Re: redhat 6.1 RAID: what's different

1999-10-07 Thread Lawrence Dickson
James and all following, You seem to have missed the point Lauri made. We aren't saying don't offer GUIs. We are saying please offer GUIs AND offer command/script control capability. Then that baby user can make his first steps AND we wannabe power users don't get trapped in a pretty box of so

Re: redhat 6.1 RAID: what's different

1999-10-05 Thread Lawrence Dickson
I am solidly with Daniel on this. Why does no one ever use the fact that a graphical interface can be put on top of a text mode interface (we have multitasking don't we?) and thus kept equivalent instead of divergent? It is self-documenting too at the developer level. GUI means "Grossly Unpredi

Re: Hotswapping successes?

1999-09-21 Thread Lawrence Dickson
FAILED in 18 disk SCSI RAID-5 with no spares. I pulled a disk followed by a dd if=/dev/md0 and it tried to reconstruct without a new disk and went into uninterruptible sleep. Larry Dickson At 03:16 PM 9/21/99 -0500, Stephen Waters wrote: >i'm looking for a headcount on the following: > >wh

Re: Newbie: What to do when a disk fails?

1999-09-16 Thread Lawrence Dickson
? Larry At 10:41 PM 9/15/99 -0400, James Manning wrote: >[ Wednesday, September 15, 1999 ] Lawrence Dickson wrote: >>raidhotremove seems to THINK it can work without unmounting >> the raid array fs... same with the echo to /proc/scsi/scsi ... >> it's really all j

Re: Newbie: What to do when a disk fails?

1999-09-15 Thread Lawrence Dickson
lly all just syncing code, isn't it, guys? At 01:25 AM 9/16/99 +0100, Paul Jakma wrote: >On Tue, 14 Sep 1999, Lawrence Dickson wrote: > > So I take it the 18 disk RAID has to be unmounted before I > can do this. That's a killer. > >eek, i was tired.. i didn't

Re: Newbie: What to do when a disk fails?

1999-09-14 Thread Lawrence Dickson
(2.2.5-15) to the best stuff? More... At 01:42 AM 9/14/99 +0100, Paul Jakma wrote: >On Mon, 13 Sep 1999, Lawrence Dickson wrote: > > >1. unmount everything that's directly on the disk that isn't raid. > >2. swapoff if you have swap on that disk > > Didn'

Re: Newbie: What to do when a disk fails?

1999-09-13 Thread Lawrence Dickson
All, Here's a reprise of this ancient message. But there's method in my madness. We need to do just this and are hitting a wall. We have stock RedHat 6.0 with the 18 disk patch by Lance Robinson, and no other kernel, module or raidtools changes. We tried removing disk fifteen (sdo, scsi 2 0

Re: Ques: re: RH 6.0 and RAID setup

1999-09-03 Thread Lawrence Dickson
We've found we have to rename /etc/raidtab to something else. Haven't really figured out why. Larry At 10:56 AM 9/3/99 -0600, you wrote: >Hello Everyone, > >I was wondering if someone could verify that I have to patch the RH 6.0 >kernel to correctly configure and setup a RAID 1 array. The reas

Re: the 12 disk limit

1999-09-02 Thread Lawrence Dickson
All, The simple patch suggested by Lance Robinson was successful in bringing up 18 disk RAID-5 on our stock RedHat 6.0 system. The changes were made on a "pure" kernel,modules,raidtools with no other previous customization. Our test was on partitions distributed over 2 disks. We got repeat

RE: the 12 disk limit

1999-08-31 Thread Lawrence Dickson
All, MANY THANKS for this TREMENDOUS response to my query - at least 3 paths to a solution, wow! We'll try Lance's patch to start with, and let you know how it works. (We're still with stock RH 6.0.) But an official 27 disk solution will be really nice once we figure out how to upgrade the res

the 12 disk limit

1999-08-30 Thread Lawrence Dickson
All, I guess this has been asked before, but - when will the RAID code get past the 12 disk limit? We'd even be willing to use a variant - our customer wants 18 disk RAID-5 real bad. Larry Dickson Land-5 Corporation

Re: FAQ

1999-07-09 Thread Lawrence Dickson
These questions are from the point of view of 0.90 or higher (i.e. RH 6.0). - How do you recover a RAID1 or a RAID5 with a bad disk when you have no spares, i.e. how do you hotremove and hotadd? Please go through it step by step because many paths seem to lead to hangs. - How do you recover a RAID

raid on raid

1999-07-02 Thread Lawrence Dickson
We want to use Linux raid to make a raid out of pre-existing raids, which I thought was possible. We tried creating two RAID-1s of 2 disks each, then a RAID-0 of these two joined. We finished the mkraids on the RAID-1s before starting the RAID-0. It said something like running md. not good and h

Re: Raid-1 problem -STILL

1999-06-29 Thread Lawrence Dickson
At 10:25 AM 6/29/99 -0400, you wrote: With a similar problem in Raid-5 I had to use mkinitrd to add the raid personalities to initrd too - see man pages. Larry Dickson >I hate to be so thick. I'm still trying to get raid-1 working. Someone has been good enough to help me out, but I think I'

Re: raid 5 RedHat 6.0 gone on reboot

1999-06-14 Thread Lawrence Dickson
ALL RIGHT, the initrd approach WORKED, and I did not have to (ugh, yech) recompile any kernels! mkinitrd --preload raid5 /boot/initrd 2.2.5-15 was the magic command (for raid5), and in lilo.conf you then have to replace the version number line with initrd=/boot/initrd and then call lilo and re

Re: raid 5 RedHat 6.0 gone on reboot

1999-06-11 Thread Lawrence Dickson
Thanks, I checked all 4 of your bullets - (1) I assume I have autodetection since dmesg|more says autodetecting RAID arrays and then gives facts about the raid like (read) sdc2's sb offset: 2835392 [events: 0002] ... autorun ... ... created md1 bind ... running: now! sde2's event count

raid 5 RedHat 6.0 gone on reboot

1999-06-11 Thread Lawrence Dickson
I brought up a raid5 on my RH6.0 system, no kernel changes - it seemed happy. I put in persistent-superblock 1 and parity-algorithm left-symmetric and 3 disks, no spares. mkraid returned fast but disk lights kept going nearly an hour: /proc/mdstat said it was resyncing. There was one SCSI timeo

hot swapping

1999-06-09 Thread Lawrence Dickson
-0400, Michael McLagan wrote: >On Thu, 03 Jun 1999 16:16:06 -0700, Lawrence Dickson wrote: > >> In the raidtools-0.90-3 RPM, there are links suggestively named >>raidhotadd and raidhotremove to raidstart, but the man files and the howto >>don't seem to say anything about h

RAID1 kernel module missing?

1999-02-01 Thread Lawrence Dickson
Folks, I'm a newbie at Software RAID, with a system that works excellently with Redhat 5.2 (Linux 2.0.36) except it seems to be missing a kernel module for RAID-1. Pentium II system, 1 G of RAM (only 960M used), 3 SCSI adapters (all Adaptec), network adapter, floppy, tape; 4 SCSI disks