Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-29 Thread Jan van Wijk
On Mon, 28 Oct 2013 19:06:24 + Steve Cottrell wrote: I can say that I've never accidentally turned on video on any camera I own. Me neither ;-) I have, several times. But only with the 'Q'. It has a mode-dial that is NOT locked, and can easily be moved a notch when taking it from the bag

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Mark Roberts
P.J. Alling wrote: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/essays/an_appeal_for_divergence_and_simplicity.shtml Excellent article. Thanks for pointing it out since I almost never look at Luminous Landscape any more (that site used to be a daily must read before it became a kind of Robb Report for

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
It's not the simplicity itself that's at issue. It's the original UNIX creed, programs that do one thing well. I want a still camera that does still photography well, that's ergonomically suited to it. Something that takes good quality photographs printable up to a certain size. I don't

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread David Parsons
I really don't think you should be looking to the Unix world for simplicity and design cues. On Mon, Oct 28, 2013 at 9:57 AM, P.J. Alling webstertwenty...@gmail.com wrote: It's not the simplicity itself that's at issue. It's the original UNIX creed, programs that do one thing well. I want a

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Stan Halpin
I can say that I have had that experience, several times, with the E-PL2. Rather than going through the process of reprogramming the button - i.e., setting it so that accidental button-pushes would be less troublesome - I sold the camera. Why would anybody think of putting a big honking button

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Steve Cottrell
On 27/10/13, David Parsons, discombobulated, unleashed: I can say that I've never accidentally turned on video on any camera I own. Me neither ;-) -- Cheers, Cotty ___/\__Broadcast, Corporate, || (O) |Web Video Production --www.seeingeye.tv

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Steve Cottrell
On 27/10/13, Joseph McAllister, discombobulated, unleashed: In that vein, movies, whilst watching the F-1 race in India this morning, I noticed that each of the team's row of engineers peering at LCD screens of the thousands of sensors on their drivers cars had a slot between the screens and the

re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape conflated with Re: K-3 manual now available (PDF)

2013-10-28 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
There are good situations for when the larger sensor in a DSLR or TTL-electronic camera, as well as the availability of the range of lenses they can use, makes sense for video work. At least at the price point I can afford in video cameras … Even professional movie makers choose DSLRs and

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Larry Colen
On Mon, Oct 28, 2013 at 09:57:43AM -0400, P.J. Alling wrote: It's not the simplicity itself that's at issue. It's the original UNIX creed, programs that do one thing well. With the ability to combine an arbitrary number of those small programs, each with their own menus of arguments, together,

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
On 10/28/2013 4:33 PM, Larry Colen wrote: On Mon, Oct 28, 2013 at 09:57:43AM -0400, P.J. Alling wrote: It's not the simplicity itself that's at issue. It's the original UNIX creed, programs that do one thing well. With the ability to combine an arbitrary number of those small programs, each

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
On Oct 28, 2013, at 1:50 PM, P.J. Alling webstertwenty...@gmail.com wrote: I also want the camera to report to me what is happening at the raw file level, not the processed jpeg. I want to know just how close I am to clipping my whites and blacks. That would be nice, does /any/ current

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
No problem Mark, scouring the internet so you don't have to. On 10/28/2013 9:37 AM, Mark Roberts wrote: P.J. Alling wrote: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/essays/an_appeal_for_divergence_and_simplicity.shtml Excellent article. Thanks for pointing it out since I almost never look at

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Larry Colen
On Mon, Oct 28, 2013 at 04:50:31PM -0400, P.J. Alling wrote: On 10/28/2013 4:33 PM, Larry Colen wrote: On Mon, Oct 28, 2013 at 09:57:43AM -0400, P.J. Alling wrote: I also want the camera to report to me what is happening at the raw file level, not the processed jpeg. I want to know just how

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
That's very true of complex computing devices. Even Windows when it was based on MS-DOS (and NT when it's UI wasn't tightly coupled it's DOS), there were things that were at best cumbersome if not impossible to do except from the command prompt. But that's still a side issue. There are only

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread David Parsons
What is important to you isn't necessarily important to someone else. I am really having trouble figuring out what specific problem there is with video on a still camera. Don't use it. I don't use the video function on my K-5. I also don't use the TAv mode, but I don't complain that it takes up

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
So what you're saying is that you're missing the point of a dedicated stills camera, or you're missing my point. There are a lot of things that are available even on the K20D that I don't ever use. However they also don't get in the way of things that I do use. From everything I know the

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Bob W
When things start becoming multifunction their use as a specialised thing suffers. Consider the Swiss Army knife, for example, or bicycle multitools - pretty good at a range of things, but not the best at any of them, and lacking the usability of the specialist thing. My bike multi tool has a

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
You obviously know little about the history of UNIX. Feature creep infected it early, but it doesn't change the original concept, and some versions remained true to that concept for a long time, not BSD unfortunately. It also doesn't change my point, though maybe it proves it. If I wanted

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Larry Colen
On Mon, Oct 28, 2013 at 07:15:27PM -0400, P.J. Alling wrote: You obviously know little about the history of UNIX. Feature creep infected it early, but it doesn't change the original concept, and some versions remained true to that concept for a long time, not BSD unfortunately. It also

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread David Parsons
Please don't lecture me about Unix or it's history. You tout Unix as an example of a utopian set of programs that are simple and good design, then go on to say that they suffer from the exact same thing you don't like about cameras. I'm curious why you put so much stock into what reviewers are

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread P.J. Alling
I brought up the Unix credo as something to be emulated not Unix itself, which I thought I made perfectly clear. I'll cop to making a comment on your ahistorical attitude maybe. But lecturing you on UNIX? I wouldn't presume, I haven't worked on software to run under UNIX in 10 years. You

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Stan Halpin
P.J - you say: From everything I know the only thing on the K-5 family of cameras that I really feel I need that's been done away with is the external SR switch. It was replaced, if you take an inventory of available controls with the dedicated Live View button. There is an

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape conflated with Re: K-3 manual now available (PDF)

2013-10-28 Thread Stan Halpin
You and Paul both make good points about the value of video within a DSLR. So, I will stipulate that video does have value to some. Do I care if it is included on my own camera? Not really, it doesn't bother me as long as its presence doesn't impede my use of the camera for still images (e.g.,

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Brian Walters
Quoting Stan Halpin s...@stans-photography.info: There is an interesting feature on the K-5 that I recently discovered. Assume SR is turned on. Put the camera on a tripod and set the shutter release for Remote activation. Et voile, the SR is automagically turned off (and cannot be turned

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Ann Sanfedele
It turns off when the camera is on the tripod and you lock up the mirror... remote or no I found that out accidentally when I thought I had forgotten to switch it off. ann On 10/28/2013 23:14, Brian Walters wrote: Quoting Stan Halpin s...@stans-photography.info: There is an interesting

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-28 Thread Stan Halpin
And I would have probably found out a lot sooner if I had used a tripod more often . . . stan On Oct 28, 2013, at 11:14 PM, Brian Walters wrote: Quoting Stan Halpin s...@stans-photography.info: There is an interesting feature on the K-5 that I recently discovered. Assume SR is turned on.

An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-27 Thread P.J. Alling
Ruminating on the K-3 and the various reviews of the K-5 family of cameras where the reviewer took off points for clunky ways to get into video mode, (this was especially true of DPReview IIRC), I found myself wanting to scream in the guy's face. What is it about it being primarily a Still

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-27 Thread David Parsons
He should just use a film camera if he's that worried about simplicity and video creep. I can say that I've never accidentally turned on video on any camera I own. On Sun, Oct 27, 2013 at 8:39 PM, P.J. Alling webstertwenty...@gmail.com wrote: Ruminating on the K-3 and the various reviews of the

Re: An appeal for Divergence and Simplicity from the Luminous Landscape

2013-10-27 Thread Joseph McAllister
In that vein, movies, whilst watching the F-1 race in India this morning, I noticed that each of the team's row of engineers peering at LCD screens of the thousands of sensors on their drivers cars had a slot between the screens and the laptops on the bench through which a DSLR was sliding back