Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Jarek Piórkowski
On Thu, 16 Jul 2020 at 11:30, Andrew Deng via Talk-ca wrote: > Hello, I believe Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region (Regional Road 1) > should be tagged as highway=primary rather than highway=secondary as it is > tagged now. > Here are some reasons I believe why: > 1) Yonge Street is

[Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Andrew Deng via Talk-ca
Hello, I believe Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region (Regional Road 1) should be tagged as highway=primary rather than highway=secondary as it is tagged now. Here are some reasons I believe why: 1) Yonge Street is considered the "Main Street" of Toronto, Thornhill, Richmond Hill, and

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Justin Tracey
In Canada, highway=primary is typically used for what I would call "highway-like" roads.[0] IMHO, Yonge is a "major" road, but has too many cross streets to be really considered highway-like, at least for most of its length. You can look at some of the other highway=primary roads in the area to

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Kevin Farrugia
Hey Andrew, I'm in agreement with Justin. I think it's too urban a road, with urban speed limits along almost its entire length and many traffic lights. I definitely wouldn't consider the part of Yonge through downtown Toronto (or most of Toronto for that matter) to be Primary, with truck

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Andrew Deng via Talk-ca
I thought the tagging would be similar to the US, where roads are tagged based on its traffic volume and importance which is why I thought Yonge should be Primary. I see now. --   Andrew Student On Thursday, July 16, 2020, 08:31:48 p.m. EDT, Kevin Farrugia wrote: Hey Andrew, I'm in

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Kevin Farrugia
Yeah, it changes from place to place and what has historically been the standard. I'm not against changing the standard, maybe we just need a better or updated definition for what can be a primary road in Ontario. Perhaps we make some standards for the heavily urbanised areas of Ontario where