[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-06 Terurut Topik hadingrh
kakek itu subjek dikirim kakek tuh judulnya apa ya ? saya yg goblok apa kakek yg rabun ? . hihihi some quotes: pendapat wansbrough mengenai thesis dr. john burton, the collection of the qur'an: this remarkable work is the fruit of many years' study, much discussion, and not a little

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-06 Terurut Topik hadjar_wish
Pandir. Saya ulang: Saya tidak bicara tentang tulisan Puin. Judul posting ini adalah judul lama yang tidak diubah... --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadingrh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: kakek itu subjek dikirim kakek tuh judulnya apa ya ? saya yg goblok apa kakek yg rabun ? . hihihi

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-04 Terurut Topik hadingrh
artikel tsb jelas2 berhubungan dgn puin ... sedang puin ternyata diluar dugaannya jusfiq .. karena dia bilang sendiri yg kemudian dimuat di Atlantic Monthly: The important thing, thank God, is that these Yemeni Qur'anic fragments do not differ from those found in museums and libraries elsewhere,

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-04 Terurut Topik hadingrh
wah ketahuan si celeng ini gak bisa baca tulisan bhs inggris yg gw kirim .. apa perlu digambar supaya bisa dibaca lebih jelas ? --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hartono_tjahjadi [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ada kutipan laen gak blok? jangan marah blok, keteteran ya? 2007/5/3, hadingrh [EMAIL

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-04 Terurut Topik hadjar_wish
Jadi, tidak sama. Artinya Allah fiktif yang di al-Musahf itu tidak menepati janjinya. --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadingrh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: artikel tsb jelas2 berhubungan dgn puin ... sedang puin ternyata diluar dugaannya jusfiq .. karena dia bilang sendiri yg kemudian dimuat

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-04 Terurut Topik hadjar_wish
Ni orang udah kewalahan. Saya tidak bicara tentang tulisan Puin. Dan tulisan Puin dibawah ini tetap mengatakan ada perbedaan antara fragmen al-Mushaf Yemen itu dengan al-Mushaf yang lain. Dibalik itu ada beda antara al-Mushaf versi Kairo dan al-Mushaf versi Magrib. --- In

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-03 Terurut Topik hadingrh
--- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadjar_wish [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadingrh hadingrh@ wrote: So much for the controversy over the Sana fragments. It was actualy Toby Lester who was the one that tried to inflate this whole issue into something it

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-03 Terurut Topik hadingrh
sudah gw bilang tempat lu gak cocok di sini, mending lu sering2 consult ke psikiater atau ahli otak kalo perlu minta diamputasi atau diganti sama usus celeng ... Robert Hoyland : the historical memory of the Muslim community is more robust than some have claimed. John Burton: What we have

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-03 Terurut Topik hadjar_wish
--- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadingrh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadjar_wish hadjar@ wrote: --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadingrh hadingrh@ wrote: So much for the controversy over the Sana fragments. It was actualy Toby Lester who was the one

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-03 Terurut Topik hadingrh
maksud lu yg dibilang puin: The important thing, thank God, is that these Yemeni Qur'anic fragments do not differ from those found in museums and libraries elsewhere, with the exception of details that do not touch the Qur'an itself, but are rather differences in the way words are spelled. This

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-03 Terurut Topik hadjar_wish
Ni orang udah kewalahan. Saya tidak bicara tentang tulisan Puin. Dan tulisan Puin dibawah ini tetap mengatakan ada perbedaan antara fragmen al-Mushaf Yemen itu dengan al-Mushaf yang lain. Dibalik itu ada beda antara al-Mushaf versi Kairo dan al-Mushaf versi Magrib. --- In

Re: [proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-03 Terurut Topik hartono_tjahjadi
ada kutipan laen gak blok? jangan marah blok, keteteran ya? 2007/5/3, hadingrh [EMAIL PROTECTED]: sudah gw bilang tempat lu gak cocok di sini, mending lu sering2 consult ke psikiater atau ahli otak kalo perlu minta diamputasi atau diganti sama usus celeng ... Robert Hoyland : the

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-02 Terurut Topik hadingrh
So much for the controversy over the Sana fragments. It was actualy Toby Lester who was the one that tried to inflate this whole issue into something it wasn't, and Dr Puin himself has denied all the findings Lester ascribes to him, apart from the spelling differences. The media and western

[proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-02 Terurut Topik hadjar_wish
--- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, hadingrh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So much for the controversy over the Sana fragments. It was actualy Toby Lester who was the one that tried to inflate this whole issue into something it wasn't, and Dr Puin himself has denied all the findings Lester ascribes

Re: [proletar] Re: Reposting: PUIN: My position concerning my work on Yemeni Koran fragments

2007-05-02 Terurut Topik hartono_tjahjadi
buktinya mana blok? hapalan turun temurun dari abad 8 blok?? yemen th 1972 ya blok? 2007/5/2, hadingrh [EMAIL PROTECTED]: So much for the controversy over the Sana fragments. It was actualy Toby Lester who was the one that tried to inflate this whole issue into something it wasn't, and Dr