[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-07 Thread Ron Fletcher
To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: [LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute Some of the old Martin OOO and Washburn parlor guitars also had the V-neck. I absolutely hated it. Only on sweaters and undershirts for me.-Dan To get on or off this list see list information at http

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-06 Thread David Tayler
I prefer a thick neck and even a V neck on a 6 course. If the V (rounded V) is done properly, it fits right into the hand, and you can hang your thumb over the top a bit, just as it sometimes appears in iconography (and is dismissed as artistic rendering). This also permits the thumb to play

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-06 Thread Daniel Winheld
Some of the old Martin OOO and Washburn parlor guitars also had the V-neck. I absolutely hated it. Only on sweaters and undershirts for me.-Dan I prefer a thick neck and even a V neck on a 6 course. If the V (rounded V) is done properly, it fits right into the hand, and you can hang your

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-06 Thread Arthur Ness
@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Tuesday, November 06, 2007 4:07 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute Also some delightful quotes courtesy of Denys about using the thumb to stop the sixth fret. There are several iconography studies of lute where the authors poohpooh the hanging thumb

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-06 Thread David Tayler
Also some delightful quotes courtesy of Denys about using the thumb to stop the sixth fret. There are several iconography studies of lute where the authors poohpooh the hanging thumb as artistic misrepresentation or poor playing--just read Capirola! Alla volte el si puo accomodarsi su la corde

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-06 Thread David Tayler
There is a great picture of a rounded v neck on the Gerle lute here http://www.lutesandguitars.co.uk/htm/cat01.htm Perhaps UV would be a better term dt At 12:07 PM 11/6/2007, you wrote: Some of the old Martin OOO and Washburn parlor guitars also had the V-neck. I absolutely hated it. Only on

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread Martyn Hodgson
Play it like popular guitars are (and often were) commonly played: ie with the neck cradled in the V of your hand between the thumb and index finger. Indeed as violinists do. Luca Manassero [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dear Collective Wisdom, I need some advice on the neck section of an

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread Daniel Winheld
Interesting- my experience has been the exact opposite. My hybrid 6 course (Arnault de Zwolle body mated to a typical late 15th/early 16th century 8 fret 6 course fingerboard) originally had a very thin neck; extremely uncomfortable (hand cramped up) but only after about 20 minutes or so of

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread Guy Smith
@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: [LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute Interesting- my experience has been the exact opposite. My hybrid 6 course (Arnault de Zwolle body mated to a typical late 15th/early 16th century 8 fret 6 course fingerboard) originally had a very thin neck; extremely uncomfortable

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread wikla
Dear all, I have the Magno dieffopruchar, Venice, c.1550 (collection of J A Beare Ltd, London) by Stephen Barber, and I very much like the shape of of the neck of that instrument. I suppose Stephen made it just as it is in the original. And as Martyn wrote, the shape of my left hand around

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread wikla
I wrote I have the Magno dieffopruchar, Venice, c.1550 (collection of J A Beare Ltd, London) by Stephen Barber, and I very much like the shape of of the neck of that instrument. I suppose Stephen made it just as it is in the original. And as Martyn wrote, the shape of my left hand

[LUTE] Re: Neck section in a 6 course lute

2007-11-05 Thread Denys Stephens
Dear Luca, There is an excellent article by Stephen Barber on the Beare collection Dieffopruchar lute in 'The Lute' (Lute Society Journal) 1982, volume XXII Part 2. I believe that his drawings of the original continue to be available, and they are likely to be the starting point used by makers who