[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-04 Thread Stefan Wagener
- Original Message - From: Peter Guelzow peter.guel...@kourou.de To: amsat-bb@amsat.org Sent: Sunday, June 03, 2012 12:57 AM Subject: [amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations Hi together, Please also have a look at this document: http://wsn.spaceflight.esa.int

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-04 Thread i8cvs
, June 04, 2012 9:26 AM Subject: Re: [amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations Thanks folks, That's a very helpful and constructive discussion. It will certainly allow for better assessment of the feasibility, options and limitations. Stefan, VE4NSA On Sat, Jun 2

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-04 Thread Jari Koivurinne
Hi all There is nothing much to do with 20W mean power. Just a 5W pep beacon... -jari oh3uw Hi Stefan VE4NSA, Peter DB2OS and folks on BB It should be very nice to have a transponder on the Lunar Lander operating into the X/K band 10,5 GHz Uplink and 24 GHz downlink. As on AO40 the

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread Jari Koivurinne
I disagree about having to have a EME class station if we put a transponder on the moon. The reason being, since the same side is always facing the earth, a directional high gain antenna may be used on the transponder itself! Lee W5LMM How big antenna and what band should be used?

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest

2012-06-02 Thread Robert G Oler
probe P5A to Mars,figure out to place an amateur radio transponder on the Moon. 73 de i8CVS Domenico - Original Message - From: Stefan Wagener To: i8cvs Cc: Amsat - BBs Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:48 PM Subject: Re: [amsat-bb] European Lunar Lander - Call

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest

2012-06-02 Thread pughkeithd
Do you really mean a deplorable antenna? 73 - Keith, W5IU -Original Message- From: Robert G Oler orbit...@hotmail.com To: i8cvs domenico.i8...@tin.it Cc: Amsat - BBs amsat-bb@amsat.org Sent: Sat, Jun 2, 2012 1:44 pm Subject: [amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread i8cvs
- Original Message - From: Bob- W7LRD w7...@comcast.net To: STeve Andre' and...@msu.edu Cc: amsat-bb@amsat.org Sent: Saturday, June 02, 2012 7:16 AM Subject: [amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations Just for the fun of it I'd like to see an accurate link budget

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread Bob- W7LRD
: Saturday, June 2, 2012 2:12:26 PM Subject: [ amsat -bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations - Original Message - From: Bob- W7LRD w7...@comcast.net To: STeve Andre' andres @ msu . edu Cc: amsat -bb@ amsat .org Sent: Saturday, June 02, 2012 7:16 AM Subject: [ amsat -bb

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread W4ART Arthur Feller
Check http://www.amsatuk.me.uk/iaru/spreadsheet.htm for a detailed link budget spreadsheet, with accompanying explanations. 73, art….. W4ART Arlington VA On 2-Jun-2012, at 01:16 AM, Bob- W7LRD wrote: Just for the fun of it I'd like to see an accurate link budget written up. It is a

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread Peter Guelzow
Check also this discussion from James Miller, G3RUH: http://www.amsat.org/amsat/articles/g3ruh/110.html 73s Peter, DB2OS ___ Sent via AMSAT-BB@amsat.org. Opinions expressed are those of the author. Not an AMSAT-NA member? Join now

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread Peter Guelzow
Hi together, Please also have a look at this document: http://wsn.spaceflight.esa.int/docs/lunarlander/LunarLander_EIDA_CDI_230512.pdf in particular see point 2.2.2 Communication and 2.2.3: Visibility of the Earth from the landing site imposes the following constraint: • communications shall

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread Robert McGwier
That can't be quite right. A gain antenna can be put on the moon but its half power beam width will be limited by libration. If we put a 2.401 GHz dish on the thing we could easily stay inside the HPBW and likely not need much power for a decent signal into a small dish on the earth. The

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-02 Thread i8cvs
should be possible. 73 de i8CVS Domenico - Original Message - From: Peter Guelzow peter.guel...@kourou.de To: amsat-bb@amsat.org Sent: Sunday, June 03, 2012 12:57 AM Subject: [amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations Hi together, Please also have a look at this document

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-01 Thread Daniel Schultz
Keep in mind that any ham radio transponder on the moon will not be an easy sat. You will need an EME class station to work it. If we build a lunar transponder, we can expect to see many, many postings on Amsat-BB about how Amsat only cares about elite hams and is not interested in building

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-01 Thread Stefan Wagener
Thanks Dan, Point well taken. Now, keep in mind we can find 1001 reasons why not. On the other hand, how about reasons to do it? How many times will we ever get a free ride to the moon surface? At this stage we need to declare our interest and yes ITAR is a potential problem. However, how about

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-01 Thread STeve Andre'
On 06/01/12 19:54, Daniel Schultz wrote: Keep in mind that any ham radio transponder on the moon will not be an easy sat. You will need an EME class station to work it. If we build a lunar transponder, we can expect to see many, many postings on Amsat-BB about how Amsat only cares about elite

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations

2012-06-01 Thread Bob- W7LRD
: STeve Andre' and...@msu.edu To: amsat-bb@amsat.org Sent: Friday, June 1, 2012 9:20:35 PM Subject: [amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations On 06/01/12 19:54, Daniel Schultz wrote: Keep in mind that any ham radio transponder on the moon will not be an easy sat. You

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest

2012-05-31 Thread i8cvs
Hi Stefan, VE4NSA It does not make sense to put a transponder on the Moon just for the simple reason that it's much more, simple and cheap to put it into earth orbit. 73 de i8CVS Domenico - Original Message - From: Stefan Wagener wagen...@gmail.com To: Amsat - BBs amsat-bb@amsat.org

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest

2012-05-31 Thread Stefan Wagener
Yes Domenico, You are correct. However, that particular ESA proposal is not about putting it into orbit. It is an opportunity to have a payload placed on the moon. Once ESA has a proposal to put something into orbit, by all means. Hope this helps, Stefan On Thu, May 31, 2012 at 9:31 AM, i8cvs

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest

2012-05-31 Thread i8cvs
an amateur radio transponder on the Moon. 73 de i8CVS Domenico - Original Message - From: Stefan Wagener To: i8cvs Cc: Amsat - BBs Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:48 PM Subject: Re: [amsat-bb] European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest Yes Domenico

[amsat-bb] Re: European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest

2012-05-31 Thread Stefan Wagener
...@tin.it *Cc:* Amsat - BBs amsat-bb@amsat.org *Sent:* Thursday, May 31, 2012 4:48 PM *Subject:* Re: [amsat-bb] European Lunar Lander - Call for Declarations of Interest Yes Domenico, You are correct. However, that particular ESA proposal is not about putting it into orbit. It is an opportunity