Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-04 Thread Thomas Eckardt
: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted I've longed for this for ages, but always thought Thomas was too busy to implement it :) however, I think it should work alongside GH's idea of a blacklist. However, what will happen with multiple recepients? Eg. 1 person marks an address

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-04 Thread Thomas Eckardt
But, if adding this feature has a major impact on performance, There is no major impact on performance! Thomas Von:Charles Marcus cmar...@media-brokers.com An: assp-test@lists.sourceforge.net Datum: 03.05.2010 17:00 Betreff:Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-04 Thread Thomas Eckardt
-test@lists.sourceforge.net Datum: 03.05.2010 16:02 Betreff:Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted There is a major change in the code that uses a personal Whitelist, which works as follows: Thomas... it's fine, but adds a lot of overhead imHo; it would suffice knowing

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-04 Thread GrayHat
someone doesn't want to receive some messages (s)he may just add a given sender to his/her personal BL (which will probably be smaller) But this (personal blacklist) is provided by every mail client - or not? That's different; if you do it at client level then you'll have to accept the

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-04 Thread Thomas Eckardt
: 04.05.2010 12:19 Betreff:Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted someone doesn't want to receive some messages (s)he may just add a given sender to his/her personal BL (which will probably be smaller) But this (personal blacklist) is provided by every mail client

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-04 Thread Steve Mallindine
So, the 99 users who believe that the message is black should each add a rule (in the case of outlook/exchange) or add to personal BL because of 1 minority guy who believes it should be white? (And in the case of multiple recepients, this 1 guy wouldn't get it anyway) Sorry, but it reminds

[Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread Thomas Eckardt
I've uploaded a 2.0.2_1.1.02_p-white.pl to the 'test' folder on SF-CVS. There is a major change in the code that uses a personal Whitelist, which works as follows: - if a Whitelist addition is done - also a personal entry is written in to the Whitelist

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread GrayHat
There is a major change in the code that uses a personal Whitelist, which works as follows: Thomas... it's fine, but adds a lot of overhead imHo; it would suffice knowing who added a given entry to the whitelits so that, in case a client box gets crazy (for whatever reason) it will be easy

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread Thomas Eckardt
;) It kinda drives me nuts. ** Thomas Von:GrayHat gray...@gmx.net An: ASSP development mailing list assp-test@lists.sourceforge.net Datum: 03.05.2010 16:02 Betreff:Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted There is a major change in the code

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread Thomas Eckardt
development mailing list assp-test@lists.sourceforge.net Datum: 03.05.2010 16:02 Betreff:Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted There is a major change in the code that uses a personal Whitelist, which works as follows: Thomas... it's fine, but adds a lot of overhead imHo

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread Charles Marcus
On 2010-05-03 10:43 AM, Thomas Eckardt wrote: The reason for the whitelist was, that everyone who receives a block report, is able to whitelist addresses - and maybe there is someone who don't want these addresses whitelisted. Public blacklisting is not so common (I think). +1 But, if

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread Alan McNeil
I've run into this too when running an ISP. In my case I only blacklisted domains that were know to be sending viruses, thinking that was helpful. The next day several real estate agents called and wanting their (infected) daily astrology report emails! So that was a case of a global blacklist

Re: [Assp-test] test for personal whitelist wanted

2010-05-03 Thread Steve Mallindine
I've longed for this for ages, but always thought Thomas was too busy to implement it :) however, I think it should work alongside GH's idea of a blacklist. However, what will happen with multiple recepients? Eg. 1 person marks an address as whitelisted, everyone else consideres the address