Re: Questions on RFC 4293 Management Information Base for the Internet Protocol (IP)

2010-04-21 Thread Fred Baker
"we didn't pay enough attention" is a very kind way to put it. The entire SNMP exercise was about monitoring; those like me who tried to make things writable pushed rocks uphill politically. That, and the experience of trying to make event triggered management rather than poll-driven management,

Re: Questions on RFC 4293 Management Information Base for the Internet Protocol (IP)

2010-04-21 Thread Bill Fenner
2010/4/19 Tina TSOU : > In RFC 4293, > - ipAddressTable is described as writable, this table uses address > as index, but the critical information for configuring address, the > address prefix ipAddressPrefix node is read-only. It seems > contradict to me. Worse, the whole ipAddressPrefixTable is

Re: Questions on RFC 4293 Management Information Base for the Internet Protocol (IP)

2010-04-21 Thread Bill Fenner
[sorry if you get duplicates, replying from an address that actually *works* this time] 2010/4/19 Tina TSOU : > In RFC 4293, > - ipAddressTable is described as writable, this table uses address > as index, but the critical information for configuring address, the > address prefix ipAddressPrefix n

Ping...//Re: Questions on RFC 4293 Management Information Base for the Internet Protocol (IP)

2010-04-21 Thread Tina TSOU
; br...@innovationslab.net ; brian.haber...@jhuapl.edu ; s...@iwl.com Sent: Tuesday, April 20, 2010 11:11 AM Subject: Questions on RFC 4293 Management Information Base for the Internet Protocol (IP) Hi all, In RFC 4293, - ipAddressTable is described as writable, this table uses address

Questions on RFC 4293 Management Information Base for the Internet Protocol (IP)

2010-04-19 Thread Tina TSOU
Hi all, In RFC 4293, - ipAddressTable is described as writable, this table uses address as index, but the critical information for configuring address, the address prefix ipAddressPrefix node is read-only. It seems contradict to me. This table uses address as index, but the public network and VPN m