Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread Richard Lockwood
Until you show me that your site isn't just a waste of bandwidth, however, you're Adblocked. If a site's a waste of bandwidth, what are you doing visiting in the first place? Making his evaluation? Don't criticise something without first knowing what you're on about, etc etc. Surely

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread vijay chopra
On 27/02/07, Richard Lockwood [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Until you show me that your site isn't just a waste of bandwidth, however, you're Adblocked. If a site's a waste of bandwidth, what are you doing visiting in the first place? Making his evaluation? Don't criticise

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
vijay chopra wrote: Take a site like slashdot, I visit, I like the content, so I decide to white-list. However I find the ads over intrusive so I put it back on the black list, Do you subscribe to slashdot? One of the perks of slashdot membership is you don't get ads. Scot - Sent

RE: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread Sebastian Potter
Not really, why do I need to see a sites ads to evaluate it's content? Because the ads are an intrinsic part of the site's content. That's what the owner of the content has decided comprises the full work, and therefore that's what you have been granted permission to use. Consumer choice in

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread vijay chopra
On 27/02/07, Sebastian Potter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Not really, why do I need to see a sites ads to evaluate it's content? Because the ads are an intrinsic part of the site's content. That's what the owner of the content has decided comprises the full work, and therefore that's what you

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread Richard Lockwood
To be blunt if it's served to *my* PC I have every right to do as I wish with the content; the same as if I buy a book, I don't have to read it all, why is it different for a website? I don't have to read the adverts in magazines or newspapers no one considers those an intrinsic part of [their]

[backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jim Gardner
I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding the proposed iPlayer services which are only to be made available to people stupid enough to be using Windows - so that I can withhold that amount from my payment, or seek a refund of that amount back from the

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
Richard Lockwood wrote: I don't have to read the adverts in magazines or newspapers no one considers those an intrinsic part of [their] content No - but they're still there. You flick past them, and they don't annoy you by their very presence, which web ads appear to. Saying that, ads

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Daniel Morris
I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding the proposed iPlayer services which are only to be made available to people stupid enough to be using Windows - so that I can withhold that amount from my payment, or seek a refund of that amount back from the

RE: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread Andrew Bowden
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To be blunt if it's served to *my* PC I have every right to do as I wish with the content; the same as if I buy a book, I don't have to read it all, why is it different for a website? I don't have to read the adverts in magazines or newspapers no one

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
Jim Gardner wrote: I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding the proposed iPlayer services which are only to be made available to people stupid enough to be using Windows Are you certain Microsoft isn't funding it? I thought most of the Windows Media

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Peter Bowyer
On 27/02/07, Jason Cartwright [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This is all my personal point of view. I can't receive digital TV, so I'd like a refund on money spent to make BBC3 and BBC4. Oh, and I can't read welsh so could TV Licencing please send me a cheque for the money spend on

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Andrew Macinnes
I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding the proposed iPlayer services which are only to be made available to people stupid enough to be using Windows - so that I can withhold that amount from my payment, or seek a refund of that amount back from the

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Matthew Somerville
Jason Cartwright wrote: Oh, and I can't read welsh so could TV Licencing please send me a cheque for the money spend on http://www.bbc.co.uk/cymru/ Well, the pop-up Oes gennych chi 5 munud i roi eich barn am y safle hwn? (Have you got 5 minutes to fill in a survey on this site, or similar)

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
Jason Cartwright wrote: This is all my personal point of view. I can't receive digital TV, so I'd like a refund on money spent to make BBC3 and BBC4. Oh, and I can't read welsh so could TV Licencing please send me a cheque for the money spend on http://www.bbc.co.uk/cymru/ Didn't some

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Seb Potter
On 27/02/07, Jim Gardner [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding the proposed iPlayer services which are only to be made available to people stupid enough to be using Windows - so that I can withhold that amount from my payment, or

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread James Ockenden
I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding the proposed iPlayer services which are only to be made available to people stupid enough to be using Windows - so that I can withhold that amount from my payment, or seek a refund of that amount back from the BBC.

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Neil Aberdeen
I would like to I would like to know what percentage of my license fee will go towards funding of Seb Potter's employment - so that I can withhold that amount from my payment, or seek a refund of that amount back from the BBC. ;-) Seb Potter wrote: On 27/02/07, *Jim Gardner* [EMAIL

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Kenneth Burrell-CAPITA
Hi Which is like paying income tax for Health Service and then having to pay for prescriptions? ... Can someone suggest a way of how you could efficiently and effectively collect payment (s) that reflects all individuals use of BBC services and programmes? Annual packages or subscription based

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jeremy Stone
The cost of the BBC's On Demand proposals (including the iPlayer) are in the public domain anyway as part of our (BBC's) submission to the BBC Trust and the the resulting Public Value Assessment document. Its worth a look. In section 8 The proposals will cost the BBC an additional £131m

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jeremy Stone
Dear all Can I remind everyone that this is a public mailing list that is archived and searchable. Please keep civil to everyone. Yes even the ones that that harp on about DRM noon and night ;) Thanks Jem -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
Kenneth Burrell-CAPITA wrote: Hi Which is like paying income tax for Health Service and then having to pay for prescriptions? ... I can choose to go to Boots, or Tesco or one of any number of small chemists to get the prescription. I'm not forced into going to a single chemist, which

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jim Gardner
It would appear from this and other mails I've received that I have the same name as someone who has a track record for trolling. I can assure everyone on the list that this is the first thread this James Gardner has started or replied to on the backstage mailing list, and given the less

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Andrew Bowden
But then, both of those methods still leave the question - how do you pay for the unpopular, but worthy, programming? PPV - you split the programme budget between the expected number of viewers. As such, EastEnders being a programme with many viewers, would cost less than a documentary on

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jim Gardner
Thanks for a straight answer at last, it's appreciated. I'm sure Microsoft are desperately pleased with themselves for earning what ever percentage of that £131 million is theirs. You have to hand it to them, they certainly know how to charge people more money for less functionality.

[backstage] Coders needed for BBC Weather New Media

2007-02-27 Thread Kathryn Schmitt
Hi all, I just thought I'd mention that there are 2 jobs going in my team. One is for a Client-side coder (continuing contract), and the other is for a server-side coder (6 month contract initially). The closing date for both positions is tomorrow, 28th Feb (as in, 23:59). You can learn more

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jeremy Stone
Yes even the ones that that harp on about DRM noon and night ;) Actually the DRM discussions in recent weeks have been incredibly stimulating and provocative and much appreciated inside BBC towers and I hope for other subscribers. (I always knew I shouldn't try and make weak jokes on

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Peter Bowyer
On 27/02/07, Jim Gardner [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Being fairly new to the list I can only imagine that this DRM thing has dragged on a bit for some of the older members, but I would remind everyone that it's pretty much universally agreed that this is the biggest mistake the BBC have ever made -

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Dave Crossland
On 27/02/07, John Drinkwater [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I got similar comments from someone else off-list related to comments i've made here and on the BBC editors site. I'm sorry to hear that - I've been quite vocal about my non-mainstream opinions, and never received such comments. --

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
George Wright wrote: On Tue, 2007-02-27 at 18:09 +, Jim Gardner wrote: I'm sure Microsoft are desperately pleased with themselves for earning what ever percentage of that £131 million is theirs Programme ingest, programme creation, programme/contributor rights, content

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Jim Gardner
I never did understand keyboard heros. The fact is, if we where talking face to face in the pub, you wouldn't dream of being so obnoxious just because you think I'm wrong. Just because you can't counter my argument with anything doesn't give you the right to resort to the fail-safe, I've

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Christopher Woods
I would've hoped that the BBC listserver either washes those kind of emails or returns them to sender. -Original Message- From: Jim Gardner [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 27 February 2007 19:20 To: backstage@lists.bbc.co.uk Subject: Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going

[backstage] Coders needed for BBC Weather New Media

2007-02-27 Thread Kathryn Schmitt
Sorry, I seem to have messed up with the tinyurls I gave in my previous post. Here are the links in their gory splendour: https://jobs.bbc.co.uk/fe/tpl_bbc01.asp?s=HqSpVAxKiZLqNnZifjobid=13564, 2395596535key=1658236c=653525135614pagestamp=sehoeqelevzzvayuna

[backstage] Bug report: backstage.bbc.co.uk

2007-02-27 Thread James Cridland
On http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/ there's a blog, and the main item of the blog is currently 'More Twitter Hacks and BBC Goodness'. Click the headline, to be rewarded by a 404 error. (Or, worse, click the 'see original' link in the RSS feed to be rewarded by a 404 error). And now I can't blog

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking (was: HD-DVD how DRM was defeated)

2007-02-27 Thread James Cridland
On 2/26/07, Andrew Bowden [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Probably even worse. Your hurting the website even more - lowering the CTR [1] by registering an impression, yet user has no opportunity to click. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_Through_Rate Depends if you ever click ads...

Re: [backstage] Ad Blocking

2007-02-27 Thread James Cridland
On 2/27/07, vijay chopra [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Take a site like slashdot, I visit, I like the content, so I decide to white-list. However I find the ads over intrusive so I put it back on the black list Ah. Other people might get irritated with the ads and therefore not go back to

Re: [backstage] A couple of things including Arrington

2007-02-27 Thread James Cridland
On 2/27/07, Dave Crossland [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The fact you deliberately linked to a torrent site - thus removing the chance of the oscar winners to earn money from their films Well done, Dave. Don't you owe me a drink? ;) -- http://james.cridland.net/

Re: [backstage] Tube on Twitter

2007-02-27 Thread Davy Mitchell
Mornington Crescent. -- Davy Mitchell Blog - http://www.latedecember.co.uk/sites/personal/davy/ Twitter - http://twitter.com/daftspaniel Skype - daftspaniel - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group. To unsubscribe, please visit

RE: [backstage] Bug report: backstage.bbc.co.uk

2007-02-27 Thread Matthew Cashmore
Joy :-) - Thanks for pointing that out James will try to sort now - I hate MT. m -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of James Cridland Sent: Tue 27/02/2007 20:38 To: backstage@lists.bbc.co.uk Subject: [backstage] Bug report: backstage.bbc.co.uk On

RE: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Matthew Cashmore
Hi David - we're looking into this issue - we'll let you know what we're going to do :-) m -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of Dave Crossland Sent: Tue 27/02/2007 14:44 To: backstage@lists.bbc.co.uk; Matthew Cashmore; Ian Forrester Subject: Re: [backstage]

Re: [backstage] Percentage of License fee going towards DRM?

2007-02-27 Thread Mr I Forrester
Hi welcome to the list Jim, Can I suggest you lurk a little more before posting more. It tends to be bad form to complain at such a early stage :) Cheers, Ian Forrester Jim Gardner wrote: I'm not exactly over-the-moon about the idea that everyone's private email address is visible. What

RE: [backstage] Tube on Twitter

2007-02-27 Thread Christopher Woods
Hang on, are we playing Finsbury Rules here? -Original Message- From: Davy Mitchell [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 27 February 2007 22:43 To: backstage@lists.bbc.co.uk Subject: Re: [backstage] Tube on Twitter Mornington Crescent. -- Davy Mitchell Blog -