[Talk-gb-westmidlands] November meeting

2014-11-04 Thread Brian Prangle
Don't forget we're back to our usual haunt for this Thursday Nov 6th at the Bull on Price Street Birmingham Rgds Brian ___ Talk-gb-westmidlands mailing list Talk-gb-westmidlands@openstreetmap.org

Re: [Talk-gb-westmidlands] November meeting

2014-11-04 Thread Andy Robinson
I’ll be there but I’m attending the Cycle Forum in Margaret Street first so I won’t get to the Bull until after 8pm. Cheers Andy From: Brian Prangle [mailto:bpran...@gmail.com] Sent: 04 November 2014 18:28 To: talk-gb-westmidlands Subject: [Talk-gb-westmidlands] November meeting

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Dan S
2014-11-03 23:35 GMT+00:00 Matthijs Melissen i...@matthijsmelissen.nl: On 2 November 2014 16:11, Andy Street a...@street.me.uk wrote: On Sun, 2 Nov 2014 13:24:46 + Matthijs Melissen i...@matthijsmelissen.nl wrote: - 'Brantano Footwear' versus Brantano Whilst company names do not

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Ed Loach
Are there still objections against Brantano? Yes. It says Brantano Footwear as the name on the sign on at least the two nearest stores to me. I have no objections to brand or operator being Brantano, but not the name field. Ed ___ Talk-GB mailing

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Philip Barnes
On Mon, 2014-11-03 at 23:35 +, Matthijs Melissen wrote: On 2 November 2014 16:11, Andy Street a...@street.me.uk wrote: On Sun, 2 Nov 2014 13:24:46 + Matthijs Melissen i...@matthijsmelissen.nl wrote: - 'Brantano Footwear' versus Brantano Whilst company names do not necessarily

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Ed Loach
In the late 70s, early 80s when ADSA arrived as the new kid on the block, everyone seemed to know it was short for Associated Dairies, but that has probably long since been forgotten. Regarding ASDA, I was following one of their delivery vans yesterday and noticed all occurrences of their

Re: [Talk-GB] Voting mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Richard Fairhurst
Matthijs Melissen wrote: I therefore think inviting list members to vote in order to make the position of the community explicit - in addition to taking comments on the mailing list into account, not as a replacement of it - is the safest way to proceed. On reflection, it would be more

Re: [Talk-GB] Voting mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Dan S
2014-11-04 15:20 GMT+00:00 Richard Fairhurst rich...@systemed.net: Matthijs Melissen wrote: I therefore think inviting list members to vote in order to make the position of the community explicit - in addition to taking comments on the mailing list into account, not as a replacement of it -

Re: [Talk-GB] Voting mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Matthijs Melissen
On 4 November 2014 15:20, Richard Fairhurst rich...@systemed.net wrote: On reflection, it would be more helpful, and less controversial, if you were to describe this process as a poll rather than a vote. That's a good suggestion, I think the word 'poll' better expresses what the intention is. I

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Matthijs Melissen
On 4 November 2014 10:25, Ed Loach edlo...@gmail.com wrote: Are there still objections against Brantano? Yes. It says Brantano Footwear as the name on the sign on at least the two nearest stores to me. I have no objections to brand or operator being Brantano, but not the name field. As I

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Matthijs Melissen
On 4 November 2014 12:55, Philip Barnes p...@trigpoint.me.uk wrote: ALDI, LIDL, ASDA and SPAR are all abbreviations of their full names, in the same way as NATO, AIDS, BBC, OSM or GNU are. Whether Spar is an abbreviation is doubtful. Spar is Dutch for spruce (a species of tree), hence the logo.

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Lester Caine
On 04/11/14 17:19, Matthijs Melissen wrote: On 4 November 2014 10:25, Ed Loach edlo...@gmail.com wrote: Are there still objections against Brantano? Yes. It says Brantano Footwear as the name on the sign on at least the two nearest stores to me. I have no objections to brand or operator

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Philip Barnes
On Tue, 2014-11-04 at 17:29 +, Matthijs Melissen wrote: On 4 November 2014 12:55, Philip Barnes p...@trigpoint.me.uk wrote: ALDI, LIDL, ASDA and SPAR are all abbreviations of their full names, in the same way as NATO, AIDS, BBC, OSM or GNU are. Whether Spar is an abbreviation is

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Matthijs Melissen
On 4 November 2014 18:55, Philip Barnes p...@trigpoint.me.uk wrote: According to wikipedia SPAR is an acronym of Door Eendrachtig Samenwerken Profiteren Allen Regelmatig, although the DE has been dropped. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spar_(retailer)#Etymology Yes, but according to the

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Andy Street
On Tue, 04 Nov 2014 18:49:44 + Lester Caine les...@lsces.co.uk wrote: The 'name' is 'Brantano Footwear' unless there IS something different on the signage, and the 'operator' is 'Brantano (UK) Ltd'. Trade marks appear to use Brantano rather than Brantano Footwear:

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread David Woolley
On 04/11/14 17:19, Matthijs Melissen wrote: So the question is - what makes you think that 'Footwear' is part of the name, rather than a description of the products they sell? The 7,510 Google hits for '+site:brantano.co.uk brantano footwear', for as start, including their TCs page. The

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread David Woolley
On 04/11/14 12:55, Philip Barnes wrote: ALDI, LIDL, ASDA and SPAR are all abbreviations of their full names, in the same way as NATO, AIDS, BBC, OSM or GNU are. BBC is an initialism, so should be in uppercase. The rest of treated as acronyms. To the extent that they are trademarks, they may

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Lester Caine
On 04/11/14 20:01, Andy Street wrote: The 'name' is 'Brantano Footwear' unless there IS something different on the signage, and the 'operator' is 'Brantano (UK) Ltd'. Trade marks appear to use Brantano rather than Brantano Footwear: http://www.ipo.gov.uk/tmtext.htm I'd avoid using

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Colin Smale
Hang on a minute... the name tag should contain the most common name, or, as the wiki puts it, the common default name. There are other tags for enthousiasts to store official names, legal names, alternate names, brands, operators etc which, in a certain frame of reference, can also be correct

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Chris Hill
On 04/11/14 22:04, Colin Smale wrote: Hang on a minute... the name tag should contain the most common name, or, as the wiki puts it, the common default name. There are other tags for enthousiasts to store official names, legal names, alternate names, brands, operators etc which, in a certain

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Colin Smale
What is right is a subjective judgement, that's the whole discussion, surely? And the ground truth paradigm isn't absolute, otherwise we would have name=HIGH ST. as has been mentioned before. If two parties have different answers yet both insist they are right, you should look again at the

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Matthijs Melissen
On 4 November 2014 22:17, Chris Hill o...@raggedred.net wrote: I would write what it says on the sign on the shop. That's why I tag ASDA as ASDA, that's what it says on the sign. I don't look at their website, their advertising or their letter heads. I use ground truth. I'm not a trademark

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Lester Caine
On 04/11/14 22:04, Colin Smale wrote: Hang on a minute... the name tag should contain the most common name, or, as the wiki puts it, the common default name. Totally Agree Colin ... The name tag should not be subjected to a 'mechanical edit' to change what has been entered by a local mapper, so

Re: [Talk-GB] RFC-2 mechanical edit: UK shop names

2014-11-04 Thread Colin Smale
I'm glad you say you agree Lester, but to me, the words common default name imply some level of consensus, not the subjective opinion of an individual mapper. I see issues here which we should not conflate; on the contrary, we should address them in order, as they form a hierarchy. Firstly,