Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-27 Thread Prudy L
-Caveat Lector- In a message dated 9/27/2002 12:43:29 AM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Why you would expect individual Jews to act in a moral maner than you would expect of others is beyond me. Strange you should think I do.  I do not.  There are few who measure up to my exp

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-26 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- Prudy, I only speak for myself. I am in the unfortunate postion of having read both pro and con material and having researched the New Age movement. I cannot jump into the pro-Israel or anti- Israel points of view. I do not defend everything Israel has done, nor do I jump int

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-26 Thread Prudy L
-Caveat Lector- In a message dated 9/22/2002 12:00:13 AM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I'm paraphrasing the little hen who said "Then I will eat it all by myself"  and the ant who told the lazy grasshopper "Sorry bub."  On a more serious note, I don't think Jews should find the

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-21 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- I'm paraphrasing the little hen who said "Then I will eat it all by myself"  and the ant who told the lazy grasshopper "Sorry bub."  On a more serious note, I don't think Jews should find themselves again victim to the "Covet, Steal, Kill" pattern that was played out against them i

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-21 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- >If I had a say in the matter, I would make sure anything the Palestinians >were to take over would be leveled to the ground before they ever >touched any part of it and I would make sure they knew it was going to >happen. They would know in advance that noting good will come of

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-21 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- (1)> Yes. Thank you for your brilliant insight. Of course it is the > parent's fault, not the Israeli soldiers who shoot live ammo > into a peaceful demonstration of school children. Poor > Israeli soldiers - yes, of course, they are the victims. (2)> Of course. Those all powerfu

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-21 Thread Prudy L
-Caveat Lector- In a message dated 9/20/2002 9:43:37 AM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: It's not as if they were against Netanyahu because they didn't like the way he cut his hair and that's what the protest was about. Had Netanyahu wanted to talk about men's tonsorial issues,

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-20 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- >Parents who let their children be used as barricades are the >guilty ones. Yes. Thank you for your brilliant insight. Of course it is the parent's fault, not the Israeli soldiers who shoot live ammo into a peaceful demonstration of school children. Poor Israeli soldiers - yes, o

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-20 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- > What kind of parents would permit their children to become soldiers > that shoot school children? This same question was asked of the > parents of WWII German soldiers. Israeli soldiers are not just facing school children, they are facing the adults who put the children up fron

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-20 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > What kind of parents allow their children to be front lines against Israeli troops? > People who want to use the decency of their opponents against their opponents. What kind of parents would permit their children to become soldiers that shoot school children? This same questio

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-20 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- > Good grief. Can't you allow reality to get in the way of a good cliche. The mob at >Concordia was a pro-Palestinian mob. It's not as if they were against Netanyahu >because they didn't like the way he cut his hair and that's what the protest was >about. As far as the chil

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-20 Thread Prudy L
-Caveat Lector- In a message dated 9/19/2002 11:07:42 PM Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > > Your name calling is very much like the primitive response of the > pro-Palestinian > > mob at Concordia. It is a common mistake to believe that people who are not pro-Israeli are pro-Pa

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-19 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- What kind of parents allow their children to be front lines against Israeli troops? People who want to use the decency of their opponents against their opponents. If they believed that all of their children would be shot down, they wouldn't put their children in front of themselv

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-19 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- > Your "if" comment is strictly speculation based on what you believe would happen. > Your name calling is very much like the primitive response of the pro-Palestinian > mob at Concordia. And yes, civilized people do back off when confronted with > people who seem primitive and o

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-19 Thread thew
-Caveat Lector- Sorry Charlie The violence was at the anti- Netanyahu protest. The protest against the Palestinian speaker was peaceful, and he was allowed to speak. Netanyahu , who is a dangerous rabid rightwing asshole, was not allowed to speak. If you don't let the Nazi's march in Skokie, y

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-19 Thread Zuukie
-Caveat Lector- It's a good idea to read carefully about the real world and not just try to tie things into one's preconceived notions. The violent rioters were the pro-Palestinian mob, who were brought in and may not have all been part of the university community. A search on the web indicated

Re: [CTRL] Freedom of speech (for Nazis?)

2002-09-19 Thread flw
-Caveat Lector- >Montreal protesters force cancellation of Netanyahu campus speech > The scene as we exited was disgusting. Benches were overturned, papers > and garbage streaked across the hallways, and broken windows. We were > shoved outside directly into a HUGE Palestinian riot, where some