Re: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and cults

2003-07-03 Thread Andrea Rapp
> "Do you >know what I call a Jew for Jesus? A Christian == Indeed, they are Christians who clothe themselves in the rituals and trappings of Judaism as a tactic of deception. HUC students made a video called "Missionary Impossible" as a tool to use with youngsters who are targeted b

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and cults

2003-07-02 Thread Rettberg, Dan
Thanks, Elisheva. You sum up my feelings on the subject well. The book I recommended is a serious scholarly study, and is not at all in the class of some materials we collect here at HUC in the name of academic freedom (white supremicist writings, for example), but that, privately, we may wish

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and cults

2003-07-02 Thread Shmuel Ben-Gad
I don't know that it is censorship. No library, so far as I know, prohibits ("censors") any publication but no library buys everything and libraries use standards like accuracy, quality, and the purpose and clientele of a particular library. Our library, for example, does collect a certain amount

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and cults

2003-07-02 Thread Elisheva Schwartz
I understand the difficulty we face, but what you are proposing is called censorship. Once we start down that slippery slope I'm not sure where we stop. (Do I, as an Orthodox Jew, refuse to circulate Gunther Plaut's Chumash?) After all, if I censor what I don't like, why can't everyone else cen

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and cults

2003-07-02 Thread Sarah Chandler
This website has a partial list of actual Hebrew-Christian churches in North America: http://www.fjmc.org/hebrewCawareness.html Temple Ohabei Shalom (in Brookline, MA, website: www.ohabei.org) has chosen to teach their high school students about "Jews for Jesus" by taking them on an unaccounted vi

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and cults

2003-07-02 Thread Stuart Schnee
True. Seems to me that Jewish Librarians need to take some sort of stand. Otherwise why not give out anti-Semitic books and "let the reader decide"? Stuart Schnee The Toby Press LLC PO Box 8531 New Milford, CT 06776-8531 www.tobypress.com =

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-07-01 Thread Rettberg, Dan
Over the years I have discovered that when it comes to academic studies of any kind (This book was based on Rabbi Harris-Shapiro's doctoral dissertation), the body of the work, and especially the notes and bibliographies, are far more important than the conclusions. I saw this work as a resour

Re: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-07-01 Thread Andrea Rapp
Be aware that Messianic Judaism by Carol Harris-Shapiro, which was recommended, gives a good picture of what messianics believe and practice, but that it also concludes that there is no valid way to exclude messianic Judaism from "authentic" Judaism. As I recall, this conclusion was made clear in

Re: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-06-30 Thread S. Alfassa Marks / FASSAC
Rachel, et al: I recommend Rabbi Tovia Singer. His group Outreach Judaism is an international organization that responds directly to the issues raised by missionaries and cults from a Jewish perspective. He is well known, and has a radio show as well. http://www.outreachjudaism.org/ Scott _

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-06-30 Thread Rettberg, Dan
You may wish to consult the book, "Messianic Judaism: a rabbi's journey through religious change in America," by Carol Harris-Shapiro (Boston: Beacon Press, 1999). Dan Rettberg Klau Library Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion Cincinnati, Ohio [EMAIL PROTECTED] ==

Re: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-06-30 Thread Andrea Rapp
Jews for Judaism is good but I like Outreach Judaism best of all. I have listened to Tovia Singer's tapes, read his material, and it's great. Also, he is an exciting speaker and presenter, and has a special presentation for teens on messianic Jewish recruitment. His website is outreachjudaism.org

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-06-30 Thread Steven M. Bergson
--- Stuart Schnee <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I highly recommend you contact the organization > "Jews for Judaism" - > they are the experts in this. I am sure they are on > the web, I think > located in Baltimore, MD. They are, indeed. http://www.jewsforjudaism.org/ They currently have onl

RE: [ha-Safran]: Judaism and Cults

2003-06-30 Thread Stuart Schnee
I highly recommend you contact the organization "Jews for Judaism" - they are the experts in this. I am sure they are on the web, I think located in Baltimore, MD. Stuart Schnee The Toby Press LLC PO Box 8531 New Milford, CT 06776-8531 www.tobypress.com ==