Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-10 Thread Santosh Helekar
--- On Mon, 3/9/09, Marshall Mendonza mmendonz...@gmail.com wrote: 1. I do not see any denial that the killing of the swami triggered the violence in the above message. I absolutely do see a denial because Marshall did not mention that the swami was murdered, and the violence started in

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-10 Thread Nascy Caldeira
PI think Dr Jose and Mervyn Lobo need to apologise to Marshall for their unwarranted and false 'tirade' against Marshall. /P Pnbsp;/P PFirst Dr Jose 'reads out of context' and fires off, and takes sides with Santosh, when he need not interfere; unless he himself has proof of his allegations,

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-10 Thread amar kantak
EVERYBODY SEEMS TO HAVE A Phd ON RELIGION. HERE IS WHAT I HAVE TO SAY: All religious texts confirm that God grants life to human being to enable the soul to reunite with him through faith and devotion. Just as the soul resides within the body, God resides within the whole universe. God is

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-10 Thread Mervyn Lobo
Nascy Caldeira wrote: I think an unconditional APOLOGY is now due from Mervyn and Dr Jose for this particular non characteristic, unwarranted TIRADE against Marshall Mendoza. And WHY NOT??? Come on Mervyn and Jose: get off your high horse. Will you??       Nascy, The last thing Marshall

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-10 Thread Santosh Helekar
To the gratuitous attack below against Jose and Mervyn for not falling in line despite being non-vegetarians, Nasci Caldeira forgot to add Marlon and Alfredchacha. He wasted a perfectly good opportunity to abuse them as well. Please note that he is comparing Jose with Goan politicians who have

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-09 Thread Edward Verdes
Jose bab, unless I have missed out some posts, can you pls tell us what was the whole debate on ORISSA about? If both had agreed to the violence against christians in Orrisa n rest of the states I doubt you wud get a chance to write what you wrote below. And who are the OTHER LIARS on

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-09 Thread Santosh Helekar
--- On Mon, 3/9/09, Edward Verdes eddiever...@hotmail.com wrote: Jose bab, unless I have missed out some posts, can you pls tell us what was the whole debate on ORISSA about?  If both had  agreed to the violence against  christians in Orrisa n rest of the states I doubt you wud get a

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-09 Thread J. Colaco jc
Eddie Verdes wrote the following [1] Jose bab, unless I have missed out some posts, can you pls tell us what was the whole debate on ORISSA about? [2] If both had agreed to the violence against christians in Orrisa n rest of the states I doubt you wud get a chance to write what you wrote below.

[Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-09 Thread Marshall Mendonza
I refer to Jose Colaco's message under this subject. I am extremely doubtful whether Jose has been following the debate on this subject, otherwise he would have thought 100 times before shooting from his keyboard. Instead of going into the entire Ramayana and Mahabharata of the issue to get him

[Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-09 Thread Marshall Mendonza
Santosh Helekar: Eddie,What do you think the debate was about? Do you think by exposing the denial of the fact that the communal violence was triggered by the murder of the VHP swami and his associates, I was justifying the violence against Christians? Response: Would the good dotor provide

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-09 Thread Santosh Helekar
--- On Mon, 3/9/09, Marshall Mendonza mmendonz...@gmail.com wrote: Would the good dotor provide evidence/ proof of - 1. The fact that the killing of the swami triggered the violence against christians in August 2008 was denied by anyone. Here is the evidence for this: Further a very

[Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it

2009-03-09 Thread Marshall Mendonza
On response to my query: Would the good dotor provide evidence/ proof of - 1. The fact that the killing of the swami triggered the violence against christians in August 2008 was denied by anyone. Santosh replied: Here is the evidence for this: Further a very important and vital point in the

[Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-08 Thread J. Colaco jc
Marshall Mendonza wrote the following : 'Santosh has in the past JUSTIFIED the violence against christians in Orissa and termed it as retaliation for the murder of Swami Laxmananda.' Dear Marshall and GoaNet moderators, May I ask for evidence that Santoshbab has EVER JUSTIFIED violence against

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-08 Thread Alfred de Tavares
By no means of stretching, twisting or even...suborning imagination can Santosh be, ever, charged with being unbalanced in his reasoning or as being anti-Christian. We can only devoutly pray that persons of his moral rational ilk prolifirate fast wide all over India so we may aspire for

Re: [Goanet] Time to prove this statement or withdraw it .....unless

2009-03-08 Thread Santosh Helekar
--- On Sun, 3/8/09, Alfred de Tavares alfredtava...@hotmail.com wrote: We can only devoutly pray that persons of his moral rational ilk prolifirate fast wide all over India so we may aspire for a better quality of life...all Dear Alfredchacha, I appreciate this tribute, but it is no