Why was the Taft-Hartley Act not rescinded

2004-03-18 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
By invoking Taft-Hartley against the longshore workers, Bush is effectively declaring war on the working class here and the Iraqi people simultaneously. - Jack Heyman, business agent for ILWU Local 10, cited in Counterpunch (2002). I agree with Shane Mage on the Labor Management Relations

Why the Democratic Party Attacks Nader the Green Party

2004-03-18 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Among the liberal pundits who cry Anybody But Bush, it's open season on Ralph Nader and the Green Party. Some wonder why the Democratic leaders and intellectuals attack Nader and the Greens, especially given that more Democrats voted for Bush than Nader in 2000: Bush received the votes of 12

Re: Reply to Doug Henwood on Ralph Nader

2004-03-18 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Could someone explain what Ralph Nader's candidacy has to do with the development of a socialist party in the U.S.? I could swear he was a petit bourgeois who believed in the beauties of small business and competition. This seems to be more a kind of supercilious political racism on your

Dollars Per Vote: Green vs. Democratic (Historical accuracy)

2004-03-18 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
At 10:46 PM -0500 3/17/04, Julio Huato wrote: Today in the U.S., continual agitation of the sort described by Marx can and must be conducted (not only but also) within the DP. Not cost-effective. It costs a left-wing candidate more to run in the Democratic presidential caucuses and primaries than

Teaching and Politics, was Re: ...Socialist Scholars Conf

2004-03-18 Thread Carrol Cox
Because of ISU computer problems I could not send this when written Tuesday afternoon. joanna bujes wrote: Yoshie Furuhashi wrote: Question: Is there any way to prepare the ground? Can we take notes from the methods of the fundamentalists and say, infiltrate the educational system? This

Fetters on Forces of Production? was Re: RS

2004-03-18 Thread Carrol Cox
Another post I couldn't send Tuesday Devine, James wrote: I worry about this old chestnut exhaustion of its historical potential. These days, the historical potential of capitalism seems to be the destruction of nature on Earth. The phrase also seems to be part of the teleological

Re: Dollars Per Vote: Green vs. Democratic (Historical accuracy)

2004-03-18 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
(Cf. In 1996, Nader opted to cap his campaign expenditures at $5,000 and ended up with 581,000 votes. Nader's DPV: $0.01, says Norman Solomon in News That Still Goes Unreported: 'Dollars Per Vote' at http://www.fair.org/media-beat/980604.html -- our Consumer Advocate sure knows how to get his

Re: Historical Accuracy

2004-03-18 Thread Joel Wendland
Thanks for helping to make concrete how CP'ers approach these questions. There are class differences between Social Democratic Parties on one hand and the Democratic Party in the USA. Lenin advocated a united front between the Communists and the Social Democrats on a class basis. The Democratic

Re: Historical Accuracy

2004-03-18 Thread Louis Proyect
Joel Wendland wrote: The social democratic parties Lenin advocated unity with also were rooted in slavery and imperialism. I'm not sure why you'd choose to try to make a distinction on this point between them and our Democrats. The social democratic parties you are referring to were part of the

Re: 93 posts Tuesday

2004-03-18 Thread Michael Perelman
Thanks Chris. You are absolutely right. All too much of this thread and those that connected to it seemed to contain repetitive, airy theorizing. The most common complaint by people leaving the list is excessive activity. I have been unable to monitor the list for the last few days, so I bear

Re: Historical accuracy

2004-03-18 Thread Doug Henwood
ertugrul ahmet tonak wrote: as usual, this commentary of Mage makes so much sense to me. I guess it's especially appealing if you like clever sobriquets like Ubu, Bushits, and Dumbocrats. It's very nice that Ralph would like to repeal Taft-Hartley. Leaving aside his history of hostility to unions

Re: Teaching and Politics - reply to Carrol

2004-03-18 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
(By professional revolutionaries Lenin did NOT mean fulltime revolutionaries. He meant ordinary people who were working for a living but in what time they had for politics they trained themselves as well as possible.) I think Carrol is basically correct, but: (1) She does not distinguish

Divided over Iran

2004-03-18 Thread Marvin Gandall
The Bush administration is split on Iran policy, according to the Financial Times - specifically over whether a deal favourable to US interests can be struck with the entrenched clerical leadership. The differences echo those between the State and Defence departments leading up to the invasion of

Doug's insult

2004-03-18 Thread ertugrul ahmet tonak
Doug, How do you know I found Mage's commentary especially appealing because I liked his clever sobriquets like Ubu, Bushits, and Dumbocrats rather than, like Michael for example, the fact that Mage's reference to Taft-Hartley was an exception [in this thread] since it offered a concrete handle?

Re: Fetters on Forces of Production? was Re: RS

2004-03-18 Thread Ted Winslow
Carrol Cox wrote: My position for some years has been that in his remarks on the relations of production becoming fetters on the forces of production Marx was plain wrong. There is simply no historical justification for the claim. (The water wheel, far from giving us the industrial capitalist

Re: Historical Accuracy

2004-03-18 Thread Marvin Gandall
Shane Mage wrote: Marvin Gandall writes: ...bourgeois-dominated but worker-based parties like the Democratic party in the US... If Marvin thinks the Dumbocrats are worker-based they're most welcome to his support. I'm not speaking here of the mass of the

giving up?

2004-03-18 Thread Devine, James
[was: RE: [PEN-L] Observations on the Socialist Scholars Conference] Ian wrote: Meanwhile, there are yet other differences today's would be revolutionaries have to deal with: a soft cage of computer surveillance that grows ever more elaborate with each passing week; massive stockpiles of

Re: Doug's insult

2004-03-18 Thread Doug Henwood
ertugrul ahmet tonak wrote: How do you know I found Mage's commentary especially appealing because I liked his clever sobriquets like Ubu, Bushits, and Dumbocrats Uh, that was a joke, unlike Jurriaan accusing me of political racism, or some such, which I just let pass. rather than, like Michael

George W. Bush's back-door political machine

2004-03-18 Thread Funke Jayson J
Title: George W. Bush's back-door political machine George W. Bush's back-door political machine It's anti-democratic, anti-Constitutional, and is working to create a one-party America for Mediatransparency.org On a Tuesday evening in mid-January, a right-wing Washington writer-for-hire

Re: Fetters on Forces of Production? was Re: RS

2004-03-18 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
The fundamental cause of the present acute party crisis lies in the extremely indecisive, vacillating and dilatory policy of the centre's leading elements. Confronted with un-postponable organizational needs of the party, they try to gain time and thereby provide a cover for the policy of directly

Mike Davis on the Democratic Party

2004-03-18 Thread Louis Proyect
For my money, the best book ever written on the Democrats is by Mike Davis. Although it appeared in 1986 and examined the failure of the Mondale candidacy, many of the themes are relevant to today's situation as should be obvious from the following excerpt I scanned in. Unfortunately, nothing by

Re: Nader

2004-03-18 Thread Dan Scanlan
Louis wrote I was no Dean supporter, but at least with Dean you would have had a fight. Kerry is just too much of a centrist and a patrician to really mix it up. It seems to me that Kerry's anti-war activities in the early 70's was a safe deviation into sense, to steal from Alexander Pope.

Re: Doug's insult

2004-03-18 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Uh, that was a joke, unlike Jurriaan accusing me of political racism, or some such, which I just let pass. Here in Europe, we distinguish between passing wind and a joke. The New Zealander Bill Rosenberg, a social democrat who sometimes has interesting things to say, has sometimes posted

Re: Dollars Per Vote: Green vs. Democratic (Historical accuracy)

2004-03-18 Thread Julio Huato
Yoshie Furuhashi wrote: It costs a left-wing candidate more to run in the Democratic presidential caucuses and primaries than to run as a Green candidate in the general election. Howard Dean spent over $40 million, did not win a single primary, and got forced out on February 18, 2004 [etc.] I

Re: George W. Bush's back-door political machine

2004-03-18 Thread Bill Lear
On Thursday, March 18, 2004 at 12:29:19 (-0500) Funke Jayson J writes: ... Economists for the National Bureau of Economic Research ... (NBER) reinforce the line. They present a welter of statistics to counter Democratic calls for tax rollbacks. Newspaper editors tend to view NBER numbers as

Re: FW: election issues forum

2004-03-18 Thread Craven, Jim
so I was supposed to do some public speaking in early May ...and I get this letter: Jim, Well, the shadow of McCarthy still lingers. When your name and description was given by our sub-commitee on the Issues Forum to the overall coordinating commitee,

Re: Observations on the Socialist Scholars Conference

2004-03-18 Thread Carrol Cox
Eubulides wrote: Meanwhile, there are yet other differences today's would be revolutionaries have to deal with: The sentence above would fit the present thread more precisely if it read: Meanwhile, there are yet other differences today's progressive agitators organizers have to deal with. .

gains -- and losses -- from free trade

2004-03-18 Thread Devine, James
March 18, 2004/New York TIMES Questioning Free Trade Mathematics By JEFF MADRICK FREE trade theory has a growing number of detractors, and one of their traditional concerns has understandably moved to center stage in this presidential election year. How much has the exporting of jobs to foreign

Re: Mike Davis on the Democratic Party

2004-03-18 Thread andie nachgeborenen
This is a really excellent book, great on why the working class in this country is so divided. jks --- Louis Proyect [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: For my money, the best book ever written on the Democrats is by Mike Davis. Although it appeared in 1986 and examined the failure of the Mondale

Re: Doug's insult

2004-03-18 Thread Doug Henwood
Jurriaan Bendien wrote: Here in Europe, we distinguish between passing wind and a joke. The New Zealander Bill Rosenberg, a social democrat who sometimes has interesting things to say, has sometimes posted sheepfarting stories on PEN-L. I think the problem with your taken approach is that you end

Re: Doug's insult

2004-03-18 Thread Michael Perelman
There is no need for insults. I am asking Jurriaan to sign off immediately. On Thu, Mar 18, 2004 at 02:30:00PM -0500, Doug Henwood wrote: Jurriaan Bendien wrote: Here in Europe, we distinguish between passing wind and a joke. The New Zealander Bill Rosenberg, a social democrat who sometimes

Re: Teaching and Politics - reply to Carrol

2004-03-18 Thread Michael Hoover
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 03/18/04 10:19 AM (By professional revolutionaries Lenin did NOT mean fulltime revolutionaries. He meant ordinary people who were working for a living but in what time they had for politics they trained themselves as well as possible.) I think Carrol is basically correct,

Reply to Jim C. on marginalisation

2004-03-18 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Jim C. wrote: it is an honor to be marginalized and demonized by half-wits, sycophants and idiots and if for some reason they did like me I would worry and lose sleep what I am doing wrong - why I have not drawn the line of demarcation clear enough. With due respect, I don't look on it that way,

Re: giving up?

2004-03-18 Thread Eubulides
- Original Message - From: Devine, James [EMAIL PROTECTED] Ian replies: Hey, if you want to give up feel free! That ain't my plan. what _is_ your plan? == Given your response to the second slice of my post below, I'm going to respond in a manner consistent with

We don't grow up! We just age! (was: Doug's insult)

2004-03-18 Thread Sabri Oncu
Some years ago, when I was a 28 years old young man, I was lovers with an English professor, who was 41 years old at the time. She must be in her mid-fifties in these days. The old male professors in her department used to call me a Greek Boy, although I never understood why. They knew that I

Nasty, ridiculous behavior

2004-03-18 Thread Michael Perelman
While the list was flooded with messages from people with plans for organizing other people, nasty behavior is causing several people whom I regard very highly to leave the list. If we can't communicate with each other, how the hell do we expect to be able to carry our message to the masses. --

Re: Reply to Jim C. on marginalisation

2004-03-18 Thread Mike Ballard
--- Jurriaan Bendien [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Jim C. wrote: it is an honor to be marginalized and demonized by half-wits, sycophants and idiots and if for some reason they did like me I would worry and lose sleep what I am doing wrong - why I have not drawn the line of demarcation clear