authors of the mail client to
  work on the mail client instead of reimplementing an editor
 
  In theory, I'm on your side. But this is all Linux ideology, and 
  that's why Linux is great. But we live under WinDOS here:-(((
 
 In theory it is great and in practice it is, too.  Sure, we live in WinDOS
 here but it doesn't mean we cannot take the high points of the other world and
 incorporate them here.  

My point was: HOW? The answer to this "how?" needs to tell:
(a) what protocol should be used;
(b) how many third-party apps will be supported by it;
(c) what functionality will this protocol provide.

My own point is that DDE would almost fit, but it isn't supported 
by the majority of software vendors.

 Like I said, I like how TB! and PMMail handle multiple
 accounts.  There is nothing as elegant and power in the Unix
 world.  I'm certainly not one to sit on that side of the fence
 and say "Hey, that's great in Windows, but we live under
 Linux." 

Linux:
Alt-F1, login, mutt;
Alt-F2, login, mutt;
in the mutt#1 open one IMAP account, in the mutt#2 open 
another. What else do you want? I simply don't understand, 
*what* multiaccount functionality you need when working with 
IMAP when the *account itself* stays on the server? Finally, 
when using IMAP the basic idea is that you need only *one* 
single account, since you're able to reach it from everywhere... 

Or are you speaking about the "identities" actually?

 Take mutt and do what?  Btw, you might want to check the many, MANY posts
 I've made on the topic on www.deja.com before answering that.  Chances are,
 I've already addressed what you may me thinking of several times over.
 Needless to say, mutt, while an excellent single-user, single-account MUA is
 utterly outclassed compared to PMMail/TB! when it comes to multiple accounts.

Ok, i'll look it through as time permits.

  And now go and check the url I've provided above:-) But under
  WinDOS this won't help you a lot, will it? 
 
 Cool, postie.  Actually, I used postie to send out turns for a Stars! game
 that I hosted quite a while ago.  That and a batch file was all I need to send
 out news postings and turn files for my game of 5-6 people.  One could do a
 lot with postie and perl if one was so inclined.

Yup, that was my point also. But that would require Perl. 
Although there exists Perl for dosish systems, it lacks in power 
considerably compared to how it can be used on Linux box. 
Just because the winDOS is organized this way, and you can 
do little or nothing about it.


SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Thought for the day:
  Everyone should believe in something -- I believe I'll have
  another drink.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Nick Danger

In Reference to "(SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things..." From Steve 
Lamb:

SL Friday, November 19, 1999, 5:40:07 PM, Thomas wrote:
 Hi Alexander,

 on Tuesday, November 23, 1999, 9:23:01 AM GMT+0800, Alexander V. Kiselev wrote:
 [...]

 Your machine is three days fast and I can never find your messages
 until after someone has replied already and I go looking. Kindly
 check. ;-)

SL Pst... ask him how the weather is.  :)

.and what the winning lottery numbers for tonight will be!

-- 
- Nick


Using The Bat! 1.38 Beta/1
 under Windows 98 4.10 Build 1998



-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Steve Lamb

Friday, November 19, 1999, 5:40:07 PM, Thomas wrote:
 Hi Alexander,

 on Tuesday, November 23, 1999, 9:23:01 AM GMT+0800, Alexander V. Kiselev wrote:
 [...]

 Your machine is three days fast and I can never find your messages
 until after someone has replied already and I go looking. Kindly
 check. ;-)

Pst... ask him how the weather is.  :)

-- 
 Steve C. Lamb | I'm your priest, I'm your shrink, I'm your
 ICQ: 5107343  | main connection to the switchboard of souls.
---+-

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread tracer

Sunday, November 21, 1999

Hello Alexander,

Saturday, Saturday, November 20, 1999, you wrote:

Alexander Hi there!

Alexander On 19 Nov 99, at 17:52, Steve Lamb wrote
Alexander about "Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah an":

  Your machine is three days fast and I can never find your messages
  until after someone has replied already and I go looking. Kindly
  check. ;-)

Alexander Okay, okay, it's been mea culpa:-) Just the new beta of WinEdt 
Alexander (2K) came out, and I've been digging in registry, and finally I 
Alexander wanted to check it's working bg, and then I forgot to move 
Alexander the time back:-) Hope you understand:-))) Needless to say 
Alexander more, that is:-)
I understand (g)

 Pst... ask him how the weather is.  :)

Alexander Well, -5 (C), if you *really* wanted to know. And the wild polar 
Alexander bears walking here and there:-)) Growling and eating people 
Alexander bg
Doesnt matter as long as they know WHOM to eat


Alexander SY, Alex
Alexander (St.Petersburg, Russia)



Best regards,
 
tracer

Using theBAT 1.38 Beta/1 

mail to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
NOTE: 1 MAILRUN PER DAY ONLY



-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 21 Nov 99, at 2:55, tracer wrote
about "Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah":

  who has any details about what will be in v2??
 
 Alexander RIT labs:-)))
 you mean we have to feed them vodka to tell us??

Well, it's a good idea (tm):-)


SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Titanics Generalized Iceberg Theorem:
  Seven-eighths of everything can't be seen.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 


-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread Steve Lamb

Saturday, November 20, 1999, 7:08:41 AM, Alexander wrote:
 Nope, PMMail will work with English only (well, actually I don't
 know, but it *definitely* won't work with Russian, it's got 
 defective code that won't accept anything then western unicode 
 script correctly, and for Russian one needs cyrillic). 

But PMMail allows you to use an external editor and the external editor,
say, vim, for example, would let you pick what spell checker to use.

 My point was: HOW? The answer to this "how?" needs to tell:
 (a) what protocol should be used;

"Send to the editor with a string to tell it where the file is" normally
works.  Has for the past 20-30 years on Unix at least.  ;)

 (b) how many third-party apps will be supported by it;

The above?  100%

 (c) what functionality will this protocol provide.

Functionality which lets you use pretty much anything there since data is
data.

 My own point is that DDE would almost fit, but it isn't supported 
 by the majority of software vendors.

Meanwhile the file system is support by 100%.  :)

 Alt-F1, login, mutt;
 Alt-F2, login, mutt;
 in the mutt#1 open one IMAP account, in the mutt#2 open 
 another. What else do you want?

That is two copies of mutt.  Would you be as happy with TB! if you had to
open a separate copy of it for each account that you had?  I know I wouldn't.

 Or are you speaking about the "identities" actually?

No.  I can't stand that paradigm that Eudora has imposed upon the masses.
Just to keep everything separated out one needs to build filters up the wazoo.
:(

 Yup, that was my point also. But that would require Perl.
 Although there exists Perl for dosish systems, it lacks in power 
 considerably compared to how it can be used on Linux box. 

Not really.  That is only because DOS lacks the standard unix utils that
some perl programmers have come to rely upon.  Personally I program as much
in perl as I can, leaving the system() and exec() calls only for things I
really need.  Generally those are other scripts we have written, not the
standard utils.

 Just because the winDOS is organized this way, and you can
 do little or nothing about it.

Again, I disagree.

-- 
 Steve C. Lamb | I'm your priest, I'm your shrink, I'm your
 ICQ: 5107343  | main connection to the switchboard of souls.
---+-

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-11-20 Thread tracer

Sunday, November 21, 1999

Hello Alexander,

Sunday, Sunday, November 21, 1999, you wrote:

Alexander Hi there!

Alexander On 21 Nov 99, at 2:47, tracer wrote
Alexander about "Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah":

  Pst... ask him how the weather is.  :)
 
 Alexander Well, -5 (C), if you *really* wanted to know. And the wild polar 
 Alexander bears walking here and there:-)) Growling and eating people 
 Alexander bg
 Doesnt matter as long as they know WHOM to eat

Alexander Americans, whom else?:-)))
How do your bears know the difference


Best regards,
 
tracer

Using theBAT 1.38 Beta/1 

mail to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
NOTE: 1 MAILRUN PER DAY ONLY



-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




(SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-01-17 Thread Steve Lamb

MUA stands for Mail Use Agent or Messaging User Agent.  MTA is for Mail
Transfer agent.  There is a third, MDA, which stands for Mail Delivery Agent.

Now, as always, I'm sure someone like Alex could come up and point out
where I am wrong, but this is my understanding of these terms, why I use them
in the way that I do and how they shape my thoughts and views on the whole
technical and social mechanisms of email.

Each of the three terms, MUA, MTA, MDA, describe not programs, but roles.
This is an important distinction since some programs could easily be several
of the different roles.

The MUA is the role of being an interface to the user.  It allows the
user to read and prepare mail for sending.  This is all an MUA does.

The MTA is the role of moving mail from system A to system B in a secure,
speedy and proper manner.  This is all an MTA does, move mail.

The MDA is the role of actually delivering mail once it is on system B.
This delivery might include further steps as delivery includes the filtering
process.

The main focus of most email clients is to fulfill the MUA role. However,
they also fill other roles. For example, TB! is an MUA (let's you
read/prepare mail for delivery), limited MTA (POP/SMTP transfers), limited
MDA (filtering mail into different folders is delivery) as well as a text
editor, a spell checker and other things.

This is why in the previous thread I said that the expected behavior of
TB! conformed to those of MUAs through the years.  Not all email clients to
everything that TB! does but the portion of the email client we were talking
about, preparing a message to be sent, falls clearly in the MUA role.

Now, here's where a lot of people would get up in arms with me.  They have
on other lists, newsgroups and, I believe, even here.  I feel that neither the
Windows world or the Unix world have gotten the concept of "Email Client" down
correctly.  Both have clients, sure, but the roles (and lack of roles) they
take on are flawed.

In Windows the problem is all of the clients implement too much.  For
example, TB!, as stated, is an MUA, limited MTA, limited MDA, text editor,
spell checker  LDAP client.  I feel that the text editor and spell checker
should be left out entirely and only hooks into a text editor provided.  The
text editor would then not implement a spell check but, instead, provide hooks
to call one.  In this way each person can use the editor they prefer and spell
checker they prefer.  In fact, they could use the editor/spell checker across
a variety of programs and in doing so have a consistent interface for those
two portions across those programs as well as the ability to choose the best
editor/spell checker for them.  This would free up time for the authors of the
mail client to work on the mail client instead of reimplementing an editor and
a spell checker which will always be subpar to the editors and spell checkers
from authors who are programming them and not them and an email client as
well.

In unix the problem is that most, if not all, of the clients implement too
little.  Hardly any clients are as capable as TB! and PMMail98 on checking
multiple, separate accounts.  Most cannot filter mail but, instead, rely upon
a program designed to fill the MDA role to do the filtering.  Because of that
paradigm most also do not handle POP/IMAP with any intelligence at all.
However, they don't encumber themselves with editors or spell checkers and,
rightfully, simply provide hooks to other programs to handle those specialized
tasks.

A lot of people have argued that an editor and a spell checker (for
example) are required in producing mail and thus should be reimplemented by
the authors of each individual email client.  A lot of other people argue that
separate tasks should be handled by separate programs.  So how do I reconcile
the need to combine some tasks (MUA/MTA/MDA) but not others (editor/spell
checker) into an email client?

The key lies in understanding what the primary function of an email client
is.  An email client is, at the core, a program which handles a database.
That database is what we call "messages."  With any database there are
functions which need to be there to make it functional.

1: Import

POP/IMAP/local spool files provide this functionality.  Therefore a proper
email client should be able to retrieve its own mail from remote servers as an
import function.

2: Sorting

Not only does this apply to what is already in the database, but also what
is coming into the database.  If the client must be able to import (retrieve)
messages from other servers it means it must also be able to filter them.

3: Export

Finally, what good is a database if you cannot take the data that is in it
and move it elsewhere.  SMTP provides this functionality.

4: Maintenance

Finally routines need to be provided for the maintenance of the database.
The ability to trim it of cruft, move records around, 

Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-01-17 Thread Alexander V. Kiselev

Hi there!

On 19 Nov 99, at 16:37, Steve Lamb wrote
about "(SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and al":

 Now, as always, I'm sure someone like Alex could come up and point out
 where I am wrong, but this is my understanding of these terms, why I use them
 in the way that I do and how they shape my thoughts and views on the whole
 technical and social mechanisms of email.

Okay, okay, you're quite right, and here is a gift to you:
http://www.infradig.com
Hope you'll like it:-) Besides, it's free...

[snip]

 In Windows the problem is all of the clients implement too much.  For
 example, TB!, as stated, is an MUA, limited MTA, limited MDA, text editor,
 spell checker  LDAP client.  I feel that the text editor and spell checker
 should be left out entirely and only hooks into a text editor provided.  

Now tell me how you think this can be implemented in winDOS:-
) No way! M$ has done everything against it already, for if only 
M$ gave the programmers some ways to do so --- winDOS 
would become Linux the next day, and there would be no place 
for M$ on the market:-). Linux has such thing as "protocols" 
that make it possible to exchange data etc. in between 
specialized applications. Quite the contrary with winDOS. What 
do we have? OLE? Don't make me laugh! DDE? Well, but how 
many applications support DDE? MAPI? M$ has done 
everything it could to prevent MAPI from spreading (the 
interested people can try to read MAPI 1.0 specs:-. M$ 
gains money (lions share of it) by marketing all-in-one 
applications, buggy, unreliable, but which pretend to be able to 
do everything. Therefore they in fact tell their users "hey, use 
our apps -- and you'll need no other programs, and you'll have 
no need to *learn* how to do things". It's idiotic, yes, but this 
position resulted in crowds of "users" that do not want to learn 
*at all*. Once more, M$ makes money out of it, and you can do 
pretty little about it:-(

 The text editor would then not implement a spell check but,
 instead, provide hooks to call one.  In this way each person
 can use the editor they prefer and spell checker they prefer. 
 In fact, they could use the editor/spell checker across a
 variety of programs and in doing so have a consistent
 interface for those two portions across those programs as well
 as the ability to choose the best editor/spell checker for
 them.  

The only programs under WinDOS that do exactly this (but 
leave no choice to the users) is... guess what? Office+Outlook:-
)

 This would free up time for the authors of the mail client to
 work on the mail client instead of reimplementing an editor
 and a spell checker which will always be subpar to the editors
 and spell checkers from authors who are programming them and
 not them and an email client as well. 

In theory, I'm on your side. But this is all Linux ideology, and 
that's why Linux is great. But we live under WinDOS here:-(((

 In unix the problem is that most, if not all, of the clients implement too
 little.  Hardly any clients are as capable as TB! and PMMail98 on checking
 multiple, separate accounts.  

With IMAP you needn't it at all (when under Linux). Take Mutt, 
and voila!

[...]

 1: Import
 
 POP/IMAP/local spool files provide this functionality.  Therefore a proper
 email client should be able to retrieve its own mail from remote servers as an
 import function.
 
 2: Sorting
 
 Not only does this apply to what is already in the database, but also what
 is coming into the database.  If the client must be able to import (retrieve)
 messages from other servers it means it must also be able to filter them.
 
 3: Export
 
 Finally, what good is a database if you cannot take the data that is in it
 and move it elsewhere.  SMTP provides this functionality.
 
 4: Maintenance
 
 Finally routines need to be provided for the maintenance of the database.
 The ability to trim it of cruft, move records around, perform backups and so
 forth.

And now go and check the url I've provided above:-) But under 
WinDOS this won't help you a lot, will it? 

[...]


SY, Alex
(St.Petersburg, Russia)
-- 
Thought for the day:
  Beware of low-flying butterflies.

--- 
PGP public keys on keyservers:
0xA2194BF9 (RSA);   0x214135A2 (DH/DSS)
fingerprints:
F222 4AEF EC9F 5FA6  7515 910A 2429 9CB1 (RSA)
A677 81C9 48CF 16D1 B589  9D33 E7D5 675F 2141 35A2 (DH/DSS) 
--- 

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-01-17 Thread Steve Lamb

Monday, November 22, 1999, 5:23:01 PM, Alexander wrote:
 The text editor would then not implement a spell check but,

 The only programs under WinDOS that do exactly this (but 
 leave no choice to the users) is... guess what? Office+Outlook:-
 )

Quite the contrary, PMMail.  ;)

 This would free up time for the authors of the mail client to
 work on the mail client instead of reimplementing an editor

 In theory, I'm on your side. But this is all Linux ideology, and 
 that's why Linux is great. But we live under WinDOS here:-(((

In theory it is great and in practice it is, too.  Sure, we live in WinDOS
here but it doesn't mean we cannot take the high points of the other world and
incorporate them here.  Like I said, I like how TB! and PMMail handle multiple
accounts.  There is nothing as elegant and power in the Unix world.  I'm
certainly not one to sit on that side of the fence and say "Hey, that's great
in Windows, but we live under Linux."

http://sourceforge.net/project/?form_grp=273

 In unix the problem is that most, if not all, of the clients implement too
 little.  Hardly any clients are as capable as TB! and PMMail98 on checking
 multiple, separate accounts.  

 With IMAP you needn't it at all (when under Linux). Take Mutt, and voila!

Take mutt and do what?  Btw, you might want to check the many, MANY posts
I've made on the topic on www.deja.com before answering that.  Chances are,
I've already addressed what you may me thinking of several times over.
Needless to say, mutt, while an excellent single-user, single-account MUA is
utterly outclassed compared to PMMail/TB! when it comes to multiple accounts.

 And now go and check the url I've provided above:-) But under
 WinDOS this won't help you a lot, will it? 

Cool, postie.  Actually, I used postie to send out turns for a Stars! game
that I hosted quite a while ago.  That and a batch file was all I need to send
out news postings and turn files for my game of 5-6 people.  One could do a
lot with postie and perl if one was so inclined.

-- 
 Steve C. Lamb | I'm your priest, I'm your shrink, I'm your
 ICQ: 5107343  | main connection to the switchboard of souls.
---+-

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-01-17 Thread Thomas Fernandez

Hi Alexander,

on Tuesday, November 23, 1999, 9:23:01 AM GMT+0800, Alexander V. Kiselev wrote:
[...]

Your machine is three days fast and I can never find your messages
until after someone has replied already and I go looking. Kindly
check. ;-)

-- 

Thanks,
Thomas.  

Message reply created with The Bat! 1.38 Beta/1
under Chinese Windows 98 4.10 Build 1998  
on a Pentium II/350 MHz.



-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--




Re[2]: (SOT) Moo-ah, Met-ah, Med-ah and all related things...

1999-01-17 Thread Watcher

-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA1

Friday, November 19, 1999, 11:31:07 PM, Thomas wrote:
 Hi Steve,

 on Saturday, November 20, 1999, 8:37:02 AM GMT+0800, Steve Lamb
 wrote:  

SL MUA stands for Mail Use Agent or Messaging User Agent.  MTA
is for Mail
SL Transfer agent.  There is a third, MDA, which stands for Mail
Delivery Agent.

 [very good explanation skipped}

 For all those who have put Steve on the kill filter, please note
 that you've missed something very educational.  

  Yes, this is the problem with people like Steve, they aren't
stupid,
just very irritating.  You have to balance if the information
received
is worth the anti-social behavior that generally accompanies it.
  I'd also like to note that from my experience a "Steve" ages very
well and becomes a considerable asset.  I can't wait!  8^)
  Generally speaking if a "Steve" does make some good points someone
that is willing to deal with his behavior will comment on it and the
rest of us will get the good parts without the bad parts via quoted
replies.
  Thank you for being willing to be that person.

SL A lot of people have argued that an editor and a spell
checker (for
SL example) are required in producing mail and thus should be
reimplemented by
SL the authors of each individual email client.  A lot of other
people argue that
SL separate tasks should be handled by separate programs.  So how
do I reconcile
SL the need to combine some tasks (MUA/MTA/MDA) but not others
(editor/spell
SL checker) into an email client?

 FYI rumours have it that the well-advertised Version 2 will have an
 option "use external editor". I think you will agree with me that
 this would make everybody happy.

  I agree, the more a program is based on hooks into the code and the
more modular the code the more customizable it will be and in general
the better the program will be accepted because it can be customized
to meet "my" needs.

- -- 
Watcher aka Bill DeVos |[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 http://www.aack.net/  | http://www.aack.net/watcher
- -
Fine day to work off excess energy.  Steal something heavy.
- -

-BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-
Version: PGP 6.5i

iQA/AwUBODYpsm14vvNVqX4UEQIPkgCfRB8khmNRV0jGqVBFHlXJv4RkexMAoMMn
7I4N44MFZ3C7Qm83H9aiezGy
=lrAm
-END PGP SIGNATURE-

-- 
--
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--