[Emu] EAP-CREDS - Question about Implementations

2022-03-22 Thread Dr. Pala
Hello EMU, I would like to address a question I could not answer during today's meeting. Specifically, there was a question on the Chat from Alan about EAP-CREDS adoption in CBRS-A. My information is a bit outdated, but AFAIK there was no implementation (that I am aware of or publicly

Re: [Emu] Re-charter text

2019-10-24 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi Mohit, On 10/24/19 3:30 AM, Mohit Sethi M wrote: Dear Dr. Pala, [ ... ] I replied privately to the first part of this e-mail - I apologize if my e-mail did offend you or was in any way inappropriate. To clarify, my questions were in reply to Mohit's comments to my previous e-mail

Re: [Emu] Re-charter text

2019-10-23 Thread Dr. Pala
recall seeing your reply to that message). Cheers, Max On 10/15/19 2:07 AM, Mohit Sethi M wrote: Dear Dr. Pala, I think we need to be more prudent when using terms such as "credential provisioning" and "credential management". The bullet later on in the current charter text

Re: [Emu] Re-charter text

2019-10-14 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi Mohit, all, sorry for the long delay in replying (probably mute at this point), however I think the new text looks great. The only possible change I would provide is the possibility to restrict the scope for the credentials management part. In particular, I would change the following:

[Emu] EAP-CREDS - Questions for the WG

2019-06-10 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi all, we are working on the definition of an EAP mechanism that should help managing device credentials for access networks. We are finalizing some parts of the document and I would like to get the input from the WG (I know it is not a WG document, yet, but I hope it will get adopted). [*]

[Emu] EAP and Transport Protocol

2019-04-01 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi EMU-ers, being fairly new to the EAP world, I noticed that in some environment, EAP is layered on top of other protocols - in particular RADIUS and DIAMETER. I guess that in some environments this make sense because of accounting purposes across operators, however this makes the protocol

Re: [Emu] EAP and Fragmentation

2019-02-27 Thread Dr. Pala
uld be encoded with different structures and encodings (e.g., DER, JSON, XML, CBOR, etc.) Maybe we can write a BCP for EAP that includes both building blocks (i.e., Fragmentation and Simple Authentication and Encryption) ? What do you think ? Cheers, Max On 2/14/19 4:54 AM, Mohit Sethi M wrote:

Re: [Emu] EAP and Fragmentation

2019-02-14 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi Alan, thanks for the answers... aligned with what I thought and they do make sense... :D Further considerations inline... On 2/12/19 11:26 AM, Alan DeKok wrote: On Feb 12, 2019, at 12:36 PM, Dr. Pala wrote: [...] This, led me to my first question: is there a de-facto "standard

[Emu] EAP and Fragmentation

2019-02-12 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi all, I am working on a draft for credentials management via EAP. When looking at the different specifications, it seems a bit weird that EAP does not provide Fragmentation control and requires each method to define their own way. /*This, led me to my first question:*/ is there a de-facto

Re: [Emu] FW: New Version Notification for draft-ietf-emu-eap-tls13-03.txt

2018-11-21 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi all, in other environment we had to add the attribute about which ID was actually authenticated in the final messages because of additional operations that some network equipment needs to perform that requires the identity of the supplicant to be disclosed (exactly to avoid the use of an

Re: [Emu] WG adoption call for draft-arkko-eap-aka-pfs

2018-11-12 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi all, I am in favor of addressing the issue of PFS in 3GPP authentication - it is important work that moves cellular network authentication towards more modern approaches and more compatible with IETF technologies. This said, I am concerned about the fact that the IPR is not marked as

Re: [Emu] Re-Charter Considerations

2018-08-23 Thread Dr. Pala
mention below (sorry for >> taking so long to get back to your message).  Does that sound like a >> reasonable approach?  That way the ADs can occasionally see how the >> work is progressing and then make decisions. >> > The discussion can continue on the EMU list as long as it d

[Emu] Re-Charter Considerations

2018-07-20 Thread Dr. Pala
Hi Emu-ers, I wanted to follow up the discussion from today's meeting. In particular, there is some work that has been proposed that might require re-chartering as indicated by Ekr and supported by the Chair(s). I would like to push forward the request for re-chartering, in particular, I would

Re: [Emu] New Chair: Mohit Sethi

2018-07-20 Thread Dr. Pala
Congratulations Mohit! Now you can do more work for free :D Cheers, Max On 7/20/18 9:43 AM, Eric Rescorla wrote: > I am pleased to announce that Mohit Sethi has agreed to serve as > co-chair for EMU. > > Thanks to Mohit! > > -Ekr ___ Emu mailing