Re: CPAN Rating

2004-06-17 Thread Kevin C. Krinke
On Thu, 2004-06-17 at 11:59, Adrian Howard wrote: > On 17 Jun 2004, at 11:41, khemir nadim wrote: > [snip] > > OK. but a module without a readme with meaning ful content, a minimum > > of > > documentation is not "anything" it's "nothing" so I'd say it's OK to > > not > > allow "nothing" to get i

Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread A. Pagaltzis
* Mark Stosberg <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [2004-06-17 16:15]: > So I think a good name might be JavaScript::Tooltip::HTML. I put in another vote for this. Regards, -- Aristotle "If you can't laugh at yourself, you don't take life seriously enough."

Re: CPAN rating

2004-06-17 Thread SilvioCVdeAlmeida
Well, I step into this thread because I _really_ think it's complicating some (maybe) simple thing. There can be many distinct actions: 1. search/browse CPAN for a module. 2. use (or require :) a module. 2.1 use it because I'm in a hurry or don't like to rewrite code. 2.2 use it because I don't

Re: CPAN Rating

2004-06-17 Thread Adrian Howard
On 17 Jun 2004, at 11:41, khemir nadim wrote: [snip] OK. but a module without a readme with meaning ful content, a minimum of documentation is not "anything" it's "nothing" so I'd say it's OK to not allow "nothing" to get into CPAN. [snip] Tosh ;-) If I removed the README file from one of my CPAN

Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread Mark Stosberg
On Thu, Jun 17, 2004 at 08:13:08AM -0500, Ken Williams wrote: > > Yeah, HTML::Tooltip and CGI::Tooltip seem like the obvious names. I > don't think you need to put "Javascript" into the name, that's too much > information. Actually, I like JavaScript::Tooltip. If the the code is not HTML-speci

Re: CPAN Rating

2004-06-17 Thread Chris Josephes
On Wed, 16 Jun 2004, Fergal Daly wrote: > On Wed, Jun 16, 2004 at 06:39:22PM -0300, SilvioCVdeAlmeida wrote: > > Let's write it better: > > 1. FORBID any module without a meaningful readme with all its (possibly > > recursive) dependencies, its pod and any other relevant information > > inside. >

RE: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread Chris Josephes
I'm 50/50 on this. Just because a module name mentions "Javascript" doesn't mean it would immediately be discounted by other developers. If people need something to handle Tooltips, they'll use it, or at least read the pod documentation. Also, there are lots of other tooltip implementations out

Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread Ken Williams
On Jun 17, 2004, at 7:36 AM, darren chamberlain wrote: * Becky Alcorn [2004/06/17 12:25]: We're looking at releasing our new module CGI::Tooltip onto CPAN. This module provides a simple perl interface to Walter Zorn's elegant Javascript tooltip library (http://www.walterzorn.com/tooltip/tooltip

Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread darren chamberlain
* Becky Alcorn [2004/06/17 12:25]: > We're looking at releasing our new module CGI::Tooltip onto CPAN. This > module provides a simple perl interface to Walter Zorn's elegant Javascript > tooltip library (http://www.walterzorn.com/tooltip/tooltip_e.htm). This > library provides a flexible way of

Re: CPAN Rating

2004-06-17 Thread Eric Cholet
Le 17 juin 04, à 12:41, khemir nadim a écrit : OK. but a module without a readme with meaning ful content, a minimum of documentation is not "anything" it's "nothing" so I'd say it's OK to not allow "nothing" to get into CPAN. We, of course, want to avoid waisting our time but I think all want t

RE: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread Pearce, Martyn
Yeah, that makes sense to me. >-Original Message- >From: khemir nadim [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: Thursday, June 17, 2004 11:52 AM >To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Subject: Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip > > >OK that was the first part of my proposal (and I find your >explication for its dismi

Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread khemir nadim
OK that was the first part of my proposal (and I find your explication for its dismissa fine) but as was explained in the original posting, this module needs a library to be installed. Wouldn't it be nice for the people browsing around to get that information right away? Would CGI::Tooltip::Whatev

Re: CPAN Rating

2004-06-17 Thread khemir nadim
"Eric Wilhelm" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message news:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > >FORBID any module without a meaningful readme with all its (possibly > >recursive) dependencies, its pod and any other relevant information > >inside. > I don't think it is in the spirit of CPAN to "FORBID" anything. O

RE: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread Pearce, Martyn
I am not convinced of this. As I read it, the developer using CGI::Tooltip needs no Javascript knowledge; I think I would see CGI::Javascript::Tooltip and immediately exclude it as I have no knowledge of Javascript. It should be made clear in the docs of the module that javascript is required at

Re: New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread khemir nadim
I think it would be appropriate to further catalogue the module name under "Java" or the name od the specific library you interface with. "Becky Alcorn" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message news:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > We're looking at releasing our new module CGI::Tooltip onto CPAN. This > module pr

Re: failures that aren't failures

2004-06-17 Thread khemir nadim
"Fergal Daly" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in message news:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Hi all, > > One of my modules has a failure noted against it that was caused by the > tester's wonky Perl installation. How can this be removed? I don't have this problem but my modules sometimes fail on windows platform

Re: CPAN Rating

2004-06-17 Thread Leon Brocard
Ken Williams sent the following bits through the ether: > Dependencies are now listed in the META.yml file, which is human- and > machine-readable. Only in recent modules which use Module::Build. Whereas it's not that hard[2] to get "good enough" dependencies for the rest. Now decide who's going

New module: CGI::Tooltip

2004-06-17 Thread Becky Alcorn
We're looking at releasing our new module CGI::Tooltip onto CPAN. This module provides a simple perl interface to Walter Zorn's elegant Javascript tooltip library (http://www.walterzorn.com/tooltip/tooltip_e.htm). This library provides a flexible way of adding good looking tooltips (onmouseovers