Re: Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-10-10 Thread Vipul Rahane
Hi Marko, Not a problem. I re-added smp_uart and fixed the build. Thanks. On Thu, Oct 10, 2019 at 1:30 AM marko kiiskila wrote: > Sorry for being difficult here, but.. > > To be exact nmgr_uart came after newtmgr-over-shell. The reason > it came to be was smaller memory footprint platforms,

Re: Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-10-10 Thread marko kiiskila
Sorry for being difficult here, but.. To be exact nmgr_uart came after newtmgr-over-shell. The reason it came to be was smaller memory footprint platforms, and assumption was that folks might still want option to newtmgr-over-uart after their dev was done. It got picked up for serial bootloader

Re: Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-10-09 Thread Vipul Rahane
Thanks Will and Chris for your response, removing it and transitioning it to smp_shell. This will be part of the MCUmgr changes to mynewt-core. On Wed, Oct 9, 2019 at 1:45 PM will sanfilippo wrote: > +1 on my part but not sure I am in the best position to vote :-) > > > On Oct 9, 2019, at

Re: Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-10-09 Thread will sanfilippo
+1 on my part but not sure I am in the best position to vote :-) > On Oct 9, 2019, at 12:42 PM, Vipul Rahane wrote: > > Hello, > > While making the changes for MCUmgr, we came across nmgr_uart which is a > predecessor of nmgr_shell. So far, from what I gather, the functionality is > the same

Re: Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-10-09 Thread Christopher Collins
Hi Vipul, On Wed, Oct 09, 2019 at 12:42:51PM -0700, Vipul Rahane wrote: > Hello, > > While making the changes for MCUmgr, we came across nmgr_uart which is a > predecessor of nmgr_shell. So far, from what I gather, the functionality is > the same except for the fact that shell can bring in other

Re: Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-10-09 Thread Vipul Rahane
Hello, While making the changes for MCUmgr, we came across nmgr_uart which is a predecessor of nmgr_shell. So far, from what I gather, the functionality is the same except for the fact that shell can bring in other code which can increase the code size a bit. As a solution I was suggesting

Unifying Newtmgr (NMP) protocol and MCUmgr (SMP) into the MCUmgr repo

2019-09-27 Thread Vipul Rahane
Hello fellow developers :-) So, Miguel and I have been working on unifying Newtmgr into the MCUmgr repo (https://github.com/apache/mynewt-mcumgr). There are no protocol level changes, since MCUmgr(SMP) and Newtmgr(NMP) were the same and so, everything should work off the bat for everybody. The