Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-12 Thread Phil Smith III
Peter Relson wrote: >I on the other hand do have sympathy. A highly significant reason that >z/OS still exists (and the same could have been said for its >predecessors OS/390 and MVS) is because of the enormous amount of time >and effort we have put into maintaining as much compatibility as we

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-12 Thread Peter Relson
That should just be made a syntax error. I have no sympathy for the "compatibility" argument. I on the other hand do have sympathy. A highly significant reason that z/OS still exists (and the same could have been said for its predecessors OS/390 and MVS) is because of the enormous amount of t

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-11 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Wed, 11 Oct 2023 15:44:39 +, Peter Relson wrote: > >As it happens, the offending sentence had already been removed from the 3.1 >book. Since the thread started before those books were generally available to >be looked at, it's not surprising that that was not realized. > I see that. Than

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-11 Thread Peter Relson
Paul G wrote I fear "unpredictable" is too often the writers' excuse when they don't know the answer to a request for clarification and can't find out. I don't think you will find that that is true in z/OS books. Writers do not make up usage of that word. They are asked to do so because the dev

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-08 Thread Michael Oujesky
Processing date from control card input is endemic to the financial industry, not just banks. I believe it stems from the fact that "daily" processing occurs after midnight, Michael At 11:08 AM 10/8/2023, Paul Gilmartin wrote: On Sat, 7 Oct 2023 22:30:52 +0200, Radoslaw Skorupka wrote: >To

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-08 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Sat, 7 Oct 2023 22:30:52 +0200, Radoslaw Skorupka wrote: >To be honest I consider date-related variables as pooor when >compared to batch scheduler features, especially ControlM (it is not >advertisement, just opinion). > You worked for a bank. I had a co-worker who had worked for a bank.

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-08 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Sat, 7 Oct 2023 18:42:42 +, Farley, Peter wrote: >I’ll admit I have NOT used symbol substitution in the “name” part (left of the >“=”) at all, only on the right (value) side, so the true answer is “I don’t >know”. Never had a reason to use substitution in the “name” part. > However infre

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-08 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Sat, 7 Oct 2023 13:10:36 -0500, Michael Oujesky wrote: >Dynamic symbols (date/time) can be evaluated at different points in >time during conversion, so if used multiple time in the JCL, they can >resolve to different values. My ROT was to never use a dynamic >symbol more that once in coding a

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-07 Thread Radoslaw Skorupka
ctober 7, 2023 1:45 PM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?] On Sat, 7 Oct 2023 09:41:56 -0700, Ed Jaffe wrote: On 9/20/2023 8:23 AM, Farley, Peter wrote: ... JCL symbols as part of the definition of othe

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-07 Thread Farley, Peter
that need. When I get a chance I will try the new feedback process. Peter From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Paul Gilmartin Sent: Saturday, October 7, 2023 1:45 PM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-07 Thread Michael Oujesky
Dynamic symbols (date/time) can be evaluated at different points in time during conversion, so if used multiple time in the JCL, they can resolve to different values. My ROT was to never use a dynamic symbol more that once in coding and where it was needed multiple time, set it to my own date

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-07 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Sat, 7 Oct 2023 09:41:56 -0700, Ed Jaffe wrote: >On 9/20/2023 8:23 AM, Farley, Peter wrote: >> ... JCL symbols as part of the definition of other JCL symbols works >> flawlessly every time. > Is this true alike for substitution both in the name (left of the "=") and in the value (right of the

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-10-07 Thread Ed Jaffe
On 9/20/2023 8:23 AM, Farley, Peter wrote: I believe that statement in the JCL Reference is in error and needs to be deleted or at the very least completely rewritten. My quite substantial experience using this technique over the last 10-15 years is that using JCL symbols as part of the defin

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-09-20 Thread Phil Smith III
Farley, Peter wrote: >I believe that statement in the JCL Reference is in error and needs to >be deleted or at the very least completely rewritten. My quite >substantial experience using this technique over the last 10-15 years >is that using JCL symbols as part of the definition of other JCL >symb

Re: JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-09-20 Thread Paul Gilmartin
Thanks for changing the Subject: as the topic drifted. On Wed, 20 Sep 2023 15:23:31 +, Farley, Peter wrote: >I believe that statement in the JCL Reference is in error and needs to be >deleted or at the very least completely rewritten. My quite substantial >experience using this technique o

JCL symbols used to define other JCL symbols [was: RE: Is SMP/E needed for installs?]

2023-09-20 Thread Farley, Peter
I believe that statement in the JCL Reference is in error and needs to be deleted or at the very least completely rewritten. My quite substantial experience using this technique over the last 10-15 years is that using JCL symbols as part of the definition of other JCL symbols works flawlessly e