[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-24 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
If you aren't averse to chemical burns, lye might be fun. On Jun 24, 6:30 pm, Robert Linthicum wrote: > Google is my friend:  The Kalloy Uno seatpost is ALUMINUM.  I just put > ammonia on our shopping list! --~--~-~--~~~---~--~~ You received this message because y

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-24 Thread Robert Linthicum
Google is my friend: The Kalloy Uno seatpost is ALUMINUM. I just put ammonia on our shopping list! --~--~-~--~~~---~--~~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-o

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-24 Thread Robert Linthicum
Priceless advice, thank you. I am going to try each recommendation, methodically. The seatpost is a Kalloy Uno, and the frame is (probably) Reynolds steel tubing, so I think that is a chrome finish on steel. If that's so, ammonia will is probably contraindicated, but I will try that, too, if all

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-24 Thread Jude
I had the same problem with an aluminum post stuck in a steel Bianchi Volpe frame. I tried all matter of twisting, tapping, penetrating, etc. I finally pulled the bottom bracket and turned the bike upside down. Ran about 2 or 3 cups of ammonia down the seat tube and let it sit overnight, did th

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-24 Thread Ken Yokanovich
Another vote for soaking with liquid penetrant. You should consider removing the water bottle screws from the seat tube and using them as a way to add penetrant from the bottom of the bike. If your Trek does not have water bottle mounts on the seat tube, you could remove the bottom bracket and a

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-24 Thread Robert Linthicum
Thanks very much for the suggestions. I particularly like the advice to wait a while & let the penetrant do its thing, because that is what I'm doing now. I have the bike in my living room to remind myself to drip a little more liquid wrench in every day, and to give the seatpost a daily nudge o

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-23 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
I'm with Bill C. Let it soak in a few applications of penetrating oil for a few days or a few weeks. It would probably be foolish to destroy the seatpost, since it's at the correct height. On Jun 23, 5:23 am, Bob wrote: > My daily rider, a vintage steel Trek, is now afflicted. This is > embarra

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-23 Thread Bill Connell
On Tue, Jun 23, 2009 at 5:23 AM, Bob wrote: > > My daily rider, a vintage steel Trek, is now afflicted. This is > embarrassing, because I remember pulling the post about two years ago > and slathering it with Phil Wood grease and Park Anti-Seize.  Oh well. > > Thus far, I have tried removing the s

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-23 Thread Bill M.
It won't help now, but one thing you DON"T want to do is mix greases, like using both Phil and anti-seize. Grease is basically oil plus a thickener, and many of the different thickeners used are chemically incompatible with each other. They may react and either lose their thickening power and ge

[RBW] Re: Fun with a Stuck Seatpost

2009-06-23 Thread Steve
I have occasionally experienced this too. Eventually it will release. The ultimate fix is to cut the top of the post off just above the end of the seat tube, then use a hacksaw blade down inside the post to cut a slot. This always works. Just be careful you don't cut into the seat tube: gentle