Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-07 Thread Ian G
On 6/7/09 08:42, Nelson Bolyard wrote: On 2009-07-05 16:03 PDT, Ian G wrote: On 4/7/09 23:19, Nelson B Bolyard wrote: You provide customer support for Firefox? Yup. Doesn't everyone who is a techie? I mean, I don't want to, but because I am a techie, people assume that I know Firefox back

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-06 Thread Nelson Bolyard
On 2009-07-05 16:03 PDT, Ian G wrote: On 4/7/09 23:19, Nelson B Bolyard wrote: You provide customer support for Firefox? Yup. Doesn't everyone who is a techie? I mean, I don't want to, but because I am a techie, people assume that I know Firefox back to front and can make it do circus

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-06 Thread Kyle Hamilton
Users are never told that a PIN is a password is a passphrase. So, they believe that a PIN is not a password, and a password is not a passphrase. So they think I have to type my password to get access to this, not the device is asking for my PIN to do what it's been asked to do. Users aren't

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-06 Thread Julien R Pierre - Sun Microsystems
Martin, Martin Paljak wrote: This is because currently tokens are used for low level internet pipe things in the form of SSL/TSL. It is impossible to bring those network level events to the UI level, and it would not make much sense either. NSS allows the password prompting callback to be

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-05 Thread Martin Paljak
On 05.07.2009, at 0:11, Nelson B Bolyard wrote: FYI, to make sense to users of eID cards currently one has to embed the word PIN into the token description as well, so that the prompt that Firefox displays would make sense: Please enter password for: MARTIN PALJAK (PIN1) GUI hints would be

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-05 Thread Nelson B Bolyard
On 2009-07-05 05:57 PDT, Martin Paljak wrote: The problem is that an average users thinks like this: password is something like 'topsecret123', PIN code is something like '1234', I'm asked for a password, let me see, which passwords I know that I might type here... More experienced

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-05 Thread Ian G
On 4/7/09 23:19, Nelson B Bolyard wrote: On 2009-07-04 04:19 PDT, Ian G wrote: Some remarks. On 4/7/09 12:18, Martin Paljak wrote: Firefox displays a Please enter password for ... dialog, which is ambiguous for casual users who need to be said very clearly when they need to enter the PIN of

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-04 Thread Martin Paljak
As I have written one of those many plugins used in EU (used in Estonia on Mac OS X and NPAPI compatible browsers, which means firefox/ safari/opera/camino ...), my opinions might be biased, but they reflect real life requirements. On 04.07.2009, at 1:04, Nelson B Bolyard wrote: FYI, to

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-04 Thread Ian G
Some remarks. On 4/7/09 12:18, Martin Paljak wrote: Firefox displays a Please enter password for ... dialog, which is ambiguous for casual users who need to be said very clearly when they need to enter the PIN of 4 or more digits. Right now my Firefox speaks Estonian but I also remember a

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-04 Thread Nelson B Bolyard
Martin, I want to read your full message and respond fully later this weekend, but right now I just want to try to clarify a couple things. FYI, to make sense to users of eID cards currently one has to embed the word PIN into the token description as well, so that the prompt that Firefox

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-04 Thread Nelson B Bolyard
On 2009-07-04 04:19 PDT, Ian G wrote: Some remarks. On 4/7/09 12:18, Martin Paljak wrote: Firefox displays a Please enter password for ... dialog, which is ambiguous for casual users who need to be said very clearly when they need to enter the PIN of 4 or more digits. Right now my Firefox

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Martin Paljak
On 03.07.2009, at 8:15, Anders Rundgren wrote: According to most people who are into consumer PKI, Java applets is the best solution for cross-browser PKI. I think Java applets suck but indeed, that's really all we got. but please don't take it out on us. Please refrain from further

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Eddy Nigg
On 07/03/2009 08:15 AM, Anders Rundgren: I'm sorry about that. Is there any other place where Mozilla people hang out where there is an interest in trying to understand why and what is happening on the PKI side for consumers? Anders, I think you must take your ideas to a standards body -

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Anders Rundgren
Anders, I think you must take your ideas to a standards body Eddy, this is exactly what I believed/hoped/craved for. Unfortunately, the people who represent stake holders like EU governments and banks do participate in International foras like OASIS and IETF, nor fund such developments. It

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Ian G
On 3/7/09 07:15, Anders Rundgren wrote: Nelson B Bolyard wrote: but please don't take it out on us. Please refrain from further sniping in this mailing list and newsgroup. Constructive contributions are welcome. I'm sorry about that. Is there any other place where Mozilla people hang out

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Ian G
On 3/7/09 09:30, Martin Paljak wrote: ... 2. Fix Firefox/NSS - Firefox still thinks that you should be able to authenticate to websites with certificates *without* TLS client authentication extension. Add automatic certificate selection, and you get trouble. Yes, this makes cert login as bad

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Nelson B Bolyard
On 2009-07-03 00:30 PDT, Martin Paljak wrote: Some constructive suggestions; mostly for Firefox: 1. Use platform API-s where appropriate: cryptoapi (and basecsp via this) on windows; cdsa/keychain on macosx. Regardless of who does it, this triples/quadruples the amount of work to be done

Re: Moving browser PKI forward (Re: Problem reading certificate from hardware token)

2009-07-03 Thread Nelson B Bolyard
On 2009-07-03 05:29 PDT, Ian G wrote: We desperately need some form of whitelisting in Firefox so that each site always gets presented the same cert. If browsers can remember cookies and username/passwords, then they can remember cert/domain combinations. This goes double for Thunderbird