Hi all,
Please can you recommend the best, most objective, and most informative history
of the USSR.
Thank you very much in advance.
Best wishes. C
___
Marxist-Leninist-List mailing list
DEar Calvin,
Greetings.
You can check with the moderator on this one, but Carr has written extensively
on this subject. The problem that I find with his works is that it includes
about 3 or 4 volumes of history! But a few people have comment that his
version is objective and closer to the
I denounce the statement below advocating the violent extermination of
people/classes, and consider such advocacy political terrorism, unacceptable to
a discussion list such as this.
I have no connection with or anything to do with individuals advocating
extermination - in this case
Doesn't Marx say that the only War is Class War?
How do you expect to win a war for the Worker?
--- On Mon, 12/20/10, waistli...@aol.com waistli...@aol.com wrote:
From: waistli...@aol.com waistli...@aol.com
Subject: [MLL] I denounce the statement below advocating . . . . .
To:
I do not understand the questions below in the context of the statement
produced. Please explain or reformulate. Advocacy of extermination of
individuals as they constitute class; and a call for violent extermination of
these individuals is akin to the reality of German fascism and Indian
I think that we're going overboard here with this statement produced renew by
Waistline; we can see that Waistline has already disassociated himself from
the extermination word; so you're SAFE, don't worry. NO one here is
advocating Terrorism or the like, as I see it. Also, No need to
Thanks Frankenstein580, I am very grateful for your response. I have read Carr
and also the excellent short course. What do people think of Getty, Davies,
Naumov, Thurston, Fitzpatrick and other so-called revisionist anti-communist
historians of the USSR? Thurston's work is very good, in my
Comrade Kale,
You are correct that it is a class war we fight and it will be a literal
violent armed struggle and only a Marxist deviant will make any and all
attempts to negate the violence of class struggle. Every great Marxist leader
from Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin,
Comrade Calvin,
I am not familiar with Comrade f580's reference to Carr but I do fully concur
with his recommendation of The History of the Communist Party of the Soviet
Union (Bolshevik) which was edited by a Commission of the Central Committee of
the CPSU (B) and authorized by this
Comrade Kale,
I just realized a mistake I have made. I responded to this query of yours on
Saturday but forgot to post it so I will do so now. My aologies.
There is a lot of sectarianism in the world and I have always railed against
the US communist movement in general on this
Dear Kale,
Yes, I've read Getty, Naumov, Thurston, Davis Their research and
revelations have been a tremendous vindication, serendipitously, if I may, or
perhaps inadvertently, of comrade Stalin and the dictatorship of the
proletariat. They don't seem to be revolutionary communists to
Not really, since the German genocide targeted people based on their ethnicity,
period.
JS
“The entire party and country should hurl into the fire and break the neck of
anyone who dared trample underfoot the sacred edict of the party on the defense
of women's rights.”
- Enver Hoxha, 1967
12 matches
Mail list logo
