Re: Freeradius with DHCP and VLANs

2013-08-14 Thread Fernando Pizarro
Hi again, Clarify that DHCP server is running in the same or an other machine, depends of the stage. Thanks. El 14/08/13 12:03, Fernando Pizarro escribió: Hi all, I'm using Freeradius version 2.1.12 with MySQL backend and EAP-TLS authentication to serve dynamic VLAN and a DHCP server to

Re: Freeradius with DHCP and VLANs

2013-08-14 Thread Arran Cudbard-Bell
On 14 Aug 2013, at 11:03, Fernando Pizarro fea...@gmail.com wrote: Hi all, I'm using Freeradius version 2.1.12 with MySQL backend and EAP-TLS authentication to serve dynamic VLAN and a DHCP server to leases this IP address. This setup work sucefully but IP address of supplicants doesn't

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-04-05 Thread Leo Combes
New article on wiki: http://wiki.freeradius.org/dhcp-for-static-ip-allocation Please let me know your thoughts. 2013/3/3 Alan DeKok al...@deployingradius.com: Leo Combes wrote: As additional information, I tried with PPA version in Debian and do not work (same problem). Maybe is a problem

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-03-02 Thread Alan DeKok
Leo Combes wrote: As additional information, I tried with PPA version in Debian and do not work (same problem). Maybe is a problem in my server. Maybe. I've just been running it with an Ubuntu 12.04 system, and it seems to work for me. I didn't install selinux, firewalls, or anything else.

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-03-01 Thread Leo Combes
what configuration options are in the PPA version? something is not right there Once installed, the configuration files in /etc/freeradius or /etc/raddb are the same, or at least the most relevant ones to its functionality. I will compare one by one to see if I find any difference. ...and it

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-03-01 Thread Alan DeKok
Leo Combes wrote: One important thing! (specially Ubuntu users):(*) DHCP functionality will not work when installed from PPA, or at least the package version 2.2.0 + dfsg-ppa10 not work. Reason: I dont know. I installed and configured without errors, seems to respond correctly OFFER

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-03-01 Thread Leo Combes
That might be an Ubuntu security setting. It seems to work fine on my systems. So it's hard to track down what's happening on other systems. Alan DeKok. As additional information, I tried with PPA version in Debian and do not work (same problem). Maybe is a problem in my server. - List

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-02-27 Thread A . L . M . Buxey
Hi, I installed Freeradius from PPA. https://launchpad.net/~freeradius/+archive/stable DHCP functionality not work when installed from PPA, or at least the package version 2.2.0 + dfsg-ppa10 not work. Reason: installed and configured without errors, seems to respond correctly OFFER and

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-02-27 Thread Leo Combes
I apollogize for the late response, I have been very busy and I couldn't keep working on this. I found the problem! (at least it works now) I installed Freeradius from PPA. https://launchpad.net/~freeradius/+archive/stable DHCP functionality not work when installed from PPA, or at least the

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-28 Thread Leo Combes
2013/1/23 a.l.m.bu...@lboro.ac.uk: hi, those ID values look a little 'wierd' - vary large and negative I don't understand where this values came from? which would be the normal values? does the DHCP response leave the server? do you have anything like dHCP snooping on the network that

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-28 Thread Alan DeKok
Leo Combes wrote: 2013/1/23 a.l.m.bu...@lboro.ac.uk: those ID values look a little 'wierd' - vary large and negative I don't understand where this values came from? which would be the normal values? It's fine. Don't worry about it. does the DHCP response leave the server? do you

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-23 Thread Leo Combes
Thanks for your reply. Fortunately it seems that the segfault is a false alarm. As it semt strange to me that Freeradius stop working by segfault, I installed FR in another PC and I copy the same configuration. Now it seems to be working, except that it stays in loop on DHCP Discover (no Offer,

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-23 Thread A . L . M . Buxey
hi, those ID values look a little 'wierd' - vary large and negative does the DHCP response leave the server? do you have anything like dHCP snooping on the network that might be blocking the responses from this new DHCP server or is the client getting its answers from a.n.another DHCP

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-22 Thread Leo Combes
Thanks Alan. I hope to make it work. As I have little experience with Freeradius, I want to start doing a little test with the mac2ip module. I made a file called mac2ip in /etc/freeradius with the following contents: 00:13:96:00:f9:84,10.1.100.1 The /etc/freeradius/sites-enabled/dhcp as

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-22 Thread Alan DeKok
Leo Combes wrote: Thanks Alan. I hope to make it work. As I have little experience with Freeradius, I want to start doing a little test with the mac2ip module. I made a file called mac2ip in /etc/freeradius with the following contents: 00:13:96:00:f9:84,10.1.100.1 OK. I have added

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-22 Thread Leo Combes
Thanks again Alan. At last I tried to run freeradius: Please use radiusd -X, not radiusd -Xx OK. Info: server dhcp { Debug: Trying sub-section dhcp DHCP-Discover {...} Info: +- entering group DHCP-Discover {...} Info: ++[reply] returns noop Info: ++[reply] returns noop

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-22 Thread Olivier Beytrison
On 22.01.2013 22:58, Leo Combes wrote: Can you follow doc/bugs? It will tell you how to post more debugging information so we can see exactly where it's going wrong. I don't know how to do that. Any link on how to do it? /usr/share/doc/freeradius/bugs or

Re: Freeradius as DHCP server (static IP + some options)

2013-01-21 Thread Alan DeKok
Leo Combes wrote: Hello. I successfully run ISC-DHCP server for provisioning modems in an ISP's network, but what I wanted to try is something more modern and with database support. I want to try using Freeradius as DHCP server, but first I want to know if it is possible with these

RE: Freeradius as dhcp; parsing option82

2012-10-16 Thread David Peterson
: Friday, September 7, 2012 7:40 AM To: FreeRadius users mailing list Subject: Re: Freeradius as dhcp; parsing option82 Ilya A. Masandilov wrote: CPU use by radiusd fell from 70% to 10-15. Great. Thank you Alan for great dhcp functional ;) You're welcome. Version 2.2.0 should have

Re: Freeradius as dhcp; parsing option82

2012-09-06 Thread Ilya A. Masandilov
Здравствуйте, Ilya. Вы писали 6 сентября 2012 г., 21:52:23: Hello! We are using freeradius as dhcp server about two years. Its working wery well, but. ... Heh, sorry, I found the solution =) Somethink like this for example, to ignore vlan #1 (default on most devices): if(

Re: Freeradius as dhcp; parsing option82

2012-09-06 Thread Ilya A. Masandilov
Heh, sorry, I found the solution =) Somethink like this for example, to ignore vlan #1 (default on most devices): if( %{DHCP-Relay-Circuit-Id} =~ /^0x([0-9a-f]{4})0001([0-9a-f]{4})$/i ) { reject } Wow. After using this code ^ and also this (filter

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread IVB
Fajar A. Nugraha-2 wrote ... and then on authorize section add something like this (just for check) if ( (request:User-Name == 00:12:23:56:78:9A) (control:Agent-Circuit-ID != %{request:Agent-Circuit-ID}) ) { update control { Auth-Type := Reject } } then use debug mode

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread IVB
Alan DeKok-2 wrote IVB wrote: But I don't see in debug output what exactly was returned in SQL query. Have you tried running the SQL queries from an SQL client on the command line? That's why they're printed out in debugging mode: so you can see them, and re-run them yourself.

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread Alan DeKok
IVB wrote: Yes, I run queries by hand and see results as strings, non-printable chars not printed, but attribute itself has non-zero length. You can't put binary data into an ASCII string field. Alan DeKok. - List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread IVB
Alan DeKok-2 wrote You can't put binary data into an ASCII string field. But that was my question! FreeRADIUS offers following schema for radcheck table: CREATE TABLE radcheck ( id int(11) unsigned NOT NULL auto_increment, username varchar(64) NOT NULL default '', attribute

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread Alan DeKok
IVB wrote: But that was my question! ... How I can put Opt82 attributes (which contains non-printable bytes) into database to offer it later for FreeRADIUS using SELECT statement? You don't. The database is intended for ASCII data. You could also edit the dictionaries to make the data

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread Igor Belikov
Hello Alan, Monday, April 2, 2012, 1:59:03 PM, you wrote: AD IVB wrote: But that was my question! AD ... How I can put Opt82 attributes (which contains non-printable bytes) into database to offer it later for FreeRADIUS using SELECT statement? AD You don't. Are you kidding? AD The

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread Alan DeKok
Igor Belikov wrote: AD You don't. Are you kidding? If you insist on going down that path, you'll be unsubscribed and banned. I'm tried of people who can't read the documentation, and who use that ignorance to put me down. Do you mean that FreeRADIUS can't accept non-ASCII data from

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread IVB
Hello Alan, Monday, April 2, 2012, 2:53:15 PM, you wrote: AD2vF Igor Belikov wrote: AD You don't. Are you kidding? AD2vF If you insist on going down that path, you'll be unsubscribed and AD2vF banned. I'm tried of people who can't read the documentation, and who AD2vF use that

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread Alan DeKok
IVB wrote: Hello Alan, Yes, I will be very happy to read how to represent 'octets' data in DB. And I ask about this several times. I don't find this info in documentation, sorry. Please give me link to right place. I gave you a hint, and you deleted it. Good luck. Alan DeKok. -

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-04-02 Thread IVB
This is incorrect: IVB wrote INSERT INTO `radcheck` ( `UserName`, `Attribute`, `Value`, `op` ) VALUES ( '00:12:23:56:78:9A', 'Cleartext-Password', 'Redback', ':=' ), ( '00:12:23:56:78:9A', 'Agent-Circuit-ID', x'000403fc0001', '==' ), ( '00:12:23:56:78:9A', 'Agent-Remote-ID',

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-03-31 Thread Alan DeKok
IVB wrote: But I don't see in debug output what exactly was returned in SQL query. Have you tried running the SQL queries from an SQL client on the command line? That's why they're printed out in debugging mode: so you can see them, and re-run them yourself. Alan DeKok. - List

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-03-30 Thread Fajar A. Nugraha
On Fri, Mar 30, 2012 at 4:29 PM, IVB i...@is.ua wrote: I need help. Software: FreeRADIUS v2.1.11, MySQL v5.1.61. Hardware: RB SE100 under SEOS-6.4.1.4-Release BRAS sends Opt-82 related attributes in following format: What format? Attributes Agent-* described in radius dictionary as

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-03-30 Thread IVB
Fajar A. Nugraha-2 wrote On Fri, Mar 30, 2012 at 4:29 PM, IVB lt;ivb@gt; wrote: I need help. Software: FreeRADIUS v2.1.11, MySQL v5.1.61. Hardware: RB SE100 under SEOS-6.4.1.4-Release BRAS sends Opt-82 related attributes in following format: What format? Agent-Remote-Id =

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-03-30 Thread IVB
Debug mode help me nothing. When I try to connect without Agent-* attributes in DB, I see in debug output 'User found in radcheck table' after performing check SQL. And finally I login successfully. When I try to connect with Agent-* attributes in DB, I don't see message 'User found in radcheck

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-03-30 Thread Fajar A. Nugraha
On Fri, Mar 30, 2012 at 6:12 PM, IVB i...@is.ua wrote: Agent-Circuit-Id = 0x000403fc0001 let's start with that one.  ( '00:12:23:56:78:9A', 'Agent-Circuit-ID', x'000403fc0001', '==' ), Does that work? Shouldn't it be something like ( '00:12:23:56:78:9A', 'Agent-Circuit-ID', 0x000403fc0001,

Re: FreeRADIUS + MySQL + DHCP Opt82

2012-03-30 Thread IVB
Fajar A. Nugraha-2 wrote On Fri, Mar 30, 2012 at 6:12 PM, IVB lt;ivb@gt; wrote: Agent-Circuit-Id = 0x000403fc0001 let's start with that one.  ( '00:12:23:56:78:9A', 'Agent-Circuit-ID', x'000403fc0001', '==' ), Does that work? No. And this is the problem. Fajar A. Nugraha-2

RE: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-14 Thread Seppo Sandberg
Start off without it. If it works... it's good enough. When I require any further pieces of information on this matter what would be the preferred way of communication, e.g. should I keep using this thread or open a new one on developer list? Best regards, Seppo

Re: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-14 Thread Alan DeKok
Seppo Sandberg wrote: Start off without it. If it works... it's good enough. When I require any further pieces of information on this matter what would be the preferred way of communication, e.g. should I keep using this thread or open a new one on developer list? The devel list is

RE: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Seppo Sandberg
Hello, maybe I'll try and rephrase my question. Which attribute should I modify with update reply, e.g. in dhcp DHCP-Discover section of the sites-available/dhcp file, if I wanted to redirect the message to another DHCP server? Best regards, Seppo -

Re: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Alan DeKok
Seppo Sandberg wrote: Hello, maybe I'll try and rephrase my question. Which attribute should I modify with update reply, e.g. in dhcp DHCP-Discover section of the sites-available/dhcp file, if I wanted to redirect the message to another DHCP server? You can't. DHCP relaying is not

RE: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Seppo Sandberg
Thank you for your swift reply. You can't. DHCP relaying is not supported. It shouldn't be hard to add, though. Patches are welcome. If I was inclined to create such a patch how would we begin to tackle the issue? I guess you would tell me how you would like to have it implemented? Best

Re: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Alan DeKok
Seppo Sandberg wrote: If I was inclined to create such a patch how would we begin to tackle the issue? I guess you would tell me how you would like to have it implemented? See src/main/dhcpd.c Look for relay. Add a cache (hash table or rbtree) for XID, and maybe (XID,MAC). Add entries

Re: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Phil Mayers
On 13/01/11 11:03, Alan DeKok wrote: Seppo Sandberg wrote: If I was inclined to create such a patch how would we begin to tackle the issue? I guess you would tell me how you would like to have it implemented? See src/main/dhcpd.c Look for relay. Add a cache (hash table or rbtree) for

Re: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Alan DeKok
Phil Mayers wrote: What's the rationale for keeping state? Some security, IIRC. I was under the impression that DHCP relays could be stateless. Since you can chain relays, but replies go straight back to the first one (via the giaddr field) Yes. The ISC DHCP relay code doesn't store

RE: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Seppo Sandberg
For our purposes, storing state would allow us to know where to send the reply. The ISC server walks through it's list of interfaces for every reply. This is simple, but it would be safer to maintain state. Is the bottom line that when implementing the dhcp relay there should be caching

Re: freeradius and dhcp relaying

2011-01-13 Thread Alan DeKok
Seppo Sandberg wrote: Is the bottom line that when implementing the dhcp relay there should be caching included? Start off without it. If it works... it's good enough. What data exactly should be stored in the cache? I'll have to think about that. Alan DeKok. - List

Re: freeradius 2.1.10 DHCP not responding

2010-10-13 Thread Arran Cudbard-Bell
IIRC there were problems binding the server to IP addresses. Try just binding to an interface or being promiscuous. On 13/10/2010, Zietz, Marco marco.zi...@pfalzkom-manet.de wrote: Hi, I'm playing with freeradius acting as DHCP-server - which is a magnificent idea! Got a little problem

Re: freeradius 2.1.10 DHCP not responding

2010-10-13 Thread Alan Buxey
Hi, I'm playing with freeradius acting as DHCP-server - which is a magnificent idea! Got a little problem getting it up and running. Already checked any comments in sources, list archive, recent git patches related to dhcp and my favourite search engine. Also used two different

Re: Freeradius as DHCP sending DHCP Offer to interface where default gateway is

2010-08-02 Thread Urazaev Vadim
01.08.2010 16:06, Alan DeKok пишет: Urazaev Vadim wrote: I`m trying to set up freeradius as dhcp server and everythins seem to be ok, in radiusd -X I can see the DHCP-Discover packets that comes from client and DHCP-Offer that server sending to client. When I tried to find out to which

Re: Freeradius as DHCP sending DHCP Offer to interface where default gateway is

2010-08-01 Thread Alan DeKok
Urazaev Vadim wrote: I`m trying to set up freeradius as dhcp server and everythins seem to be ok, in radiusd -X I can see the DHCP-Discover packets that comes from client and DHCP-Offer that server sending to client. When I tried to find out to which interface server send`s responses I saw

Re: Freeradius as DHCP sending DHCP Offer to interface where default gateway is

2010-08-01 Thread Urazaev Vadim
01.08.2010 16:06, Alan DeKok пишет: Update the FreeRADIUS code so that it uses a BPF socket on FreeBSD. Or, run on a system with only one interface. Alan DeKok. - List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html Thanks for your answer. - List

Re: FreeRADIUS as dhcp

2010-07-30 Thread Alan DeKok
Urazaev Vadim wrote: Hello all. I tried to configure freeradius to operate as dhcp server and reach the point from where I can`t proceed. the version of freeradius is 2.1.9 I have two situation 1. DHCP Discover packet comes from client who directly connected to network which freerasdius

Re: FreeRADIUS as dhcp

2010-07-30 Thread Urazaev Vadim
30.07.2010 10:27, Alan DeKok wrote: Urazaev Vadim wrote: Hello all. I tried to configure freeradius to operate as dhcp server and reach the point from where I can`t proceed. the version of freeradius is 2.1.9 I have two situation 1. DHCP Discover packet comes from client who directly connected

Re: Freeradius AS DHCP + rlm_perl

2010-07-30 Thread Urazaev Vadim
30.07.2010 19:03, Urazaev Vadim пишет: Hi everybody. FreeRadius ver. 2.1.10 from git My problem is string : === ++[perl] returns reject from radiusd -X debug The last strings in perl script that executed : radiusd::radlog(L_ERR, --- RLM_MODULE_OK

Re: Freeradius AS DHCP + rlm_perl

2010-07-30 Thread John Dennis
On 07/30/2010 12:57 PM, Urazaev Vadim wrote: [16 pages of debug output snipped for brevity] Sorry Guys for disturb you, problem was in eval{} block in my perl script inside which command return always return reject code. Anyway Thanks for all. And for that I had to page through 16 pages of

Re: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread Alan DeKok
Kassai Istvan wrote: I'd like to know how can I get it working? Which DHCP server can cooperate with freeradius? What have I modify in freeradius? ./configure --with-dhcp make make install It doesn't work with a DHCP server. It *is* a DHCP server. It works with DHCP clients. Alan

RE: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread ZHANG Gina
eradius.org] On Behalf Of Alan DeKok Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 12:06 PM To: FreeRadius users mailing list Subject: Re: Freeradius with DHCP Kassai Istvan wrote: I'd like to know how can I get it working? Which DHCP server can cooperate with freeradius? What have I modify in freeradius

Re: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread Alan DeKok
ZHANG Gina wrote: Does this DHCP server assigns IP addresses from the ip address pool of radius? No. It requires code updates to allow the SQL IP pool module to handle DHCP packets. You *can* read static IP's from a text file or from an SQL DB. You just can't dynamically assign them.

RE: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread ZHANG Gina
@lists.fre eradius.org] On Behalf Of Alan DeKok Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 1:28 PM To: FreeRadius users mailing list Subject: Re: Freeradius with DHCP ZHANG Gina wrote: Does this DHCP server assigns IP addresses from the ip address pool of radius? No. It requires code updates to allow the SQL

Re: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread Kassai Istvan
Thanks. Can I somehow know, is my freeradius compiled with DHCP support? I dont wanna recompile it if isnt needed. Can I found an example, how to make this DHCP to assign IP-s from a postgres database? 2009. 11. 10, kedd keltezéssel 19.06-kor Alan DeKok ezt írta: Kassai Istvan wrote: I'd

Re: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread Alan DeKok
ZHANG Gina wrote: Does version 2.1.3 have this functionality? Where is the document describing the configuration? It's in 2.1.3. The only documentation is in raddb/sites-available/dhcp Alan DeKok. - List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html

Re: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread Alan DeKok
Kassai Istvan wrote: Thanks. Can I somehow know, is my freeradius compiled with DHCP support? Try configuring DHCP. If it doesn't work, it isn't compiled in. But it's not normally included. I dont wanna recompile it if isnt needed. Can I found an example, how to make this DHCP to

RE: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread ZHANG Gina
, November 10, 2009 2:23 PM To: FreeRadius users mailing list Subject: Re: Freeradius with DHCP ZHANG Gina wrote: Does version 2.1.3 have this functionality? Where is the document describing the configuration? It's in 2.1.3. The only documentation is in raddb/sites-available/dhcp Alan DeKok

Re: Freeradius with DHCP

2009-11-10 Thread Kassai Istvan
I dont wanna recompile it if isnt needed. Can I found an example, how to make this DHCP to assign IP-s from a postgres database? No. So I'm afraid I will ask some further questions about it :-) Thanks for very quick answering. - List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See

Re: freeradius with dhcp

2004-05-17 Thread Alan DeKok
ro0ot [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Can I configure the system to let freeradius works with dhcp? No, sorry. Alan DeKok. - List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html

Re: freeradius with dhcp

2004-05-17 Thread M Singh
Why not ? My university implements something that looks like that. A laptop first gets a DHCP lease, and can address a single IP which is presumably the address of the server. Then I fire up the Cisco VPN client that authenticates via an encryption algorithm and then the laptop can access the

Re: freeradius with dhcp

2004-05-17 Thread Alan DeKok
M Singh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Why not ? Because freeradius working with dhcp means freeradius knows about dhcp. My university implements something that looks like that. A laptop first gets a DHCP lease, and can address a single IP which is presumably the address of the server. Then I

Re: freeradius with dhcp

2004-05-17 Thread ro0ot
Yep, thats what I mean...thanks Alan DeKok, :) Probabily I have to find another solution, :-( Regards, ro0ot Alan DeKok wrote: M Singh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Why not ? Because freeradius working with dhcp means freeradius knows about dhcp. My university implements something that