Yoshie Furuhashi wrote:
>
> Speaking of evidence, can Ricardo offer evidence for his insinuation
> that studies that have found "for every male diagnosed as suffering
> from depression, two to six times as many females are so diagnosed"
> are inaccurate? What's his ground for thinking so? Is
For good criticism of Gilligan see also a fine book called the Mismeasure of Woman, I
forget the author, and Susan Faludi's first book. --jks
In a message dated Tue, 1 Aug 2000 5:11:07 PM Eastern Daylight Time, Yoshie Furuhashi
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
<< Ricardo wrote:
> > Maybe I was to
Rob wrote:
>G'day Carrol ( yeah, I know you don't read my posts, but that doesn't mean
>one of us can't be civil, eh?)
>
> >The disproportion in rates of clinical depression between men and women is
> >one of those facts so widely known and accepted that like the fact that
> >Lansing is the capit
Yoshie Furuhashi wrote,
> Actually, nearly all feminists -- including even Carol Gilligan --
> have written about how sexism victimizes men as well, not just women
> (if you haven't noticed the prevalence of this argument in feminism,
> you haven't read many feminists). And this feminist recogni
At 04:29 PM 08/01/2000 -0500, you wrote:
>Yoshie Furuhashi wrote:
>
> >
> > Speaking of evidence, can Ricardo offer evidence for his insinuation
> > that studies that have found "for every male diagnosed as suffering
> > from depression, two to six times as many females are so diagnosed"
> > are i
At 06:36 PM 08/01/2000 -0400, you wrote:
>For good criticism of Gilligan see also a fine book called the Mismeasure
>of Woman, I forget the author
Carol Tavris. It's a good book (though it leaves important stuff out).
Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] & http://bellarmine.lmu.edu/~JDevine
G'day Carrol ( yeah, I know you don't read my posts, but that doesn't mean
one of us can't be civil, eh?)
>The disproportion in rates of clinical depression between men and women is
>one of those facts so widely known and accepted that like the fact that
>Lansing is the capital of Michigan it doe
G'day Yoshie,
>Yes (and Carrol did so in his post),
Oh, I realise Carrol added the required reservations; I just wasn't sure
where he was going with 'em.
>>The patronising and stifling insult sustained by women here seems the pick
>>of two real stinkers ...
>
>What do you exactly refer to in th
Yoshie Furuhashi wrote:
> > sound reasons to be depressed)
This reduces the whole discussion to nonsense. The *whole* point about clinical
depression is that one is "depressed" WITHOUT any reasons, sound or otherwise,
for being depressed. (We are not dealing here with the "ultimate" causes,
w
>Yoshie Furuhashi wrote:
>
>> > sound reasons to be depressed)
>
>This reduces the whole discussion to nonsense. The *whole* point about
>clinical
>depression is that one is "depressed" WITHOUT any reasons, sound or otherwise,
>for being depressed. (We are not dealing here with the "ultimate" cau
Greetings Economists,
I will reach into Carrol's comments on depression to make a point about
rationality which leaps out at me from Carrol's comments,
Carrol,
..."Most of us, when "depressed," are unable to do sustained reading (of any
texts). I own a stationary bicycle, and while suffering
11 matches
Mail list logo
