Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-09-01 Thread MFPA
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Hi On Friday 29 August 2014 at 9:04:54 AM, in mid:54003426.4030...@signal100.com, Mark Rousell wrote: Social interaction inevitably involves some extent of information sharing, and always has, but that doesn't mean that privacy (and all the

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-29 Thread Mark Rousell
On 27/08/2014 11:16, Jason Antony wrote: What can't be controlled is when people who know you give out your personal details on social networks. It could happen because they may not see anything wrong with it, they may be tricked into it [games/surveys], or they wish to harm you. This is

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-29 Thread Mark Rousell
On 27/08/2014 11:46, d...@geer.org wrote: I fully agree with you, which means that I see few ways to preserve the liberty that privacy represents than to withdraw from much of civil society while it shares ever more -- sharing ever more on the I've got nothing to hide premise. Technology

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-29 Thread Samir Nassar
It is safe to say this thread has moved way off topic from being about using gnupg. Samir -- Samir Nassar sa...@samirnassar.com https://samirnassar.com PGP Fingerprint: EE76 B39E 0778 8F95 F796 B044 FE67 9A90 8E99 7AB2 Public Key: https://samirnassar.com/files/key.asc signature.asc

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-29 Thread Mark Rousell
On 27/08/2014 17:15, Robert J. Hansen wrote: Figure out what *precisely* you're concerned with, and start talking about that -- but privacy as a word has become so vague it's almost useless. If we can't describe precisely what we're afraid of losing, we're going to lose it and we won't even

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-29 Thread Mark Rousell
(This did not seem to reach the list previously. Apologies if you've seen it twice.) On 27/08/2014 15:54, shm...@riseup.net wrote: actually you chose to step out of the front door today i assume ? you took the bus to work or maybe you drove ? i don't know, maybe a tractors more your thing, but

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-29 Thread Mark Rousell
On 29/08/2014 09:29, Samir Nassar wrote: It is safe to say this thread has moved way off topic from being about using gnupg. Samir Yes. My apologies for my part in taking it off-topic. -- Mark Rousell PGP public key: http://www.signal100.com/markr/pgp Key ID: C9C5C162

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread dan
| Is this not the core of the question? In a world of social media | and sensor-driven everything, does not the very concept of private | information fade, per se? I believe it does. | | No. Taking part in social networks and other media is a choice. One can | a) choose not to take

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread Jason Antony
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 On 2014-08-27 15:02, Mark Rousell wrote: No. Taking part in social networks and other media is a choice. One can a) choose not to take part at all, or b) choose how one takes part and what information one shares. What can't be controlled is

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread Mark H. Wood
On Wed, Aug 27, 2014 at 06:46:13AM -0400, d...@geer.org wrote: | Is this not the core of the question? In a world of social media | and sensor-driven everything, does not the very concept of private | information fade, per se? I believe it does. | | No. Taking part in social

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread shm...@riseup.net
Mark Carousel wrote: On 23/08/2014 11:16, d...@geer.org wrote: On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: Open data and transparency should only be about what concerns everybody, like government actions, trains schedule, etc. not private information. Is this not the core of the

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread shm...@riseup.net
Jason Antony wrote: On 2014-08-27 15:02, Mark Rousell wrote: No. Taking part in social networks and other media is a choice. One can a) choose not to take part at all, or b) choose how one takes part and what information one shares. What can't be controlled is when people who know you

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread Robert J. Hansen
I fully agree with you, which means that I see few ways to preserve the liberty that privacy represents than to withdraw from much of civil society while it shares ever more... I see a couple, but much like Dan, I'm not optimistic about them. The first is this: *stop talking about privacy*.

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread MFPA
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Hi On Wednesday 27 August 2014 at 5:15:09 PM, in mid:53fe040d.2080...@sixdemonbag.org, Robert J. Hansen wrote: I've run into self-styled privacy advocates here in the U.S. who are furious over how the U.S. has been reading their email. The

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread MFPA
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Hi On Wednesday 27 August 2014 at 11:16:24 AM, in mid:53fdaff8.30...@gmail.com, Jason Antony wrote: What can't be controlled is when people who know you give out your personal details on social networks. It could happen because they may not

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Is there really as much of a distinction as some would have us believe? Yes, absolutely. If the problem is X and your advocacy loudly insists that Y is happening, then you're (a) not solving X (although Y might need fixing anyway), and (b) all the people you've persuaded to join your cause

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread MFPA
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Hi On Wednesday 27 August 2014 at 8:37:10 PM, in mid:53fe3366.6010...@sixdemonbag.org, Robert J. Hansen wrote: Is there really as much of a distinction as some would have us believe? Yes, absolutely. If the problem is X and your advocacy

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-27 Thread Robert J. Hansen
But there will be significant overlap between the dataset collected by somebody harvesting content and the inferences about somebody's life that could be drawn by somebody harvesting metadata. I had hoped the quote from the EFF website would illustrate this. For some individuals, yes. For

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-26 Thread Mark Rousell
On 23/08/2014 11:16, d...@geer.org wrote: On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: Open data and transparency should only be about what concerns everybody, like government actions, trains schedule, etc. not private information. Is this not the core of the question? In a world

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-25 Thread MFPA
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Hi On Friday 22 August 2014 at 3:17:30 AM, in mid:53f6a83a.1050...@sixdemonbag.org, Robert J. Hansen wrote: I respectfully submit that once the definition is broadened that far, the word ceases to have probative value. But if that's the

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-23 Thread dan
On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: Open data and transparency should only be about what concerns everybody, like government actions, trains schedule, etc. not private information. Is this not the core of the question? In a world of social media and sensor-driven everything,

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-23 Thread Garreau, Alexandre
On 2014-08-23 at 12:16, d...@geer.org wrote: On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: Open data and transparency should only be about what concerns everybody, like government actions, trains schedule, etc. not private information. Is this not the core of the question? In a world of social

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-23 Thread dan
| On 2014-08-23 at 12:16, d...@geer.org wrote: | On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: | Open data and transparency should only be about what concerns everybody, | like government actions, trains schedule, etc. not private information. | | Is this not the core of the question? In

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-23 Thread Mirimir
On 08/23/2014 08:08 PM, d...@geer.org wrote: | On 2014-08-23 at 12:16, d...@geer.org wrote: | On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: | Open data and transparency should only be about what concerns everybody, | like government actions, trains schedule, etc. not private information.

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-22 Thread Garreau, Alexandre
On 2014-08-22 at 01:16, Robert J. Hansen wrote: On 8/21/2014 3:35 PM, Johannes Zarl wrote: Compiling a collection of publicly available information is an almost perfect description of the term surveillance. E.g. a surveillance camera does exactly that: it collects publicly available

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-22 Thread Rejo Zenger
++ 22/08/14 11:38 +0200 - Garreau, Alexandre: The difference in the relation we have with information is who does it concern: when it concerns everybody (like Science, information about politics, events, Philosophy, Art, etc. what generally is what Wikipedia contains, aka “encyclopedic

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-22 Thread Doug Barton
Can I ask that the whole discussion of what is or is not surveillance be taken off line somewhere? It really doesn't matter what we call it, the interesting bit here is that we know all kinds of data are being collected by all kinds of folks. That leaves open the (IMO much more interesting)

RE: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-22 Thread Charles Spitzer
Or, to put it another way: security through obscurity is ok. as long as no one finds out, or goes looking for, public information, everything's hidden well enough. Regards, Charlie 602.420.4123 -Original Message- From: Gnupg-users [mailto:gnupg-users-boun...@gnupg.org] On Behalf Of

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-22 Thread Garreau, Alexandre
On 2014-08-22 at 21:13, Rejo Zenger wrote: ++ 22/08/14 11:38 +0200 - Garreau, Alexandre: The difference in the relation we have with information is who does it concern: when it concerns everybody (like Science, information about politics, events, Philosophy, Art, etc. what generally is what

Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread da...@gbenet.com
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 - Original Message Subject:GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back Date: Wed, 20 Aug 2014 18:02:21 -0400 From: Free Software Foundation i...@fsf.org Reply-To: Free

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Robert J. Hansen
GNU community members and collaborators have discovered threatening details about a five-country government surveillance program codenamed HACIENDA. The good news? Those same hackers have already worked out a free software countermeasure to thwart the program. A little late to the party. This

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread flapflap
Robert J. Hansen: [snip] Also note that, contrary to the FSF's press release, this isn't government surveillance. It isn't even surveillance in the usual sense of the word. If you run a public service like HTTP, how is it surveillance for someone, anyone, to say the server sixdemonbag.org,

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Robert J. Hansen
I'm not happy with that definition/understanding of surveillance. It's not just about reporting on what colors people's houses are - it's more about someone going to every door, trying to open it, and noting what kind of door and lock there is. Then, comes back with a key, opens the door,

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Johannes Zarl
On Thursday 21 August 2014 11:41:40 Robert J. Hansen wrote: If it escalates to an intrusion, then yes, that's definitely surveillance in my book. Compiling a collection of publicly available information is not. Compiling a collection of publicly available information is an almost perfect

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Robert J. Hansen
On 8/21/2014 3:35 PM, Johannes Zarl wrote: Compiling a collection of publicly available information is an almost perfect description of the term surveillance. E.g. a surveillance camera does exactly that: it collects publicly available information. So does the phone book, Wikipedia, and IMDB.

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Gabriel Niebler
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 I'm sorry, I know this is OT for the list, but... Am 21.08.2014 um 15:54 schrieb Robert J. Hansen: GNU community members and collaborators have discovered threatening details about a five-country government surveillance program codenamed

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Aaron Toponce
On Fri, Aug 22, 2014 at 12:46:38AM +0200, Gabriel Niebler wrote: On the contrary, IMO this sort of thing is fully encompassed by the word surveillance, at least as far as I have always understood it. Otherwise any surveillance camera installed in a public or publicly accessible place would not

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Filip M. Nowak
Hi, Name me any piece of non-trivial information which doesn't have the potential to be used against someone. What do you mean by non-trivial? Regards, Filip ___ Gnupg-users mailing list Gnupg-users@gnupg.org

Re: Fwd: GNU hackers discover HACIENDA government surveillance and give us a way to fight back

2014-08-21 Thread Robert J. Hansen
Just to get pedantic, according to Wikipedia [1]: First, thank you for citing a definition rather than using a loose handle on a notion. I genuinely appreciate it! That seems pretty clear to me that HACIENDA is indeed a surveillance program. It also means that a newspaper reporting on the