[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-09 Thread Leonard Williams
I've seen some of the manifests via Ancestry.com--the handwriting is not always too clear. My great grandfather came over from Denmark and promptly changed his name from Jörgen Wilhelm Hansen to John William Hansen. On a more musical note, I once heard a family chamber group

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-09 Thread howard posner
On May 8, 2013, at 11:33 AM, r.turov...@gmail.com wrote: The purported Ellis Island name manglings is a myth. Every immigrant's name had to be and was matched to the ship's manifest, and any deviation was massively illegal. As was selling alcoholic beverages in the United States between 1920

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Christopher Stetson
Hi, Tobiah and all. Yes, officially you're right Tobiah, but Francesco lived at a time when Europe was transitioning to the use of established family names, so many names that we use today would seem ridiculous if interpreted in their original meaning. Basically, European

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Christopher Wilke
Tobiah, Nothing wrong with calling him da Milano, although in actually usage he's one of the few, like Michelangelo or Josquin, who are frequently referred to by first name. We do say, da Vinci. Yes, this literally translates to of __, but place names were - and are -

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Dan Winheld
For a while (in the Siena book, anyway) Francesco was da Parigi- but in the end just a vacation- Busman's Holiday. And of course, Alberto da Ripa- who stayed in France, but then Francophoned to de Rippe, like Jean Paul Paladin- Had lute, would travel. It can get complicated; Ottaviano dei

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Christopher Stetson
Indeed on the Ellis Island factor. I had a harpsichord playing colleague whose family was Goldberg because her grandfather had immigrated from Russia alone at 14 years old. He was standing in line behind a man named Goldberg. When they reached the desk, the official assumed he

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread r.turov...@gmail.com
Dan, The purported Ellis Island name manglings is a myth. Every immigrant's name had to be and was matched to the ship's manifest, and any deviation was massively illegal. So any changes people claim were made either at naturalization, or at the passport office in the old country. Cheers, RT

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Nancy Carlin
My last name is another Ellis Island story - my husband's family came from the Russia/Poland area and had a name that was hard to pronounce, so wanted something that people in the US couple say. They chose Carlin, no realizing that they had a name from another ethnic group (Irish) that was no

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Dan Winheld
Name checking against a ship's manifest sounds too logical to be dismissed. More likely mangling happened during hasty, crowded embarkations; where legality taxonomic scrupulousness were more ephemeral- but the errors only coming to light at Ellis Island, where the shouting itself (according

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Dan Winheld
What? You're NOT Irish? One of my best friends recently found out that he isn't Irish either. Over 60 years of being virulently anti Anglo-Saxon down the drain after a genealogical search revealed he is of nearly 100% English ancestry. One rotten, interconnected species, the lot of us. On

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
To tell you how I know this: Some 10 years ago I embarked on a search for a branch of the family that was missing for 80 years in South Africa (their surname was SAUTSCHECK, and the search was successful, all SouthAfrican cousins were found! (the few NorthAmerican were not...)). In the process

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Roman Turovsky
It ended up on my shelf! Sorry to disappoint you, but Elhaik theory has already been discredited: he made a lot of idiotic claims, such as Georgians and Armenians having been proto-Khazar etc. He seems to be one of those scholars whose goal is refute the connection between

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Christopher Stetson
In re: horse-thieves and revolutionaries of all colors among our ancestors. Indeed, even the ancestors of this Mayflower descendant. And don't forget our beloved Anglo-Saxon motto: Think locally, act globally. :-( Chris. On Wed, May 8, 2013 at 3:50 PM, Roman Turovsky

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread r.turov...@gmail.com
There is another dictum: Talk British, think Yiddish! RT On 5/8/2013 5:37 PM, Christopher Stetson wrote: In re: horse-thieves and revolutionaries of all colors among our ancestors. Indeed, even the ancestors of this Mayflower descendant. And don't forget our beloved

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-08 Thread Christopher Stetson
That one I like! On Wed, May 8, 2013 at 5:40 PM, [1]r.turov...@gmail.com [2]r.turov...@gmail.com wrote: There is another dictum: Talk British, think Yiddish! RT On 5/8/2013 5:37 PM, Christopher Stetson wrote: In re: horse-thieves and revolutionaries of all colors among

[LUTE] Re: Frank from Milan

2013-05-07 Thread Joshua Burkholder
It's certainly more proper to refer to him simply as Francesco for short, which is how I usually see him referred in articles and such. Just like we say Leonardo and not da Vinci, and so on. There are many examples of this. Joshua (who also happens to be da Milano) On May 8, 2013, at 4:43