Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-11 Thread Dave Cridland
On Thu Dec 11 10:28:40 2008, Jehan wrote: Hum... I would consider that it would be interesting to know if a server can store my bookmarks. On the other side, if the server wants to send notifications of an updated bookmark, I would think it is interesting that it sends it only to significant c

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-11 Thread Jehan
Dave Cridland;5522 Wrote: > > Only those intended to be discoverable should be listed there. Some > aren't, Bookmarks being one of them. > Hum... I would consider that it would be interesting to know if a server can store my bookmarks. On the other side, if the server wants to send notificat

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-11 Thread Dave Cridland
On Thu Dec 11 00:17:44 2008, Jehan wrote: But then, what if (even if it should never happen!) the other entity set some other "node" value which is not yours? 1/ Should you anyway answer, and you give again the right node value in your result query? No. That would be against XEP-0030. 2/

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-11 Thread Dave Cridland
On Thu Dec 11 01:00:44 2008, Jehan wrote: in the list of disco features ( http://xmpp.org/registrar/disco-features.html ), are we supposed to have every proposed namespace? Because I don't find for instance "XEP-0168: Resource Application Priority" ('urn:xmpp:rap:0' and 'urn:xmpp:raproute:0'

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jehan
Hi, Hop again about this caps XEP (sorry!). in the list of disco features ( http://xmpp.org/registrar/disco-features.html ), are we supposed to have every proposed namespace? Because I don't find for instance "XEP-0168: Resource Application Priority" ('urn:xmpp:rap:0' and 'urn:xmpp:raproute:0')

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jehan
Hi, still about to this same XEP, during implementation, I came to a new question. In the service discovery request (the one to associate a list of features to a node), there is the "node" attribute. This attribute can have only a single value to be consistent: the one you set in the 'c' attribut

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jehan
Hi, Dave Cridland;5492 Wrote: > > This message is the only one in my mailbox with this subject - maybe > I'm missing your earlier one. > Here is my first message: Jehan;5452 Wrote: > Hi, > > I was rereading lately the XEP-0115 and one strange point strikes me > (aïe!) in section "5.4 Pro

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jehan
Remko Tronçon;5491 Wrote: > > 6.2 is about how caps information relates to the actual result of disco > info. > 7 describes what things you should advertise to announce your support > for XEP-115. Every XEP has a section on what namespaces it uses. This > one is just an edge case because you ca

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Dave Cridland
On Wed Dec 10 12:59:32 2008, Jehan wrote: Hi, no feedback on this? Noone is interested? :-( On the same XEP, I have other interrogations/remarks. This message is the only one in my mailbox with this subject - maybe I'm missing your earlier one. Aren't section "6.2 Discovering Capabil

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Remko Tronçon
> Aren't section "6.2 Discovering Capabilities" and "7. Determining > Support" nearly the same? 6.2 is about how caps information relates to the actual result of disco info. 7 describes what things you should advertise to announce your support for XEP-115. Every XEP has a section on what namespace

Re: [Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jehan
Hi, no feedback on this? Noone is interested? :-( On the same XEP, I have other interrogations/remarks. Aren't section "6.2 Discovering Capabilities" and "7. Determining Support" nearly the same? I understand that the separation is mostly to make the difference between the case where there is a

[Standards] Missing point in XEP-0115: Entity Capabilities ?

2008-12-05 Thread Jehan
Hi, I was rereading lately the XEP-0115 and one strange point strikes me (aïe!) in section "5.4 Processing Method". It seems explained that whether you know or not the sent entity capability verification string "ver", you send anyway a service discovery stanza to the generating entity! Consideri