Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 01.07.2002 0:41 Uhr, Weldon Whipple wrote > I don't know how publishers feel about attention paid to page turns, but > THIS performer noticed them last week! I can just repeat my story: Our orchestra was performing from newly engraved parts (I think it was a Reichardt Opera, but I am not sure

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Éric Dussault
Thank you to everybody on the list for your feedback. I see that most people prefers tight spacing, which surprises me a little bit. I do space more tightly when doing parts needing page turns, but I was thinking more of general instrumental (classical piano, PVG etc...) spacing. I also looked at

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Dan Carno
At 10:10 PM 6/29/2002 -0400, Éric Dussault wrote: > I am citing the part where I ask for your >opinions : >« Good engraving is almost always tight engraving. It may be tempting, when >you are getting paid per page (the method most publishers use) to space >music generously to create extra pages,

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread David H. Bailey
Weldon Whipple wrote: [snip]> > I don't know how publishers feel about attention paid to page turns, but > THIS performer noticed them last week! > As a community band director who purchases new band works from a variety of publishers, it seems as if the people who know anything about musi

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 01.07.2002 0:39 Uhr, John Howell wrote >> But the problem with Finale spacing is that it becomes uglier as >> the music is becoming tighter. Am I silly or what? > > Finale's defaults (which I have complained about in the past and won't > repeat) give VERY wide spacing, which I feel leaves muc

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Weldon Whipple
On Sun, 30 Jun 2002 11:39, Jón Kristinn Cortez <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > How tight is tight? It all depends on the music; layout, page-turns, > repeats, sections and so on. Last Sunday night I was the (piano and organ) accompanist for a big choral program. Since beginning to read Powell's book

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Johannes Gebauer
I don't have the book in question, so I have no idea what the spacing looks like, but I have always considered my spacing pretty tight. I have arrived at tight spacing after having copied some scores or parts that I myself considered to look good and readable. This tought me that the spacing table

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread John Howell
Éric Dussault asked for opinions on this quote: >« Good engraving is almost always tight engraving. It may be tempting, when >you are getting paid per page (the method most publishers use) to space >music generously to create extra pages, but you should resist the urge. >Tighly spaced music is eas

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread David H. Bailey
Éric Dussault wrote: > > >>Where can I buy Powell's book? >> > > www.npcimaging.com > > >>However, I also agree with you that the music has to look good, and that >>if in your professional opinion a tighter layout is not good (I can >>think of many older orchestral works which are way too

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 29 Jun 2002, at 22:10, Éric Dussault wrote: > « Good engraving is almost always tight engraving. It may be tempting, when > you are getting paid per page (the method most publishers use) to space > music generously to create extra pages, but you should resist the urge. > Tighly spaced music is

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Éric Dussault
> Where can I buy Powell's book? www.npcimaging.com > However, I also agree with you that the music has to look good, and that > if in your professional opinion a tighter layout is not good (I can > think of many older orchestral works which are way too tight, along with > many early-20th-cent

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread Jón Kristinn Cortez
On 30.6.2002 02:10, "Éric Dussault" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I was just reading this new book and some ideas expressed by mr. Powell urge > me to get the opinion of you people on this list. > I first have to say that there are a lot of interesting things in this book. > The staff sizes chart

Re: [Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-30 Thread David H. Bailey
Éric Dussault wrote: > I was just reading this new book and some ideas expressed by mr. Powell urge > me to get the opinion of you people on this list. > I first have to say that there are a lot of interesting things in this book. > The staff sizes chart at the beginning is one good example. I

[Finale] Steven Powell's Music Engraving Today

2002-06-29 Thread Éric Dussault
I was just reading this new book and some ideas expressed by mr. Powell urge me to get the opinion of you people on this list. I first have to say that there are a lot of interesting things in this book. The staff sizes chart at the beginning is one good example. I would have appreciated that he o