Re: [Talk-us] Extremely long Amtrak route relations

2020-11-21 Thread Brian M. Sperlongano
It seems that OSM has a an architectural problem with over-large relations? > +1 The Tongass National Forest [1] was recently mapped with great detail. It comprises most of the Alaska panhandle and all of its islands and inlets. The relation has 28,000 members and contains over 2 million nodes.

Re: [Talk-us] Extremely long Amtrak route relations

2020-11-21 Thread Ray Kiddy
It seems that OSM has a an architectural problem with over-large relations? Is modifying the relations in potentially arbitrary ways a good solution? Seeking something that may work now, can any "size-based" relation splits be done in a way that they can be automatically removed at some

[Talk-us] Extremely long Amtrak route relations

2020-11-21 Thread Clay Smalley
I posted this on the Slack but I figured I should put this on the mailing list to make sure it reaches everybody: Many long-distance Amtrak trains have route relations with 1000+ members. If I split one way that happens to be a member of one of these routes, I end up with a changeset with a