RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-21 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
ot putting out some Struts's concepts I was missing. José. > -Original Message- > From: PILGRIM, Peter, FM [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Thursday, February 20, 2003 6:49 PM > To: 'Struts Users Mailing List' > Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- Ac

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-20 Thread PILGRIM, Peter, FM
> -Original Message- > From: NYIMI Jose (BMB) [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: 17 February 2003 14:37 > To: Struts Users Mailing List > Subject: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects > > > Dear Struts Users, > > I have just bought this book : "Expert one-one-one

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Marco Tedone
I would say DTO -Original Message- From: NYIMI Jose (BMB) [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 5:35 PM To: Struts Users Mailing List Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects Rod Johnson: "The idea of copying properties fr

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Marco Tedone
s are not true domain objects On Mon, 17 Feb 2003, Chris Halverson wrote: > Date: Mon, 17 Feb 2003 09:16:01 -0600 > From: Chris Halverson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Reply-To: Struts Users Mailing List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: Struts Users Mailing List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Robert S. Sfeir
On Monday, Feb 17, 2003, at 13:04 US/Eastern, John Cavacas wrote: Struts is great for what it does, and Rods Spring Framework also seems great at what it does. There are also flaws in both Struts and Spring. But that's the beauty and simplicity of all of this. If you don't like something, don

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
It's 19h22 in Belgium : time for me to go home :-) Thanks for your input ... Soon ? José. DISCLAIMER "This e-mail and any attachment thereto may contain information which is confidential and/or protected by intellectual property rights and are intended for the sole use of the reci

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread John Cavacas
> I think Rod makes a common mistake in believing Struts is suppose to act > as the base of your domain architecture. Struts is a presentation layer" > controller. Sophisticated applications will also need their own *domain > layer* controller. [John Cavacas] I have to disagree with that statement

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Craig R. McClanahan
> * Thus a Struts ActionForm is not a true domain object. Definitely true -- ActionForm is a view tier object, used (by the framework, not the application) to maintain the server-side state of input fields on an HTML form. Trying to treat it as a domain object is a misuse of Struts, and vio

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Robert McIntosh
Touche... Of course I have to shamelessly plug our domain layer framework, eQ!(www.browsersoft.com/eQ) :-) One of the goals is to be UI independant, as well as deployment independant (app server, client-server, standalone), but we also provide adapters for Swing and of course Struts. If we had

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread David Graham
"Validation code shouldn't be contained in web-tier controllers or any objects unique to the web tier. This allows the reuse of validation objects for other client types". You can perform absolutely no validation in the Struts web tier if you choose. Validate wherever you like; Struts provides

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Brandon Goodin
Monday, February 17, 2003 10:10 AM To: Struts Users Mailing List Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects > True data binding is generally inflexible and troublesome. > Having come > from the VB world many years ago, and its data binding way of doing >

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
Rod Johnson: "The idea of copying properties from an action form to business command is inelegant and there is no support for type checking." Was there so far an around solution ? José. DISCLAIMER "This e-mail and any attachment thereto may contain information which is confidential

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
Rod Johnson: "The idea of copying properties from an action form to business command is inelegant and there is o support for type checking." Was there so far an around solution ? José. DISCLAIMER "This e-mail and any attachment thereto may contain information which is confidential

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Craig R. McClanahan
On Mon, 17 Feb 2003, Chris Halverson wrote: > Date: Mon, 17 Feb 2003 09:16:01 -0600 > From: Chris Halverson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Reply-To: Struts Users Mailing List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: Struts Users Mailing List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Subject: Re: Struts d

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Robert McIntosh
NYIMI Jose (BMB) wrote: True data binding is generally inflexible and troublesome. Having come from the VB world many years ago, and its data binding way of doing things, I can say that I can't stand it. Having a middle ground creates more opportunities and power than not having it. I know

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
> True data binding is generally inflexible and troublesome. > Having come > from the VB world many years ago, and its data binding way of doing > things, I can say that I can't stand it. Having a middle > ground creates > more opportunities and power than not having it. I know some > who sti

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Robert McIntosh
NYIMI Jose (BMB) wrote: -Original Message- From: Robert Taylor [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 4:35 PM To: Struts Users Mailing List Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects If you use any flavor of DynaForms, you can

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread John Espey
any light on that argument. > -Original Message- > From: David Graham [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 9:31 AM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain > objects > > > It's n

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
> -Original Message- > From: Robert Taylor [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 4:35 PM > To: Struts Users Mailing List > Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true > domain objects > > > If you use any flavor of Dyna

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Robert Taylor
onForms are not true domain > objects > > > > -Original Message- > > From: David Graham [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 3:55 PM > > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Subject: Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true >

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread David Graham
ply-To: "Struts Users Mailing List" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Struts Users Mailing List" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects Date: Mon, 17 Feb 2003 09:18:08 -0600 i think the argument isn't about it

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread David Graham
Is there any plan to move ActionForms to true domain objects ? No. See past developer and user list discussions on this topic. > Struts uses too many > concrete base classes. We will be working to use more > interfaces over time. Any idea on when or version ? Because introducing interfac

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread David Graham
L PROTECTED]> Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects Date: Mon, 17 Feb 2003 09:10:48 -0600 > -Original Message- > From: David Graham [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 8:55 AM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sub

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread James Childers
> -Original Message- > From: Chris Halverson [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 9:16 AM > To: Struts Users Mailing List > Subject: Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain > objects > > > "James Childers" &

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread John Espey
sers Mailing List > Subject: RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain > objects > > > > > > -Original Message- > > From: David Graham [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 8:55 AM > > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread Chris Halverson
"James Childers" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > You can't really use that outside of a servlet container. This is > not a knock to Struts; it was never designed to be a general purpose > MVC model. But noone is going to write a Swing app using Struts, for > example. http://javaboutique.internet.co

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread NYIMI Jose (BMB)
> -Original Message- > From: David Graham [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 3:55 PM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true > domain objects > > > The author correctly states th

RE: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread James Childers
> -Original Message- > From: David Graham [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Monday, February 17, 2003 8:55 AM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain > objects > > However, Struts is not "too JS

Re: Struts design flaw -- ActionForms are not true domain objects

2003-02-17 Thread David Graham
The author correctly states that ActionForms are not true domain objects. This is intentional. He also correctly points out that Struts uses too many concrete base classes. We will be working to use more interfaces over time. However, Struts is not "too JSP oriented". JSP is the most popular