Re: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-13 Thread Jon Frost \(iCounty Software\)
((NIH/NIDA)) [E]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Eric Neumann" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "public-semweb-lifesci hcls" Sent: Friday, August 11, 2006 3:46 PM Subject: RE: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions) Wikipedia has clearly been working in the

Re: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-13 Thread Matthew Cockerill
On 11 Aug 2006, at 21:46, Booth, David (HP Software - Boston) wrote: [snip] (For example, one probably would not use a wikipedia URL as a concept identifier in a Semantic Web application, because the definition of a term can change as fast as a user can type in a browser.) [snip] Actuall

RE: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-11 Thread Booth, David (HP Software - Boston)
y, August 10, 2006 5:06 PM > To: 'June Kinoshita'; 'Joanne Luciano' > Cc: 'Jeremy Zucker'; 'Skinner, Karen ((NIH/NIDA)) [E]'; 'Eric > Neumann'; 'public-semweb-lifesci hcls' > Subject: RE: Size estimates of current LS space (a

RE: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-10 Thread Nigam Shah
Hi June, Thanks for the detailed response. One follow up comment (not for you) below: > Could the scientific community perform this > vetting and editing function itself, a la wikipedia? We have > found that in general, this does not work. Many scientists > refuse to correct or criticize colleag

Re: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-10 Thread June Kinoshita
These are issues that the SWAN/Alzforum project team has been thinking about for a number of years and that have informed our approach to designing SWAN. We believe that in order for community curation to succeed, the user community (in our case, neurodegenerative disease researchers) hav

Re: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-04 Thread Robert Stevens
I think there are two issues in a suspicion of distributed curation: 1. Wanting curation to be good before publication, rather than "it will become good eventually with enough people looking at it". 2. The perceived need to control what appears as the community view. Feedback from the comunity

Re: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-04 Thread Joanne Luciano
I would like to get some feedback on the feasibility of distributed curation. Me too! PIs who have years of experience in managing curation projects are not that enthusiastic about its role. It seems the CS community is all for it but the actual *users* havent really bought in. Are there a

Re: Size estimates of current LS space

2006-08-03 Thread Eric Jain
Eric Neumann wrote: As per today's Telcon, does any person with genomics knowledge (that includes you too Carole) have estimates for the following numbers: 1. How many bio-molecular and organism-anatomical-functional entities and records (broad sense) are currently accessible through the web

RE: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-03 Thread Nigam Shah
Hi Jeremy, Please see inline comments below.. > The semantic web interests me for several reasons. For one, I > believe it will be a solid substrate for distributed curation, > which is a necessary part of the ongoing effort to improve the > quality of the biological data we use. > Like wikiped

Re: Size estimates of current LS space (and Introductions)

2006-08-02 Thread Jeremy Zucker
Hello folks, It appears that I forgot to put the URL in that last email about the pathguide: http://www.pathguide.org Well, since I've already managed to embarrass myself publicly, I figure I might as well introduce myself formally. My name is Jeremy Zucker, and I am a bioinformatics s

Re: Size estimates of current LS space

2006-08-01 Thread Jeremy Zucker
Hi folks, One resource that is likely to be of use in the pathway space is the pathguide: It has detailed statistics about the size of each database and other metadata for about 222 biological pathway databases. This is the target space for conversion to BioPAX. Sincerely, Jeremy On

RE: Size estimates of current LS space

2006-07-31 Thread Skinner, Karen \(NIH/NIDA\) [E]
These may be helpful resources: The Nucleic Acids Research Public Links Directory See: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?db=pubmed&cmd=Retrieve&dop t=AbstractPlus&list_uids=16845014&query_hl=6&itool=pubmed_docsum And the Nucleic Acids 2006 Molecular Biology Database Collection ht

Re: Size estimates of current LS space

2006-07-31 Thread Carole Goble
Eric strewth. hmmnot sure, and on the grounds you should ask people who know if you don't know, I just emailed Rolf Apweiler, Ewan Birney and Arek Kasprzyk to see if they would hazard a guess for at least the public databases. I'll also ask our local proteomics and microarray people abo