[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-30 Thread howard posner
On Mar 29, 2008, at 10:52 AM, Arthur Ness wrote: > Unless you > have some urge to talk about Leonardo da Vinci's wandering beard. I just acquired such an urge, at least to the extent of understanding the reference. What are we talking about? -- To get on or off this list see list information

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-30 Thread howard posner
On Mar 29, 2008, at 10:52 AM, Arthur Ness wrote: > Where did Richafort find it? In a registered letter from Henry VIII. -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-30 Thread David Tayler
Well, my example was really to show how tricky attribution is. But you can dig a bit further. In this case, you can go by the Grove, but the Grove is not really an authoritative source in that it is a secondary reference. Yes, we all read it, but it is a bit like Trader Joe's as well. The real g

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread David Tayler
Geez that was completely garbled. Obviously I need to adjust my meds, what I meant was I would never mean to imply that Arthur Ness' knowledge of anything is less than truly stellar in all respects. And also, the Francesco book is my favorite lute book. dt To get on or off this list see lis

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread David Tayler
cia Suite, Op. 8a, >performed by the >Carlos Chavez Symphony Orchestra; >Fernando Lozano, conductor. >Click on the CML link here >http://mysite.verizon.net/arthurjness/ >=== > >- Original Message - >From: "David Tayler" &

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread vance wood
rom the menu--simple. In the mean time post something you might be interested in or--- is it that you really have nothing to say? - Original Message - From: "Peter Martin" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Lute list" Sent: Saturday, March 29, 2008 4:15 PM Subject:

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread Peter Martin
Sean, I think we're just suffering a visit from Wowbagger the Infinitely Prolonged. Once he has insulted everyone individually he will move on On 29/03/2008, Sean Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > I rather enjoy learning more about the music I like. Maybe you should > join the Nintendo l

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread Sean Smith
I rather enjoy learning more about the music I like. Maybe you should join the Nintendo lute society where things move a little quicker. Or start one where the insults move more to your taste. Sean Begin forwarded message: you should discuss with each other via telephono..don't be exi

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread igor .
you should discuss with each other via telephono..don't be exibionist please . > > > > > > > > > > > -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread igor .
you gentleman's , you are so B O r i N g.. > > > -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread Arthur Ness
Original Message - From: "David Tayler" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "lute-cs.dartmouth.edu" Sent: Saturday, March 29, 2008 3:02 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Fingering question | It is a favorite pastime to say pieces are really not by X, | and it is easy because, when you come

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread David Tayler
Well spotted Peter!!! dt At 02:46 AM 3/29/2008, you wrote: >How amazing. I never noticed this before. But yes, Francesco's Richafort >De mon triste deplaisir (Ness 121) follows the melody of Pastyme right the >way through from beginning to end. > >Anyone know the words of the Richafort? 'De mon

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread Ron Andrico
, Ron Andrico http://www.mignarda.com > Date: Sat, 29 Mar 2008 00:12:53 -0400> To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu> From: > [EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [LUTE] Re: Fingering question> > - Original > Message - > From: "Ron Andrico" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>&

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread Arthur Ness
- Original Message - From: "Peter Martin" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Lute list" Sent: Saturday, March 29, 2008 5:46 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye | How amazing. I never noticed this before. But yes, Francesco's Rich

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread Peter Martin
How amazing. I never noticed this before. But yes, Francesco's Richafort De mon triste deplaisir (Ness 121) follows the melody of Pastyme right the way through from beginning to end. Anyone know the words of the Richafort? 'De mon triste deplaisir' seems a long way away from 'Pastyme with good

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread Benjamin Narvey
Is "Pastyme with Good Companye" really not by Henry the VIII? Excuse this perhaps very silly question from a 17c-iste, but I always assumed it was actually by the great man himself - although there could easily be new information/finds/theories I am not aware of. I note however that the New Grove

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-29 Thread David Tayler
It is a favorite pastime to say pieces are really not by X, and it is easy because, when you come right down to it, in the renaissance there is no real way to prove anybody wrote anything. People argue whether Shakespeare existed. You can't go exclusively on attribution, because they are often wron

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-28 Thread Arthur Ness
- Original Message - From: "Ron Andrico" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> (One issue with Francesco' 'La Compagna' is that the piece may not really be his after all, coming from a much later source.) ooo Victor Coelho's theory was throughly

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-27 Thread Rob MacKillop
Dear Gernot, The composer who has caused me the most concern over fingering is Fuenllana. There are many instances where he could have made life easier for everyone. I don't know if being blind was an issue here. I doubt it. What occurred to me is that some odd fingerings could have resulted from

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-27 Thread Ron Andrico
Dear Gernot: I think we all wrestle with fingering questions such as the one you point out. Another is in Francesco's 'La Compagna' where we must dash up and down the fingerboard on the chanterelle, while it would be much easier to use a higher position on a lower course. I think the ori

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2008-03-26 Thread David Tayler
The original tab picture would be instantly seen as hexachord relationships, so refingering would not only be possible but is amply represented in source variants. To a skilled player, the tab represents a set of relationships. Alterations not only include "changing courses in midstream" but also

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-09 Thread G. Crona
gt; To: Sent: Wednesday, November 09, 2005 2:15 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Fingering question > Vance and All, > > Here is the chord again, this time with the preceding measure and the rest > of its own measure > > | f | f| > |---|--| > | | b| > |---|--| &g

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-08 Thread corun
Vance and All, Here is the chord again, this time with the preceding measure and the rest of its own measure | f | f| |---|--| | | b| |---|--| | d | | |---|--| | c | d| |---|--| | a |d | |---|--| | | b| |---|--| Actually the two preceding mea

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-08 Thread Craig Allen
Vance wrote: > >After rethinking my previous response I should have included that a lot >depends on what comes after and what preceeded it. Your fingering is >correct in most cases that I can imagine. Vance, You're quite correct. I will post the full measure the chord is in as well as the prece

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-07 Thread Vance Wood
:13 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Fingering question > At 05:45 PM 11/6/2005, Mathias Rösel wrote: > > >if 5 is your LH pinky and 3 is middle finger, I should say yes. And > >remember to get you the small axe with no more than 50 cm vibrating > >string length, so as to be able to

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-06 Thread corun
At 05:45 PM 11/6/2005, Mathias Rösel wrote: >if 5 is your LH pinky and 3 is middle finger, I should say yes. And >remember to get you the small axe with no more than 50 cm vibrating >string length, so as to be able to do it >:) Yes, 5 is the LH pinky and 3 is the middle finger. And thanks, the ne

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-06 Thread Charles Browne
I tried it and found, for my hand , that is was marginally easier to get the fourth finger down on the 'd' with the 5th on the 'f'. That way, it allowed me to get the barre a bit straighter. 60cm vsl not nice though!:-) Charles To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question

2005-11-06 Thread Mathias R�sel
> |f > |- > |b > |- > | > |- > |d > |- > | > |- > |b > |- > > Would it be common to barre across the b fret and then use 5 for the first > course and 3 for the fourth? I think that's the only way I'd be able to do > it with my small stretch. if 5 is your LH pinky and 3 is middle finger, I shou