RE: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-24 Thread Haakon Claassen (hclaasse)
) -Original Message- From: Priscilla Oppenheimer [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: maandag 23 september 2002 20:45 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852] In what ways was the SIP equipment better? The fact that it comes from a www/internet IETF world, versus H.323 which comes

RE: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-24 Thread Clubb, Steven
Can you forward that link? Thanks, Steve -Original Message- From: Haakon Claassen (hclaasse) [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Tuesday, September 24, 2002 10:19 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: SIP vs H323 [7:53852] I am not THE expert on these matters but it comes to play in my

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-23 Thread Gunjan Mathur
I tested one SIP equipement of vonage, and that was far far better then any device using H323...that's the reason I want to know the diff in between these two. What I understand is SIP model works on www/internet and h323 model is telephony, I believe this is the main reason for the quality

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-23 Thread Steven A. Ridder
The signalling protocol used to set-up/tear-down a converstation wouldn't affect the quality of the voice. Maybe the equipment you used was superior, or was on a low latency network. Gunjan Mathur wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... I tested one SIP equipement of

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-23 Thread Priscilla Oppenheimer
In what ways was the SIP equipment better? The fact that it comes from a www/internet IETF world, versus H.323 which comes from the ITU, wouldn't necessarily mean that it's better. In fact, to make a very broad generalization, the IETF has historically been involved with data networking which

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-23 Thread Chuck's Long Road
Priscilla Oppenheimer wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... In what ways was the SIP equipment better? The fact that it comes from a www/internet IETF world, versus H.323 which comes from the ITU, wouldn't necessarily mean that it's better. In fact, to make a very

SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-22 Thread Gunjan Mathur
Hi, Is Cisco 2600 series support SIP? if yes, Please forward the web link if any... What is the main differance in between SIP H323, which gives better quality of output? TIA __ Do you Yahoo!? New DSL Internet Access from SBC Yahoo!

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-22 Thread Steven A. Ridder
h.323 is more robust, but more complicated (both to develop for and learn). SIP is new and easy, but useless right now. There's more security in h,323 right now. -- RFC 1149 Compliant. Gunjan Mathur wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... Hi, Is Cisco 2600 series

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-22 Thread Jason Weden
Ok, so SIP is nowhere near useless. It is being used all over the place and will eventually replace H.323. Telcos like Vonage (which uses Cisco SIP equipment), deltathree, and Denwa are using it for last mile telephony connectivity for residences and enterprises, and WorldCom, after surfacing

Re: SIP vs H323 [7:53852]

2002-09-22 Thread Steven A. Ridder
I agree that SIP is the future, it just isn't there yet. There is some SIP being built into Unity and CM, but until everything is SIP (as opposed to MGCP/H.323 and Skinny), it just isn't useful yet. I know that SIP is being deployed in SP networks, and I have implemented it in a Telco, but for