Re: [DISCUSS] A proposal for migration to GitHub issue (LUCENE-10557)

2022-05-06 Thread Tomoko Uchida
Thanks Gus, for providing the clear pros/cons list and posing an objection. I welcome constructive criticism that strengthens our discussion. Among the informative list, I'd highlight a new perspective I haven't seen so far (and honestly, I haven't considered): Security issues that are visible to

Re: [DISCUSS] A proposal for migration to GitHub issue (LUCENE-10557)

2022-05-06 Thread Gus Heck
I think both tools have their merits and drawbacks What I like about Jira: - It has ample room and configuration for issue metadata and customizable workflows and in general a deep feature set - It has user roles, PMC members can see security issues that are hidden from the world...

Re: XML retrieval with Intervals

2022-05-06 Thread Alan Woodward
I *think* it would be possible to write an IntervalsSource implementation that took opening and closing tags, and did the right thing here - as you say, a standard `contains` will try and minimise things, but you could write something that attempted to match an opening tag with its

Re: XML retrieval with Intervals

2022-05-06 Thread Michael Sokolov
+1 MarkLogic is an excellent product. This Lux thing was inspired by it. On Fri, May 6, 2022 at 11:29 AM Walter Underwood wrote: > > If you need to search XML, consider MarkLogic. It is a very full-featured > database and search engine based on XML. > > https://www.marklogic.com > > Disclaimer:

Re: XML retrieval with Intervals

2022-05-06 Thread Walter Underwood
If you need to search XML, consider MarkLogic. It is a very full-featured database and search engine based on XML. https://www.marklogic.com Disclaimer: I worked there for a couple of years ten years ago. But I’ve been inside that product and it is non-muggle technology. wunder Walter

Re: [DISCUSS] A proposal for migration to GitHub issue (LUCENE-10557)

2022-05-06 Thread Michael McCandless
On Thu, May 5, 2022 at 7:56 AM Robert Muir wrote: As far as replies, in github I highlight the part of the thing i want > to reply to, and press 'r' key on my keyboard. it quotes it and > everything. Really convenient to me. > Whoa, thank you!! I had no idea GitHub has such extensive keyboard

Re: XML retrieval with Intervals

2022-05-06 Thread Michael Sokolov
Many years ago I had started this Lux project that was designed to build an XML-aware index using Solr; see https://github.com/msokolov/lux/tree/master/src/main/java/lux/index/analysis for the analysis chain I used. Maybe you'll find something useful in this project? It's dormant for years, and

XML retrieval with Intervals

2022-05-06 Thread Mikhail Khludnev
Hi Devs! I found intervals quite nice and natural for retrieving scoped data (thanks, Alan!): foo stuff bar I.containing(I.ordered(I.term(""), I.term("")), I.unordered(I.term("bar"), I.term("foo"))); It works like a charm until it encounter ill nested tags: foo bug bar Due

Re: [DISCUSS] A proposal for migration to GitHub issue (LUCENE-10557)

2022-05-06 Thread Tomoko Uchida
Thanks, Jan for your suggestion - I'd defer the discussion for the options to contribute from outside GitHub for now, but we'll come back to this later and we'll find some good ways (if the coming possible vote is passed). > BWT: All issues, both in JIRA and GitHub are readable to the public

Re: [DISCUSS] A proposal for migration to GitHub issue (LUCENE-10557)

2022-05-06 Thread Jan Høydahl
For code changes, patch files in Jira used to be the only option. Over the years, this is almost completely replaced by PRs, but we still leave the door open for patch in JIRA. We could apply the same principle here: Don't shut down JIRA, but change documentation so that GitHub issues is