I just don't understand this hate.
I had said before, and I would like to say it again : "The bigger
picture is that India is doing a lot better than Pakistan. It is on
course to continue to do even better. And this is because whereas India
has painstakingly built up a reasonably efficient market e
On Friday 22 Jul 2011 10:28:42 am M.K.Pai wrote:
> The Pakistani "establishment" has been unanimous that it was a rogue
> operation. Of course, if you can point me to contrary evidence, I
> shall stand corrected.
>
There is no "evidence" either way available to me. It's what one wants to
believ
Hello,
I agree that its misguided to conflate India's domestic problems,
however grave, with India's foreign policy alternatives.
On Thu, Jul 21, 2011 at 7:01 PM, ss wrote:
> On Wednesday 20 Jul 2011 5:47:18 pm M.K.Pai wrote:
>> The point I was trying to make was that it does not matter what the
On Wednesday 20 Jul 2011 5:47:18 pm M.K.Pai wrote:
> The point I was trying to make was that it does not matter what the
> Pakistanis say. What they do, matters. What we do, matters.
>
While I have no disagreement with your statements, I think that in the post
9-11 situation. the Pakistan army h
On Wednesday 20 Jul 2011 9:22:50 am Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:
> should I prescribe you stronger
> eyeglasses so you can go back and read what I wrote correctly?
>
Did I manage to get you angry enough to start trying to detect physical
defects in me? If I did it means I had exactly the effec
On Wednesday 20 Jul 2011 6:43:50 pm Bharath Chari wrote:
> However, I can't understand the reasoning that hate politics within a
> country is less abhorrent or different to cross border ones. If that
> wasn't your submission, then I stand corrected.
>
Bharat it is your prerogative to hold the v
On 07/20/2011 09:22 AM, Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:
The brown chaddi types hate muslims in general
The pakistanis hate indians in particular
what is the difference at all? and should I prescribe you stronger
eyeglasses so you can go back and read what I wrote correctly?
On Wednesday 20 July
Hello,
The point I was trying to make was that it does not matter what the
Pakistanis say. What they do, matters. What we do, matters.
Would we like the Pakistani army to take a few casualties ? Sure. When
we did not move troops to our western border after 26/11, we allowed
the US to pressurize t
The brown chaddi types hate muslims in general
The pakistanis hate indians in particular
what is the difference at all? and should I prescribe you stronger
eyeglasses so you can go back and read what I wrote correctly?
On Wednesday 20 July 2011 09:20 AM, ss wrote:
> On Wednesday 20 Jul 2011 5:20
On Wednesday 20 Jul 2011 5:20:49 am Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:
> Let us just assume I don't choose to carry my argument on further
Your choice is sacrosanct, as is mine.
Let me get this right. You think that the bjp/rss follow "hate Pakistan"
politics and not "hate Muslims". For that reason y
As is your line of circular reasoning
Let us just assume I don't choose to carry my argument on further
--Original Message--
From: ss
Sender: silklist-bounces+suresh=hserus@lists.hserus.net
To: silklist@lists.hserus.net
ReplyTo: silklist@lists.hserus.net
Subject: Re: [silk] W
On Tuesday 19 Jul 2011 8:11:46 am Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:
> The sangh parivar is making the same sort of circular reasoning you make
> when you say "muslims do x" vs "pakistanis do x".
>
> The difference is about circular arguments on silklist versus burning
> houses and killing people.
>
The sangh parivar is making the same sort of circular reasoning you make
when you say "muslims do x" vs "pakistanis do x".
The difference is about circular arguments on silklist versus burning
houses and killing people.
ss [19/07/11 07:33 +0530]:
On Tuesday 19 Jul 2011 7:22:47 am Suresh Ramasub
On Tuesday 19 Jul 2011 7:22:47 am Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:
> Well, lets put it this way, you're heading straight for more than one
> logical fallacy when you confuse "muslims" and "pakistanis"
LOL. There is no easy escape here sir. Are you saying that the BJP/RSS do not
hate Muslims?. Is tha
ss [19/07/11 06:50 +0530]:
1. If Pakistani politicians hate India, is there anything wrong in Indian
polticians hating Muslims? Are they not valid political viewpoints that must
be put to vote? Pakistanis have reasons to hate India and Indians have reasons
to hate Muslims.
Well, lets put it th
On Tuesday 19 Jul 2011 6:17:12 am Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote:
> Bharat's point is that the bjp rss crowd are indistinguishable from the
> pakistanis in their tactics of hate politics
>
> I agree
>
Please correct me if you believe I am "putting words in your mouth" - that is
words that you d
On the topic of what Pakistanis need to do to get elected, here is a Pakistani
take on Aatish Taseers article that rubbishes the idea that Pakistani
politicians need to hate India to get elected. The "hate India" is a
charcteristic, he says, of the military establishment and the faux liberals of
bject: Re: [silk] Why My Father Hated India
Sent: Jul 19, 2011 06:13
On Tuesday 19 Jul 2011 1:07:44 am Bharath Chari wrote:
> > Why would a politican in Pakistan have to say unpleasant things about
> > India to get elected? Does that translate to the inability to get elected
&
On Tuesday 19 Jul 2011 1:07:44 am Bharath Chari wrote:
> > Why would a politican in Pakistan have to say unpleasant things about
> > India to get elected? Does that translate to the inability to get elected
> > if a Pakistani politician were to say good things about India?
> >
> >
> > shiv
>
> To
On 07/18/2011 07:51 PM, ss wrote:
On Monday 18 Jul 2011 2:37:20 pm M.K.Pai wrote:
Salman Taseer, probably said what he did for public consumption. Its
difficult for a Pakistani politician to get elected unless he says
unpleasant things about India.
My My! That is odd isn't it?
Why would a po
On Monday 18 Jul 2011 2:37:20 pm M.K.Pai wrote:
> Salman Taseer, probably said what he did for public consumption. Its
> difficult for a Pakistani politician to get elected unless he says
> unpleasant things about India.
>
My My! That is odd isn't it?
Why would a politican in Pakistan have to sa
Hello,
This theme has been regurgitated in far too many fora, on the Net and off it.
IMHO, it is not worthy of the intellectual horsepower of silk-listers.
Salman Taseer, probably said what he did for public consumption. Its
difficult for a Pakistani politician to get elected unless he says
unpl
More from the same author
http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/2009/04/aatish-salmaan-taseer-punjab-
pakistan/
>“In Pakistan, the clothes people wear are much better. There’s far less
> poverty. India makes its own things, its own cars, but then you don’t get
> Land Cruisers. In India, you get Indian
On Sat, Jul 16, 2011 at 5:48 AM, Thaths wrote:
> Why My Father Hated India
> Aatish Taseer, the son of an assassinated Pakistani leader, explains
> the history and hysteria behind a deadly relationship
> By AATISH TASEER
On almost similar lines -
http://www.csmonitor.com/Commentary/Opinion/2011/
On Saturday 16 Jul 2011 5:48:05 am Thaths wrote:
> Pakistan had better roads, better cars; Pakistani businesses were
> thriving; its citizens could take foreign currency abroad. Compared
> with starving, socialist India, they were on much surer ground. So
> what if India had democracy? It had broug
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304911104576445862242908294.html#printMode
Why My Father Hated India
Aatish Taseer, the son of an assassinated Pakistani leader, explains
the history and hysteria behind a deadly relationship
By AATISH TASEER
Ten days before he was assassinated in Jan
26 matches
Mail list logo
