Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Patching
Hi Geoff, I thought incidents and accidents were reported. At least those which are reported in the first place. I am a little ambivilent to them being published in Soaring Australia other than brief reports and a web location where people can access a fuller report. I would also suggest that

[Aus-soaring] B 57 For Sale (WAS: *Subject:* B 50 varios)

2005-11-01 Thread Peter and Mandy Temple
We happen to have a B57 Super glide computer surplus to needs. So if anyone wants to put the B50 and B57 together to make a system we're open to offers for the B57. Or if someone already has a B50 please make us an offer for the B57. The cost of the B57 new was $1000. Mandy and Peter Temple --

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread McLean Richard
Hi guys, You can add me as a yes to the poll question too. I think the issue may hinge on how we get these reports ... which is probably closely related to the potential defamation/liability issues eluded to by ops. Putting all the gory details in the magazine is probably not the best idea from a

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Geoff Kidd
Richard . ,       To be clear on what I have requested from the Board, I am not advocating anything gory, nor am I advocating names or aircraft rego or specific details on location or specific aircraft type. But what I do say is needed is sufficient description and generic definition of

[Aus-soaring] Re: Aus-soaring Digest, Vol 26, Issue 2

2005-11-01 Thread Lindsay Mitchell
_   Aus-soaring mailing list   Aus-soaring@lists.internode.on.net   To check or change subscription details, visit:   http://lists.internode.on.net/mailman/listinfo/aus-soaring -- next part -- An HTML attachment was scrubbed.

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread DJ Olsen Photo
GA has been doing this for yearsI don't understand the objectionsOn 01/11/2005, at 9:05 PM, Geoff Kidd wrote: Richard . ,       To be clear on what I have requested from the Board, I am not advocating anything gory, nor am I advocating names or aircraft rego or specific details on location or s

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Mark Newton
McLean Richard wrote: You can add me as a yes to the poll question too. I think the issue may hinge on how we get these reports ... which is probably closely related to the potential defamation/liability issues eluded to by ops. Putting all the gory details in the magazine is probably not the be

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Mark Newton
McLean Richard wrote: I came back to gliding 6 years ago & have since been alarmed at the lack of 'safety consciousness' there is in gliding ops compared to other forms of aviation that I have experienced (GA & military). I think a large part of that is due to the fact that we no longer read reg

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread DJ Olsen Photo
Mark You seem to have mastered being a one man debating show Seems to me your second email was a damn fine rebuttal of your first. :-) Cheers David ___ Aus-soaring mailing list Aus-soaring@lists.internode.on.net To check or change subscription d

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Mark Newton
DJ Olsen Photo wrote: You seem to have mastered being a one man debating show Seems to me your second email was a damn fine rebuttal of your first. :-) How? I don't see any inconsistency: Both messages advocate a point of view which claims that the usefulness of regular publication of accide

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread McLean Richard
All good points. I think the bottom line is that we keep killing ourselves in the same consistently boring ways because these things that kill us (without the benefit of hindsight) are not often very obvious or visible at the time. Writing about them makes them more visible - we can all get complac

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Mark Newton
McLean Richard wrote: Writing about them makes them more visible - we can all get complacent. Pilots may find it hard to relate the little tidbits he/she does hear about potential deadly habits or omissions to their own flying until they actually see /hear of it happening or read about it. The

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Don Ingram
I strongly agree with Richard on this issue. Material presented with the aim of increasing safety is duly digested and stored away, hopefully increasing ones level of safe behaviour. The crash comics however seem to have far more bite, the material presented is chillingly real & often gives on

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread DJ Olsen Photo
>Now, think about this: If we can agree that writing about this stuff is a worthwhile exercise, what's the better investment in effort? Waiting for an actual accident to happen where someone really gets hurt and writing about it post-mortem, or making use of the fact that we already know what th

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Mark Newton
Don Ingram wrote: Material presented with the aim of increasing safety is duly digested and stored away, hopefully increasing ones level of safe behaviour. The crash comics however seem to have far more bite, the material presented is chillingly real & often gives one reason to pause and conside

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Peter Creswick
In the FLYING magazine of many years past, there used to be (may still be - I haven't bought one for years) a column called "I learned about flying from that ...". The Air Safety Digest runs a similar series, ie, short stories on "dramas". Some time ago, there was also a thread on aus.aviatio

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Geoff Kidd
Mark       You said "But FSA has the resources to do the publication properly, with more depth, and with analysis from aviation safety experts (instead of what some people in this thread have advocated, which is producing a few paragraphs of summary raw data in the mag and making everyone rea

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Robert Hart
Mark Newton wrote: Every pilot bears the responsibility to improve upon that situation. GFA can't help, CASA can't help, it's a self-regulatory system and it's all down to us. Mark I disagree with you in a number of areas, but we've been over those before and rehashing them now isn'

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Robert Hart
Mark Newton wrote: Now, think about this:  If we can agree that writing about this stuff is a worthwhile exercise, what's the better investment in effort? Waiting for an actual accident to happen where someone really gets hurt and writing about it post-mortem, or making use of the fact

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Michael Shirley
Hi Guys & Gals   Learn from the mistakes of others. You will not live long enough to make them all yourself! Cheers Michael Shirley   - Original Message - From: Geoff Kidd To: Discussion of issues relating to Soaring in Australia. Sent: Tuesday, November 01, 2005 10

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Emilis Prelgauskas
On Tue, 01 Nov 2005 22:08:53 +1030, Mark Newton wrote: What are you people really hoping to >get out of it?   The regular reminder that us pilots have feet of clay, and there by the grace of God (except perhaps for the AUGC CFI who is better positioned in that hierarchy than the rest o

[Aus-soaring] Seven hours in a Grob

2005-11-01 Thread Robert Hart
For the week 24 - 28 October, I was duty instructor for Caboolture Gliding Club's cross country week at Darling Downs Soaring Club. Unfortunately the weather was rather uncooperative, even though we flew every day. Thunder storms were the order of the day - with the storm on Monday evening bein

[Aus-soaring] Accident and Incident Reporting

2005-11-01 Thread VHGNJ
I'm a CFI; whenever there is an accident I'm asked what happened. Our members expect that I should be up to date with the safety situation in our sport, they're right to do so. I would like to see a restricted email list introduced wherein current information regarding very recent accidents ca

Re: [Aus-soaring] Accident and Incident Reporting

2005-11-01 Thread DJ Olsen Photo
I would like to see that expanded to include "incidents" reported to those instructors On 02/11/2005, at 2:51 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm a CFI; whenever there is an accident I'm asked what happened. Our members expect that I should be up to date with the safety situation in our spo

Re: [Aus-soaring] ACCIDENT & INCIDENT REPORTING

2005-11-01 Thread Peter Stephenson
I gained the same impression as Dave did! :-) I read Flight Safety almost in preference to Soaring Australia (SA) as it has good articles. It used to have precis of all the accidents/incidents including gliders all of which I used to read religiously. It is a shame they have ceased them but GFA