Re: [Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa (by Rose Fernandes)

2012-01-31 Thread Eddie Fernandes
Thanks Rose. Yes, I had seen that but it is only a mild distraction: 1. Jerusalem is not a country. 2. The proposal has not been implemented as far I am aware. 3. Jerusalem's proposal was for unoccupied property with overseas owners. Goa's proposal is for owners outside the State even when

[Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa (by Rose Fernandes)

2012-01-31 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear Eddie Here is my response to your posting on the above. EF1: Jerusalem is not a country. RF1: Goa is not a country either as far as I am aware and this posting is on Goa. Unless while I was mildly distracted a magic wand was used to make it into one! Apologies, cannot respond

Re: [Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa

2012-01-30 Thread Eddie Fernandes
Selma, the Non-Occupancy Tax proposal is just a jingoistic jibe designed to woo those with the lowest level of intelligence to vote for Congress. It does not have even a remote possibility of becoming law because: 1. The Union Policy is to woo NRIs to India. 2. As far as I am aware, no state in

Re: [Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa

2012-01-30 Thread Eugene Correia
I see the points Eddie has made. The Congress hasn't put its manifesto out but rather testing the waters by leaking out some issues on which the election would be fought. The NRI commissioner is on the Congress drafting committee and, hence, the NRIs should hope he would see that nothing is in the

[Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa (by Rose Fernandes)

2012-01-30 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear Eddie When I read point 2. in your posting As far as I am aware, no state in India or country in the world has such a law I googled non-occupancy tax and saw the following article by David Lev dated 11 October 2011: Absentee owner tax could slash Jerusalem rent prices. Not sure if it has

Re: [Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa

2012-01-30 Thread Eddie Fernandes
Dear Eugene, Re: I see the points Eddie has made. Response: I do not think you do as you are leaping to conclusions without the facts . Re: The Congress hasn't put its manifesto out but rather testing the waters ... Response: This is not just an election idea but was first put out, I think, in

[Goanet] NRI Goans and their rights in Goa

2012-01-29 Thread Carvalho
I had posted this post, because I know people of substance read Goanet, to keep their pulse on the NRI community. I also hope Goan Associations worldwide take cognisance of it and engage in debate, which I know at least is happening in the UK. I hope Gulf Goans and Canadian GoansĀ galvanize as