Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Zoraster
I'm healing from Surgery. My bike rides are now limited to coffee shops and dining with the wife. My ride is no longer my comfy long distance tours (until next year). So for the comfy daily ride I switched to a nice Celeste Bianchi Milanno that fits perfect for these rides. Then I dreamed of the

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Matthew J
> I think (from what the marketing looks like at least) that they are trying to penetrate the market that sees Brooks saddles as > "precious." Which never made sense to me. A little proofide once a year and the things will last fifty years easy. > All are only partly right but are myths t

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Peter Morgano
I think (from what the marketing looks like at least) that they are trying to penetrate the market that sees Brooks saddles as "precious." There are a lot of people that think you cant get them wet, they need constant maintenance and take 3 years to get comfortable. All are only partly right but a

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Matthew J
A comment meant as nothing more than a dramatic attempt to demonstrate why many people are in fact willing to pay a premium for a non-leather hammock saddle. In hindsight I should have used one of those evil winky faces with those terms to make clear I had no intent to poke anyone in the eye.

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Joe Bernard
*I will point out that several people reading the list reached out to me off line saying they would be very happy to use a quality hammock saddle made without leather.* I will point out that nobody was arguing against the idea. You're the one who brought up "dead animals" in a thread about th

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Matthew J
You are misreading my original post on the topic if you think I am arguing that all shell saddles are uncomfortable. Rather, I said that Cambium gives hope to those of us who find shell saddles uncomfortable and prefer not to buy leather products. I will point out that several people reading

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Patrick Moore
No one will deny you your preferences, for Brooks type saddles or for vegetarian eating. No one will deny that plastic saddles hurt you and wear out quickly for you. One will and must deny your reasoning that, because it is is so for you, it is so universally in the absence of any further presente

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-19 Thread Matthew J
> Not sure about a "stain factor," but one tester on one of the forums > said the rough textured surface destroyed a pair of bib shorts. All the more reason to support sales of the Cambium if it gets some of the many who should not be wearing bibs in public out of them and into comfortable loo

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 16:07 -0700, Chris Halasz wrote: > I'm wondering what the pant stain factor of the Cambium may be. > > Some of my Brooks saddles have been OK this way, some less so. > > Also wondering about the breathability or thermal experience in warm weather. > > And shellacking of

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Robert F. Harrison
:-) Given that there are about 200 in the wild right now it's a long shot, at least on this list. As far as I know I'm the only one on RBW-owners-bunch who owns one. Aloha, Bob On Tue, Jun 18, 2013 at 2:15 PM, Jimmy Hutch wrote: > WTB: Brooks Cambium C17 > > -Jimmy > > -- > You received this m

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Jimmy Hutch
WTB: Brooks Cambium C17 -Jimmy -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to rbw-owners-bunch+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To post to this group, send e

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Robert F. Harrison
On Tue, Jun 18, 2013 at 1:07 PM, Chris Halasz wrote: > I'm wondering what the pant stain factor of the Cambium may be. > Also wondering about the breathability or thermal experience in warm > weather. > I've got the natural color model and as one might expect, haven't stained my pants. The wo

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Chris Halasz
I'm wondering what the pant stain factor of the Cambium may be. Some of my Brooks saddles have been OK this way, some less so. Also wondering about the breathability or thermal experience in warm weather. And shellacking of the cotton weave will not be allowed! Chris Tucson, AZ -- You rec

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Matthew Joly
Exactly what proof would you need. To watch me and hundreds of other hammock saddle fans squirm while riding plastic saddles. I've tried dozens of models over the years. For a while I thought the Fizik Ronin [sp?] was going to be the one. The padding wore down in less than a month. Surface

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread William R.
This is funny. Last year, right about this time, it was when Rapha had just introduced their new shoes made out of Yak leather. I was peacefully riding my B17'ed Sam when approached from behind by a large group of fast/racer types. As the group sped by me, a guy on a Colnago yelled for everyone

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Patrick Moore
I'm going to have a nice steak tonight. If there is one thing that annoys, it is badly reasoned yet still pompous self righteousness. Don't eat animal products if you don't like to. Good Hindus don't, and good Orthodox monks don't, either. They have good reasons, but they don't assume a pose of p

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Patrick Moore
??? 25K miles at least? Hardly short. Uncomfortable? Proof? Again 25 k miles over the years? My first Flite from circa 1990 that has been on half a dozen bikes with 7 k on the last one? Not to mention all the other Flites I've put thousands of miles on? And this is just one particular model of plas

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Doug Williams
How sad that this is getting so off topic right when the “off topic” veers into territory that I (possessing both philosophy and political science degrees) am qualified to comment on. J The vegan choice is a moral choice; often motivated by religion (of course, religion and morals often int

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Deacon Patrick
Food isn't vegan, actually. All the woodland creatures displaced and slaughtered in the plowing and maintenance of those grain fields. Short of growing all my own food using only hand tools very slowly, I can't figure out how I could eat a truly vegan diet. And it is absolutely a moral judgemen

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Peter Morgano
a snickers bar isn't vegansorry couldn't resist. On Tue, Jun 18, 2013 at 12:40 PM, Scott Henry wrote: > Gentlemen, take your panties, pull them out and untwist them. > > Not sure how a persons dietary choices are thought of as political. > Barry, nor George, could care less what you eat. >

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Scott Henry
Gentlemen, take your panties, pull them out and untwist them. Not sure how a persons dietary choices are thought of as political. Barry, nor George, could care less what you eat. Go step away from the computer and have a Snicker's bar, some of you get cranky when you are hungry. Its a seat, you

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread JL
I was just thinking that I hope Riv gets a few of these saddles in stock. They have been supportive of Brooks as a brand and cyclists who want alternatives to leather products in the past so it seems plausible. I don't need a new saddle but I am curious how this compares to my Brooks. FWIW

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Joe Bernard
The thread was started by a person actually using the saddle, which is where discussions of comfort come in. You are injecting politics into it, then pretending you're not. I'm quite well versed in the tactics of political debate on the internet, and know the semantics game. I'm done with this.

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 10:56 -0500, Matthew Joly wrote: > Arguing comfort or lack thereof of something one has never used is not > disingenuous? Isn't that exactly what you are doing? I say again, the world is full of platic saddles. Most cyclists find them comfortable. If you haven't found on

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread cyclotourist
Because it's fun to watch the histrionics: http://www.rivbike.com/product-p/bavsss.htm Cheers, David On Tue, Jun 18, 2013 at 9:02 AM, Joe Bernard wrote: > The thread was started by a person actually using the saddle, which is > where discussions of comfort come in. You are injecting politics

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Matthew Joly
Arguing comfort or lack thereof of something one has never used is not disingenuous? Your argument is the lack of leather should lower the market value of the product. My response is to show there is in fact a significant market that values the lack of leather. Zappos, to name one large com

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Joe Bernard
*There are a growing number of prosperous vegans in the UK, US, EU, and of course India, who like nice things without dead animals in them. The majority is not yet enlightened, but we are growing and we are very willing to spend our money on products that don't need to kill an animal to make.*

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Matthew J
Apparently you have not been following the earlier discussions on the Cambium. Yes, mainstream saddles are frequently plastic. I and others interested in leather free alternatives to quality Brooks and Berthoud saddles have said and this and other bicycle forums that the plastic saddles all t

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 06:34 -0700, Matthew J wrote: > Actually not politics at all. I disagree. When I read about veganism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veganism it's all politics. Using the word is invoking politics. Why "Vegan" for this saddle, and not any of the many, many plastic saddles on

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Matthew J
Made in the UK AFAIK. On Monday, June 17, 2013 9:16:48 PM UTC-5, Peter M wrote: > > I worked in a Vegan restaurant for a long time (a lot of fixed gear bikes) > and the owner made it a point not to make the non-vegans feel like they > were baby killing satan worshippers. I would imagine the smar

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Matthew J
Actually not politics at all. The nternet combined with inexpensive global shipping is changing the world of commerce. Companies that know how to take advantage of both make money products targetting global niche markets. Vegan products make up a growing, multi-million market. Brooks is joi

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-18 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2013-06-17 at 22:24 -0400, Peter Morgano wrote: > Its too narrow for my fat ass. If they make a wide one in a year or > two I will give it a look. Should come in somewhat cheaper than the > standard offerings considering its made of rubber and cotton. Yes, exactly like this. > > > On M

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Peter Morgano
Its too narrow for my fat ass. If they make a wide one in a year or two I will give it a look. Should come in somewhat cheaper than the standard offerings considering its made of rubber and cotton. On Mon, Jun 17, 2013 at 10:22 PM, Steve Palincsar wrote: > Wouldn't it be nice to discuss this sa

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Steve Palincsar
Wouldn't it be nice to discuss this saddle on the basis of its merits rather than all this /politics/? -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to rbw-

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Peter Morgano
I worked in a Vegan restaurant for a long time (a lot of fixed gear bikes) and the owner made it a point not to make the non-vegans feel like they were baby killing satan worshippers. I would imagine the smart people at Brooks would do the same and not market this as a "this saddle will make you sl

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Joe Bernard
Yes, you've gone out of your way to impress upon me your vegan ways, and the error of mine. I'm not interested in the politics of leather Brooks saddles, but thanks for playing. On Monday, June 17, 2013 6:27:33 PM UTC-7, Matthew J wrote: > There are a growing number of prosperous vegans in the

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Matthew J
There are a growing number of prosperous vegans in the UK, US, EU, and of course India, who like nice things without dead animals in them. The majority is not yet enlightened, but we are growing and we are very willing to spend our money on products that don't need to kill an animal to make. A

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Joe Bernard
Hmm, good point. Although calling 1000 non-leather Brooks saddles "limited" is pushing the concept, in my opinion. I'm not at all convinced there's much of a market for one. Joe "I've been wrong before" Bernard Vallejo, CA. On Monday, June 17, 2013 5:56:28 PM UTC-7, Statrixbob wrote: > Actual

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Robert F. Harrison
Actually my reading of the letter is that their first production run is going to be a limited edition at 145 quid. These will all be numbered. I would suspect that sales after the limited edition will be less expensive. "Now, on Monday 17th June, a specially dedicated website for the new Cambium S

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Joe Bernard
Hmm. I assumed this would be an attempt to make a Brooks saddle more accessible to the masses, both in construction and price. I don't think the market is hollering for a Brooks just as pricey as the leather ones, but without the leather. An odd decision, in my opinion. Joe Bernard Vallejo, CA

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-17 Thread Ron Mc
New Brooks mail today - 145 quid for this saddle. that's the same price as a Select Grade B17, etc. Looks like the wrong end of the market to me. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop re

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-11 Thread Tim Gavin
Robert- I'm a new Riv owner ('97 Road) and will be riding Thurs, Fri, and Sat of my first RAGBRAI this year. Tim On Tue, Jun 11, 2013 at 1:25 AM, Joe Bernard wrote: > Thanks, I found that and a couple others with that newfangled Googley > thing you kids talk so much about. I've always like th

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-10 Thread Joe Bernard
Thanks, I found that and a couple others with that newfangled Googley thing you kids talk so much about. I've always like those little foldy/take-apart bikes, but never bothered to look for a forum before. On Monday, June 10, 2013 9:17:49 PM UTC-7, Statrixbob wrote: > No, there is only the RBW

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-10 Thread Robert F. Harrison
No, there is only the RBW owners bunch list. But if another list existed and if it were about Bike Fridays more information would be available here : http://mx.bikefriday.com/mailman/listinfo/yak Aloha, Bob On Jun 10, 2013 6:07 PM, "Joe Bernard" wrote: > There's a Bike Friday list? > > On Mo

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-10 Thread Joe Bernard
There's a Bike Friday list? On Monday, June 10, 2013 8:06:38 PM UTC-7, Statrixbob wrote: > I've now moved the C-17 over to my Quickbeam. After the demise of my > Hunq's rear wheel it seemed to be the right move. I put in about 12 miles > so far today and, once again, the saddle was good. And as

Re: [RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-10 Thread Robert F. Harrison
I've now moved the C-17 over to my Quickbeam. After the demise of my Hunq's rear wheel it seemed to be the right move. I put in about 12 miles so far today and, once again, the saddle was good. And as I'd moved the entire seat post I didn't really have to spend any time get the angle right. http:/

[RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-10 Thread Zoraster
I'm setting up two bikes for easy rides this month. A bit of rest this year and simple rides to local shops with the wife. The Touring bike has to wait for next year. The new Brooks Saddle looks made for the bikes I'm building! Finally Getting my wife to enjoy rides with me! My Brooks love conti

[RBW] Brooks Cambium C-17 First Look

2013-06-06 Thread Robert F. Harrison
I was chosen as one of the first 100 folks to receive a Brooks Cambium C-17 saddle. Mine just arrived today and while I haven't yet mounted it on a bike (probably my daily ride, the Hunq), I did take some pictures to "prove it happened." http://www.flickr.com/photos/mgps-bob/sets/72157633977211833