RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-19 Thread tom barnett
Paul Yes -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Paul Sent: Tuesday, September 18, 2007 10:05 PM To: ShopTalk@mail.msen.com Subject: Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture Hi Tom, Mine does not have a hole, but it does have a notch behind

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-18 Thread Paul
helps. Tom -Original Message- *From:* [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] *On Behalf Of *Paul *Sent:* Monday, September 17, 2007 7:18 PM *To:* ShopTalk@mail.msen.com *Subject:* Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture Hi Tom, This sounds very interesting but I am having

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-18 Thread Alan Brooks
I have been hitting my clubs with a butt weight sufficient to match the weight of all of my clubs for over two years. That means a butt weight around 100-g in my driver. My clubs are MOI matched and have graphite shafts in all of them. I keep a non-weighted driver around for periodic baselin

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-18 Thread tom barnett
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Paul Sent: Monday, September 17, 2007 7:18 PM To: ShopTalk@mail.msen.com Subject: Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture Hi Tom, This sounds very interesting but I am having trouble visualizing it. I have a golfsmith

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-18 Thread Dave Tutelman
At 06:34 AM 9/18/2007, André Cantin wrote: It seems to me that that the human factor will skew the results. This should be no cause for surprise. If you do either robot testing or computer simulation, counterweighting (or differing grip weights) make no measurable difference in perform

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-18 Thread André Cantin
Dave T. It seems to me that that the human factor will skew the results. A. For some recent test results, see http://www.hirekogolf.com//hireko/webpages/tech_articles/system_q2_experiment/system_q2_experiment.htmlHope this helps, DaveT

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread TOM FLANAGAN
I sure don't disagree with Dr Tutelman. I think we're more in concert than not in this case. I mentioned the butt end only as a last resort. I don't nor did it recommend it. What I hoped to demonstrate was that no matter what one does re; swingweight, a change of a point of so is essentially mean

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Paul
Golfsmith, it was less than one swing step. I hope this helps. Tom -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] On Behalf Of Don M Sent: Sunday, September 16, 2007 4:50 PM To: ShopTalk@mail.msen.com Subject: Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture Bob, I have seen a

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Dave Tutelman
Ed and I are in agreement here, specifically... At 05:58 PM 9/17/2007, Ed Reeder wrote: ... in all honesty, I DON'T do what I described in the long "how to" post I just sent. I'll sort the shafts based upon deflection/weight, but then I just tip according to the desired deflection I want usin

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Ed Reeder
TFlan, Is 100% correct about the lie angle adjustments. I left that out of what I posted to make things simpler. If you are really anal, do some preliminary lie adjustments on your heads before assembly. Also, in all honesty, I DON'T do what I described in the long "how to" post I just sent

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Ed Reeder
Bob, First, here are some SW formulas/rules of thumb that may be of value to you: Grams needed to change 1 SW point Formula (varies by the length of the club): grams = 49.61 / (length – 14) For example, a 37" club will need a 2g (2.16g) weight difference to change the SW 1 point 2.16 = 49.61 /

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Dave Tutelman
Bob, I think your numbers are in the right direction, but want some reassurance on their actual values. Let's do some sanity checks on them. At 01:50 PM 9/17/2007, Bob Barrette wrote: I tried your wire suggestion and it worked great! Here are the results I came up with. (A)When I place th

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Dave Tutelman
At 01:21 PM 9/17/2007, TOM FLANAGAN wrote: So I'd say the final place to adjust SW isn't at the head. But working at the butt end . . . the grip, will allow for some small changes in ending SW. Formula? I guess you'd have to ask Dr. T... I'm on record for well over a decade as disagreeing wit

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread tom barnett
Bob Pretty much what I am getting 2.3-3.0 s.w. per ½ inch. Tom -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Bob Barrette Sent: Monday, September 17, 2007 12:50 PM To: ShopTalk@mail.msen.com Subject: RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Bob Barrette
Hi Tom: I tried your wire suggestion and it worked great! Here are the results I came up with. (A)When I place the shaft above the cradle and under the wire , I get 3 S/W less than when I place it in the cradle.( D2 vs. C9 ) (B)For every 1/2 inch I extend the shaft beyond the

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread TOM FLANAGAN
I doubt I have the answer but consider the identifiable factors; Head weight Shaft Weight Shaft length Spine location Grip weight - plus tape and/or adhesive to install. We all know that SW changes approx 3 points per 1/2 inch lenght. We know that one SW point equals about 2 grams. We know that

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Bob Barrette
Thanks Tom: I did the same thing, only I taped the shaft to the fixture. I like your wire idea much better, easier and faster! Now to create a formula, to determine the change in S/W (+ or -), for each inch past the cradle. Regards, Bob - Building a

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread John Hyde
Dear Bob: Give me a call to explain how to do this. Too many words to type. 317-255-3533. John Hyde From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Bob Barrette Sent: Sunday, September 16, 2007 10:30 AM To: shop talk shop Subject: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Bob Barrette
Hi Colin: I didn't make myself clear enough. I do exactly what you are saying, I make sure that the heads are properly weighted, (7 gram progression).That will insure a very constant S/W through the set. Let us assume that they come out at C8 Say I have a customer that wants a D3 S/W throughout t

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Colin Dick
Hi Bob, I have always checked and adjusted head weights before frequency matching. This works well for me. I can get a fair approximation by taking a head/shaft SW, then measuring it at 1/2" longer, and if appropriate, by adding a few grams to the head. Colin Colin Dick- GCA Accredited Pr

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-17 Thread Don M
As I recall the deal, the goat shaft has to be one of the same that you are using to build the set. -Don M --- Bob Barrette <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Don: > I wonder if you were to use a sacrifice "goat" shaft > of say 95 grams, then you made a set with a 75 gram > shaft, would the informatio

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-16 Thread Bob Barrette
Don: I wonder if you were to use a sacrifice "goat" shaft of say 95 grams, then you made a set with a 75 gram shaft, would the information gleaned from the "goat" shaft be different at 75 grams? And if so, you would have to create a formula that would compensate for gram weight changes? Regards

RE: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-16 Thread tom barnett
To: ShopTalk@mail.msen.com Subject: Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture Bob, I have seen a write-up of a person who drilled a hole such as you are comtemplating. Using a pre-tested club as a constant, he weighted the back end of the scale with lead tape to re-zero it. I have often wished to do

Re: ShopTalk: Swing Weight fixture

2007-09-16 Thread Don M
Bob, I have seen a write-up of a person who drilled a hole such as you are comtemplating. Using a pre-tested club as a constant, he weighted the back end of the scale with lead tape to re-zero it. I have often wished to do the same thing. The other way is to sacrifice a "goat" shaft, I believe.