[scots-l] James OSwald and Crail,

2003-07-15 Thread Philip Whittaker
Hi folks, I know that simeone on thw list has already mentioned this! I am one of the folk on the list who reckon that James Oswald is one of the great unknown Scots. As has already been mentioned on the list he was born in Crail in the East Neuk of Fife ( Good name for a tune. In fact it is

Re: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriuosly)

2003-07-15 Thread Matt Seattle
Toby Rider wrote: That stuff is rubbish, just like top 40 music of every other genre nowadays.. Sad.. Craig David's pretty good, no? Posted to Scots-L - The Traditional Scottish Music Culture List - To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

RE: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Jim Dawson
Toby Rider wrote: That stuff is rubbish, just like top 40 music of every other genre nowadays.. Sad.. Matt Seattle wrote: Craig David's pretty good, no? Exactly.I find it sad and narrow minded that people can rubbish music like this. In fact I do not see any real information regarding

RE: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Jack Campin
Jim Dawson wrote: In fact I do not see any real information regarding modes coming out in this discussion, plenty of show boating about how much music history they know and nothing about how to use modes in real life music. I presume you mean me. I'd already put a fair bit of such

RE: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Jim Dawson
Jack Campin wrote: I presume you mean me. No Jack I was not referring to you, I was simply venting at people being dismissive of certain genres of music without having anything of worth to add to the discussion or even thinking about the reality that some people do like such music (and I am not

[scots-l] Re: Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Nigel Gatherer
Jim Dawson wrote: ...I do not see any real information regarding modes coming out in this discussion, plenty of show boating about how much music history they know and nothing about how to use modes in real life music. In my humble opinion, you do not need to know anything about modes in

[scots-l] Looking for a Venue in Edinburgh

2003-07-15 Thread Nigel Gatherer
I'm helping to organise a small concert in Edinburgh in October. The duet appearing are an acoustic duo, mandolin and guitar, and I expect there will be an audience of between 25 and 50. They particularly like performing in a church-type environment because of the acoustics. Can anyone think of a

Re: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Toby Rider
Jack Campin wrote: I presume you mean me. No Jack I was not referring to you, I was simply venting at people being dismissive of certain genres of music without having anything of worth to add to the discussion or even thinking about the reality that some people do like such music (and I am

Re: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Matt Seattle
Perhaps it's got a bit out of hand, very hot weather here in the Borders at the moment at any rate. Most genres have their 'quality' artistes, and in mentioning Craig David I was referring to top 40 generally, not of course 'country' music. As for understanding modes (etc. etc.) I don't think it

[scots-l] Re: Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Nigel Gatherer
Toby Rider wrote: ...Obviously there are some genuine talents sandwiched between the Christina Aguilera [Snip] I thought her last single was good. The one where she has a terrible wind problem in a phone booth. And in another recent song (Dirty) she wore a lovely kilt, although I couldn't

Re: [scots-l] Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Bruce Olson
Matt Seattle wrote: .. Rambling further.. PW mentions Owsald. There's been a bit of a renaissance and reappraisal of JO recently, with some CDs on the 'serious' end of the market. What I've heard sounds pleasant but lightweight to me, but might not be the best stuff(?). Oswald was

Re: [scots-l] Oswald

2003-07-15 Thread Matt Seattle
Bruce Olson wrote: ... That's all that come to the top of my mind at present, but I'm sure others can add more to this short list. That's plenty indeed. What interests me particularly about Oswald is where he's reworked traditional variation sets, or come up with his own variations

Re: [scots-l] Looking for a Venue in Edinburgh

2003-07-15 Thread Jack Campin
I'm helping to organise a small concert in Edinburgh in October. The duet appearing are an acoustic duo, mandolin and guitar, and I expect there will be an audience of between 25 and 50. They particularly like performing in a church-type environment because of the acoustics. Can anyone think

[scots-l] Oswald miscellany

2003-07-15 Thread Jack Campin
Composite followup to three messages. [Oswald] : I see in the Scotman that there is a music festival soon in Crail. An : obvious opportunity for an ensemble specialising in the music of one : of the Scottish masters of the baroque and traditional styles. I wonder : whether the organisers even

Re: [scots-l] Re: Modal Tunes (but seriously)

2003-07-15 Thread Toby Rider
Nigel Gatherer wrote: Toby Rider wrote: ...Obviously there are some genuine talents sandwiched between the Christina Aguilera [Snip] I thought her last single was good. The one where she has a terrible wind problem in a phone booth. And in another recent song (Dirty) she wore a lovely kilt,