Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread DJ Delorie
> Dave the established practice with pcb is to make it difficult for > friends to solder. If you don't believe me I still have an unattempted > DJ's torture^h^h^h^h^h^h^h challenge kits;) I've been thinking of making some smaller ones, maybe with CSPs this time... mwahahaha!! _

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Steve Meier
On Tue, 2008-03-11 at 11:14 -0800, Dave N6NZ wrote: > So then I decided to do a through-hole board that would be easy for some > friends to solder. Dave the established practice with pcb is to make it difficult for friends to solder. If you don't believe me I still have an unattempted DJ's t

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Dave N6NZ
Ben Jackson wrote: > On Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 10:39:22AM -0800, Dave N6NZ wrote: >> Ben Jackson wrote: >>> You've always had to draw lines to pads to connect to any >>> surface polygons. >> Not being able to create non-round pins that support thermals is a >> fundamental brokenness. Let's fix it

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Ben Jackson
On Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 10:39:22AM -0800, Dave N6NZ wrote: > > Ben Jackson wrote: > > You've always had to draw lines to pads to connect to any > > surface polygons. > > Not being able to create non-round pins that support thermals is a > fundamental brokenness. Let's fix it. Does that apply t

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Dave N6NZ
Ben Jackson wrote: > You've always had to draw lines to pads to connect to any > surface polygons. Not being able to create non-round pins that support thermals is a fundamental brokenness. Let's fix it. -dave ___ geda-user mailing list geda-user@

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread joeft
Ben Jackson wrote: > On Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 08:39:31AM -0800, Dave N6NZ wrote: >> Steve Meier wrote: >>> I am also interested in why you would want a thermal for connecting a >>> via onto a pad in which the via is sitting. >> ?? OK, I'm still under-caffeinated, but I don't parse your question. >>

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Ben Jackson
On Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 08:39:31AM -0800, Dave N6NZ wrote: > Steve Meier wrote: > > I am also interested in why you would want a thermal for connecting a > > via onto a pad in which the via is sitting. > > ?? OK, I'm still under-caffeinated, but I don't parse your question. > I'm guessing you mis

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Dave N6NZ
Steve Meier wrote: > I am also interested in why you would want a thermal for connecting a > via onto a pad in which the via is sitting. ?? OK, I'm still under-caffeinated, but I don't parse your question. I'm guessing you missed my initial rant? What I was trying to do is create an oblong pi

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Steve Meier
I am also interested in why you would want a thermal for connecting a via onto a pad in which the via is sitting. I have used vias in pads twice now. 1) High density bga with a minimal number of layers. number of layers is no longer an issue with pcb. 2) Conducting heat away from a component and

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Steve Meier
I haven't tried this but a work around might be to use a polygon rather then a pad. If you need to solder to the polygon then make a small pad not connected to the via and open the soldermask clearence but not the polygon clearance. Steve M joe tarantino wrote: > > > On Mon, Mar 10, 2008 at 5:16

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-11 Thread Dave N6NZ
joe tarantino wrote: > - Expanding the grammar to support inner layer pad <> outer layer pad > would be great. (Would one geometry definition apply to all inner layers?) > - Also consider whatever would allow pins (and vias) with no connection > to some layers (maybe supporting blind and buried

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread joe tarantino
On Mon, Mar 10, 2008 at 5:16 PM, Dave N6NZ <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > DJ Delorie wrote: > >> PCB needs first class support for oblong through-holes. > > > > Yup. I've talked about a "multi-pin" before; this is a pin with > > arbitrary shaped copper/soldermask/etc on each layer. > > > Yes, whe

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread Peter Clifton
On Mon, 2008-03-10 at 16:16 -0800, Dave N6NZ wrote: > DJ Delorie wrote: > >> PCB needs first class support for oblong through-holes. > > > > Yup. I've talked about a "multi-pin" before; this is a pin with > > arbitrary shaped copper/soldermask/etc on each layer. > > > Yes, when you get to multi

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread Dave N6NZ
DJ Delorie wrote: >> PCB needs first class support for oblong through-holes. > > Yup. I've talked about a "multi-pin" before; this is a pin with > arbitrary shaped copper/soldermask/etc on each layer. > Yes, when you get to multi layer boards you often want a different annulus on inner layers.

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread andrewm
Dave wrote: > I realize I can draw them in by hand by turning of "new traces clear > polygons". I guess for this design that's what I'll have to do, because > regenerating all my footprints, regenerating and re-validating the net > list, and re-doing all the routing done so far is just too co

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread DJ Delorie
> PCB needs first class support for oblong through-holes. Yup. I've talked about a "multi-pin" before; this is a pin with arbitrary shaped copper/soldermask/etc on each layer. ___ geda-user mailing list geda-user@moria.seul.org http://www.seul.org/cg

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread Dave N6NZ
So then the whole concept of getting an oblong through-hole pad by having a pad overlapping a pin is fundamentally broken? There's a day of my life I'll never have back. Pardon my French, but that is bogus. It's not like oblong through-hole pads are a new idea or anything. PCB needs first cl

Re: gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread DJ Delorie
pcb doesn't support thermals on pads. ___ geda-user mailing list geda-user@moria.seul.org http://www.seul.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/geda-user

gEDA-user: [pcb] overlapping pin/pad -- won't form thermal

2008-03-10 Thread Dave N6NZ
Yet another issue with pad+pin stacks. I created hand-solder pads with a pin slightly smaller than the pad to work around the clearance bug. Now, when I click on those pin+pad stacks with the thermal tool, it does not form a thermal. Anybody else see this, or am I doing something wrong? -dave